WEBVTT

1
00:00:04.090 --> 00:00:08.000
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we're ready to begin whenever you are. Okay.

2
00:00:08.650 --> 00:00:10.439
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, everybody.

3
00:00:10.660 --> 00:00:29.579
City of El Cerrito: Today is, April 21st, 2026, special City Council meeting. The time is 6.03. Madam, City Clerk, please call roll. Thank you, Mayor, and just to clarify, this is the start of the regular City Council meeting. Mayor Kinto? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Saltzman?

4
00:00:29.600 --> 00:00:35.680
City of El Cerrito: Councilmember Quetzanes? Here. Councilmember Mochiyama? Here. Councilmember Weisinger? Here. We have a quorum.

5
00:00:35.720 --> 00:00:38.349
City of El Cerrito: Please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance.

6
00:00:41.060 --> 00:00:45.879
City of El Cerrito: I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

7
00:00:46.060 --> 00:00:54.480
City of El Cerrito: And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

8
00:01:04.590 --> 00:01:08.580
City of El Cerrito: Phantom City Clerk teleconference and public comment instructions.

9
00:01:08.950 --> 00:01:23.669
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor. This hybrid meeting provides an option to participate in person or via Zoom with closed captions available. As with our prior meeting, we are still meeting… waiting on one piece of equipment, so this meeting will not be livestreamed or broadcast on our website.

10
00:01:23.680 --> 00:01:39.930
City of El Cerrito: But it will be recorded via Zoom. Meetings of the City Council are subject to the Brown Act and are held for the purpose of conducting city business. The Brown Act ensures the public's right to be heard, and while City Council may not respond to your comments directly, your comments will be heard prior to Council taking action.

11
00:01:40.030 --> 00:01:51.150
City of El Cerrito: For members of the public who wish to provide oral testimony, the Mayor will announce the time for public comment on each applicable item. A request to speak can be submitted to the City Clerk by completing a speaker card.

12
00:01:51.350 --> 00:02:08.269
City of El Cerrito: A request can be, done virtually by selecting the raise hand feature on Zoom, or by dialing star 9 if calling in. In-person speakers will be heard first. The Council's adopted Rules of Order and Procedure specify that public speakers address the City Council in an orderly and respectful manner.

13
00:02:08.270 --> 00:02:12.670
City of El Cerrito: Proceed their comments with their name and city of residence, and be respectful of time limits.

14
00:02:12.670 --> 00:02:20.429
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor. That concludes my announcement. Okay, thank you very much. We'll go to, Council and Staff Communications, City Manager Karen Pickup.

15
00:02:26.840 --> 00:02:32.400
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Your Honor. I would actually like to call up Christina Laird to provide staff communications tonight.

16
00:02:37.170 --> 00:02:49.969
City of El Cerrito: Okay, good evening, Mayor Kinto and Council members. Christina Laird, Acting Senior Management Analyst in the Public Works Department. Just wanted to give you a brief update on our Earth Day activities that's coming up this Saturday.

17
00:02:50.150 --> 00:02:53.530
City of El Cerrito: So that we're excited to host,

18
00:02:53.750 --> 00:03:11.080
City of El Cerrito: Work parties again this year, as we do every year, from 9am to 12. There'll be various work parties. I think we have 8 work parties throughout the city this year. Anyone can go join a work party. You can find the details on our website at elseerrito.gov slash earthday.

19
00:03:11.330 --> 00:03:17.799
City of El Cerrito: And then additionally to work parties, we are having a prepare workshop at the community center.

20
00:03:18.060 --> 00:03:29.730
City of El Cerrito: That will be from 1 to 4 p.m. on Saturday. And, we'll have repair coaches there, helping residents repair any kind of broken item. We have,

21
00:03:30.170 --> 00:03:37.870
City of El Cerrito: And, coaches there for jewelry, for clothing, sewing, anything that needs mending, as well as your household goods and electronics.

22
00:03:37.890 --> 00:03:49.360
City of El Cerrito: And we're gonna have the El Cerrito, the ECRU artist, the Creative Artists in Reuse. They'll be doing activities in the community center as well for the children, some crafts.

23
00:03:49.360 --> 00:04:00.390
City of El Cerrito: And then, additionally, out in the outdoor patio space, we're gonna have a bunch of community organizations tabling. So some of the community groups include…

24
00:04:00.650 --> 00:04:03.120
City of El Cerrito: Recycle More, our partners.

25
00:04:03.260 --> 00:04:19.400
City of El Cerrito: As well as MCE, ECRA Walk and Roll, 511, I'm sorry, 511 couldn't make it. We'll have 350 Contra Costa, Citizens Climate Lobby, the, El Cerrito Garden Club,

26
00:04:19.459 --> 00:04:35.510
City of El Cerrito: As well as Sustainable Contra Costa. And so, and the Urban Forest Committee will also be there. So we welcome anybody who would love to attend this event, and please share with your neighbors and your friends who want to attend, get some more information, or have anything repaired.

27
00:04:36.110 --> 00:04:37.100
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

28
00:04:37.790 --> 00:04:45.279
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much. And that's all I have, Your Honor. Thank you. Okay, thank you very much. Any, communications that you'd like to report here?

29
00:04:45.470 --> 00:04:46.970
City of El Cerrito: I'll start on my lap.

30
00:04:48.610 --> 00:04:49.860
City of El Cerrito: Am I right, Aaron?

31
00:04:50.240 --> 00:04:53.530
City of El Cerrito: I just want to announce that,

32
00:04:54.470 --> 00:05:13.499
City of El Cerrito: I did attend the San Francisco Climate Week over the weekend and had a chance to speak on electrification and what cities and counties are doing, and it was a local city's perspective. As mayor of El Cerrito, I was joined by

33
00:05:13.590 --> 00:05:20.359
City of El Cerrito: Councilmember Igor Tregoop in Berkeley, as well as Councilmember Wang in Oakland.

34
00:05:20.380 --> 00:05:28.610
City of El Cerrito: and our BART Board Director, Barnali Ghosh, as well as a county supervisor in Mendocino. So.

35
00:05:28.610 --> 00:05:45.959
City of El Cerrito: stay tuned on the things that we'll be working on. As a member of the Air Board, we will be discussing, a lot of the things dealing with, the new rule changes that are coming up, so do attend our meeting. We're,

36
00:05:45.980 --> 00:05:49.790
City of El Cerrito: live, via, Zoom.

37
00:05:49.860 --> 00:05:56.080
City of El Cerrito: So if you look at the Bay Area Air District, you'll see the, schedule. We meet.

38
00:05:56.190 --> 00:06:00.149
City of El Cerrito: On the first Wednesdays of the month, starting at 10 o'clock.

39
00:06:00.320 --> 00:06:06.549
City of El Cerrito: And, next we will do, oral communications from the public.

40
00:06:06.830 --> 00:06:11.909
City of El Cerrito: Now is the time for members of the public who wish to provide public comments regarding

41
00:06:12.020 --> 00:06:30.209
City of El Cerrito: matters not on the agenda, consent items, and presentation items. Requests to speak can be submitted to the City Clerk by completing the speaker card using the raise hand feature on the Zoom, or dialing 9 if joining by phone. The person requests to be taken

42
00:06:30.420 --> 00:06:38.999
City of El Cerrito: In-person requests will be taken first. Please remember to identify yourself and your City of Residence at the beginning of your comments. Madam City Clerk.

43
00:06:39.160 --> 00:06:49.259
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor. Before we begin, I just want to, let you know we have a total of 34 speakers signed up currently amongst all of our items tonight.

44
00:06:49.260 --> 00:07:07.520
City of El Cerrito: That's not including any virtual speakers that may come up later. If the mayor would like to implement the council waterfall policy for, reducing speaker times, that is at your discretion. This item, we have 9 requests to speak. Most of the speakers are signed up for item 8A.

45
00:07:07.790 --> 00:07:24.219
City of El Cerrito: The threshold to reduce from 3 minutes to 2 minutes is more than 11 speakers, and then down to 1 minute for over 21 speakers. So, if you could confirm what you would like to do for this item, where we currently have 9 speakers signed up to speak.

46
00:07:24.480 --> 00:07:28.280
City of El Cerrito: Let's do, 2 minutes. Okay.

47
00:07:38.580 --> 00:07:39.660
City of El Cerrito: Okay…

48
00:07:39.850 --> 00:07:49.010
City of El Cerrito: All right, so with that, we will start with our request… our in-person request to speak, going first to Michael Fisher, followed by James Silvey.

49
00:07:54.350 --> 00:07:58.779
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, and members of the Council.

50
00:07:58.930 --> 00:08:06.629
City of El Cerrito: My name is Michael Fisher, I live in El Cerrito, and I have lived for more than 82 years.

51
00:08:07.120 --> 00:08:11.290
City of El Cerrito: I emphasize that to note that I am a senior.

52
00:08:11.640 --> 00:08:18.799
City of El Cerrito: Maybe not quite as senior as our wonderful centenarian Plus, who we celebrated last meeting.

53
00:08:19.070 --> 00:08:21.320
City of El Cerrito: But definitely a senior.

54
00:08:22.210 --> 00:08:28.859
City of El Cerrito: Many of my fellow El Suritans working in support of Measure C are also seniors.

55
00:08:29.920 --> 00:08:34.120
City of El Cerrito: I am one of the small group that wrote Measure C.

56
00:08:34.549 --> 00:08:38.539
City of El Cerrito: I wanted an appropriate senior exemption.

57
00:08:38.679 --> 00:08:44.069
City of El Cerrito: And we use the same language as other El Cerrito tax measures.

58
00:08:44.900 --> 00:08:50.169
City of El Cerrito: For the first time for any such measures, opponents have raised an issue.

59
00:08:50.550 --> 00:08:56.250
City of El Cerrito: And as noted, this issue has… This issue is…

60
00:08:57.940 --> 00:09:02.300
City of El Cerrito: On the, consent agenda tonight.

61
00:09:02.940 --> 00:09:09.739
City of El Cerrito: To provide for significant increases in eligibility for the exemption.

62
00:09:10.730 --> 00:09:16.220
City of El Cerrito: It does make me worry that this item has come up.

63
00:09:16.350 --> 00:09:19.480
City of El Cerrito: I'm glad the Council's going to fix it.

64
00:09:21.130 --> 00:09:31.619
City of El Cerrito: The Council has the extension And it provides an increase in the senior exemption in three ways.

65
00:09:32.090 --> 00:09:39.740
City of El Cerrito: One, The measure eliminates the tax for those qualifying, rather than postpones it.

66
00:09:40.480 --> 00:09:41.370
City of El Cerrito: True.

67
00:09:41.750 --> 00:09:50.040
City of El Cerrito: There is no requirement that the owner have at least a 40% equity in their property.

68
00:09:50.410 --> 00:09:58.969
City of El Cerrito: And there is no requirement that the property not be subject to a reverse mortgage. Thank you for your comments.

69
00:09:59.390 --> 00:10:02.809
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is James Silvey, followed by Charles Taylor.

70
00:10:08.230 --> 00:10:11.200
City of El Cerrito: Hello, thank you for the opportunity to speak here.

71
00:10:11.610 --> 00:10:18.429
City of El Cerrito: I'm commenting because I believe… oh, sorry, first name. James Silvey. I am a resident of El Cerrito.

72
00:10:19.880 --> 00:10:26.050
City of El Cerrito: I'm commenting here today because I strongly believe that El Cerrito needs to invest in its future.

73
00:10:26.380 --> 00:10:32.830
City of El Cerrito: We can't keep kicking the can down the road like we have in the past, and that's why I strongly support Measure C.

74
00:10:33.510 --> 00:10:36.940
City of El Cerrito: Measure C is a clean, straightforward funding measure.

75
00:10:37.250 --> 00:10:40.110
City of El Cerrito: The money raised by the measure is put into a special fund.

76
00:10:40.270 --> 00:10:42.330
City of El Cerrito: And it can only go toward the library.

77
00:10:42.820 --> 00:10:51.650
City of El Cerrito: If we want to renovate the library, build a new library, or even secure fund-matching grants, it starts with us building those funds first.

78
00:10:53.060 --> 00:10:57.359
City of El Cerrito: My concern is that many folks believe that we should continue to wait instead.

79
00:10:58.130 --> 00:11:01.650
City of El Cerrito: They claim that it's just this particular measure they don't support.

80
00:11:01.950 --> 00:11:06.060
City of El Cerrito: But there are no alternative measures or proposals put forward by this group.

81
00:11:06.890 --> 00:11:11.929
City of El Cerrito: There are no solid ideas on where the funding will come from if this measure doesn't pass.

82
00:11:12.080 --> 00:11:15.709
City of El Cerrito: We'd be left waiting again, with no progress made.

83
00:11:16.190 --> 00:11:19.990
City of El Cerrito: There's never gonna be a magic solution to the funding.

84
00:11:20.370 --> 00:11:23.590
City of El Cerrito: The longer we wait, the more it's going to cost.

85
00:11:23.820 --> 00:11:28.110
City of El Cerrito: Compare the cost of building anything now to the cost 10 years ago.

86
00:11:28.560 --> 00:11:34.110
City of El Cerrito: We're only cheating ourselves and future generations if we delay this further than it already has been.

87
00:11:35.610 --> 00:11:42.200
City of El Cerrito: If you support the library and want to invest in El Cerrito's future, I believe Measure C is the right way to do that.

88
00:11:42.850 --> 00:11:44.150
City of El Cerrito: Thanks again for your time.

89
00:11:45.100 --> 00:11:49.220
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. Our next speaker is Charles Taylor, followed by Barbara Lass.

90
00:11:54.410 --> 00:11:56.029
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, Mayor Kinto.

91
00:11:57.420 --> 00:12:00.910
City of El Cerrito: Mayor Pro Tem Salzman, and the rest of the Council.

92
00:12:01.720 --> 00:12:03.200
City of El Cerrito: I'm Charles Taylor.

93
00:12:03.750 --> 00:12:09.290
City of El Cerrito: One of the proponents of the initiative for an improved new library.

94
00:12:09.410 --> 00:12:10.780
City of El Cerrito: with Measure C.

95
00:12:11.910 --> 00:12:13.920
City of El Cerrito: I am a senior citizen.

96
00:12:14.630 --> 00:12:17.860
City of El Cerrito: And have lived in El Cerrito for 42 years.

97
00:12:18.380 --> 00:12:26.010
City of El Cerrito: My wife and I raised our daughters here. One of them lives in El Cerrito and has been active in civic affairs

98
00:12:26.140 --> 00:12:28.279
City of El Cerrito: Since returning after college.

99
00:12:28.570 --> 00:12:30.499
City of El Cerrito: I also have two grandchildren.

100
00:12:30.730 --> 00:12:31.920
City of El Cerrito: in the city.

101
00:12:32.330 --> 00:12:40.049
City of El Cerrito: I'm here to speak to you regarding the proposed exemption, senior exemption, for the El Cerrito Library tax proposal.

102
00:12:40.660 --> 00:12:48.720
City of El Cerrito: When drafting the measure to fund an improved library and expanded operations, our intent…

103
00:12:48.860 --> 00:12:56.299
City of El Cerrito: was to have elderly residents in El Cerrito who were in reduced health or circumstances have relief.

104
00:12:56.550 --> 00:12:58.459
City of El Cerrito: From the full effect.

105
00:12:58.590 --> 00:13:00.100
City of El Cerrito: Of the tax measure.

106
00:13:00.880 --> 00:13:07.870
City of El Cerrito: I am glad today that the Council today is proceeding with the measure proposed in the packet. Thank you.

107
00:13:09.070 --> 00:13:12.430
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Barbara Last, followed by Eve Ma.

108
00:13:15.760 --> 00:13:33.700
City of El Cerrito: Good evening. Thank you for this opportunity to speak. My name is Barbara Lass. I'm a resident of El Cerrito, and I've lived here for over 25 years. I'm here tonight to talk about El Cerrito Trail Trekkers. We are, an official non-profit under the umbrella of the El Cerrito Community Foundation.

109
00:13:33.700 --> 00:13:40.859
City of El Cerrito: And we have tried in recent years, repeatedly, to work with the city on,

110
00:13:40.900 --> 00:13:54.439
City of El Cerrito: trail improvement projects. We are, able to provide funds, we're able to provide volunteer labor. We would like to do things like improve the, trail in Tassahara Park, make it more passable.

111
00:13:54.440 --> 00:14:13.529
City of El Cerrito: and safer. We would like to help Boy Scouts do Eagle Scout projects in which they work on the trails. We would like to have signs put up that mark where the trails are in the city so that people can use the wonderful public paths that we have. And these are just some of the things that we would like to do. We've met,

112
00:14:13.840 --> 00:14:38.779
City of El Cerrito: continued resistance from city staff about, doing these things. There's one obstacle after another. We have to have liability waivers, which I understand are important. There are meetings, there are plans, there are specifications, we do those things, and then there's something else that we have to do. Boy Scouts, even Boy Scouts, have been denied the opportunity to do volunteer work

113
00:14:38.780 --> 00:14:57.470
City of El Cerrito: for the city in cooperation with us. It seems as if the city does not want to work with its citizens who want to donate their time to these important things, such as our open space and our trails. And we really wish there was a way for us to move

114
00:14:57.470 --> 00:15:06.339
City of El Cerrito: forward, on these, these kinds of volunteer projects. The words city and citizen are very closely related.

115
00:15:06.410 --> 00:15:13.200
City of El Cerrito: It seems to us that citizens should be able to participate in improving their community. Thank you. Thank you.

116
00:15:13.640 --> 00:15:17.489
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. Our next speaker is Eve Ma, followed by Bill Barish.

117
00:15:21.650 --> 00:15:26.260
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, Mayor Quinto and El Cerrito City Council members.

118
00:15:26.260 --> 00:15:47.110
City of El Cerrito: I am here… my name is Eve Ma. I am a resident of El Cerrito, and I'm here to talk about ducks. There is a rumor going around that there's a desire to get rid of the ducks. This rumor may or may not be true, but I just wanted the City Council to know that there are people in the city that love the ducks.

119
00:15:47.110 --> 00:16:03.529
City of El Cerrito: And I got one sheet full, I could have gotten another sheet full, but I figured one sheet would get the point across, so I hope that we will not get rid of our ducks. And I'm talking about the ducks in Arlington Park. Thank you very much. Thank you.

120
00:16:04.020 --> 00:16:07.370
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Bill Barish, followed by Michael McDougal.

121
00:16:11.940 --> 00:16:17.759
City of El Cerrito: Good evening. Mayor, Council, Bill Barish, I live in El Cerrito, still.

122
00:16:19.060 --> 00:16:25.260
City of El Cerrito: the… resolution on the exemptions for Measure C.

123
00:16:25.980 --> 00:16:34.810
City of El Cerrito: Seems to be… composed of… mostly air.

124
00:16:37.060 --> 00:16:41.339
City of El Cerrito: the criteria… I'm reading from the draft of the resolution.

125
00:16:42.400 --> 00:16:49.500
City of El Cerrito: Applicants are not required to apply for or participate in these programs in order to qualify for the exemption.

126
00:16:50.220 --> 00:16:52.290
City of El Cerrito: I don't understand that wording.

127
00:16:53.770 --> 00:16:59.209
City of El Cerrito: How would you… qualify to receive an exemption that you don't

128
00:17:03.260 --> 00:17:08.240
City of El Cerrito: You can't… how would you… how would you apply to receive something that you

129
00:17:09.010 --> 00:17:21.540
City of El Cerrito: might not qualify for it. There's… it's… it's very… poorly written, And it doesn't… express The fact that they're…

130
00:17:21.950 --> 00:17:37.710
City of El Cerrito: Is really no exemption And that the Council Is trying to create something that the proponents didn't include.

131
00:17:39.010 --> 00:17:44.769
City of El Cerrito: So that I would ask that you Step back from this.

132
00:17:45.750 --> 00:17:53.649
City of El Cerrito: and figure out exactly what it is you're approving before you move forward. Thank you.

133
00:17:55.270 --> 00:17:58.540
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Michael McDougal, followed by Wade Huntley.

134
00:17:59.730 --> 00:18:09.090
City of El Cerrito: Hello, my name is Michael McDougal. I live in El Cerrito. I'm also on your financial advisory board. The reason that I'm talking here is there's the annual,

135
00:18:09.090 --> 00:18:20.540
City of El Cerrito: the quarterly fund report, is in the consent calendar, and one part of those funds is our Section 115 trust, which… wave at the people out in the

136
00:18:20.550 --> 00:18:30.449
City of El Cerrito: internets. That's, the trust where we set aside money for, paying down our liability towards, retirement.

137
00:18:30.860 --> 00:18:31.720
City of El Cerrito: Stuff.

138
00:18:32.340 --> 00:18:50.129
City of El Cerrito: One of the things… and I've… I've read, as a part of your member of your financial advisory board, I've… I've read the ACVER quite closely, and I've also reviewed our comprehensive financial policy in the last year as part of our job on… on there. One thing that I expected to see in front of the Council relating to the 115 Trust.

139
00:18:50.190 --> 00:19:09.360
City of El Cerrito: was, there's a waterfall when we have a, general fund surplus, when the expenditures in the general fund are less than the revenues in the general fund. And we did have that last year, which is fantastic, to the tune of $2.4 million. But I expected to see before the council a third of that going into the 115 trust.

140
00:19:09.360 --> 00:19:28.789
City of El Cerrito: some time, and I just think it's been… been a while, and I was… I just wanted to light a fire under, either the city or maybe the City Council to see if we could get that agendized. So, since we did have a surplus, we should see an item where it comes before you to allocate into the 115 trust. So, thank you very much.

141
00:19:28.810 --> 00:19:29.639
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

142
00:19:29.680 --> 00:19:33.639
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Wade Huntley, followed by Sherry Drobner.

143
00:19:38.000 --> 00:19:54.389
City of El Cerrito: Good evening. Thank you for entertaining our… all these comments. My name is Wade Huntley. I have been an El Cerrito resident for almost 27 years, and I am the co-president of the El Cerrito Trail Trackers. I'm here tonight to advocate on behalf of a healthier.

144
00:19:54.390 --> 00:19:59.030
City of El Cerrito: And more productive relationship between the city and groups like ours.

145
00:19:59.030 --> 00:20:22.390
City of El Cerrito: As you probably know, El Cerrito Trail Trekkers has been a non-profit organization in El Cerrito for over a decade, with a mission to sustain, improve, and utilize open space. You're probably very familiar with one of the signature achievements of this collaboration, which was the acquisition of the Madera Open Space added to the Hillside Natural Area, which is enjoyed by

146
00:20:22.390 --> 00:20:25.720
City of El Cerrito: Residents and community members, every day.

147
00:20:27.060 --> 00:20:30.500
City of El Cerrito: Recently, this engagement has become significantly more challenging.

148
00:20:31.360 --> 00:20:36.729
City of El Cerrito: We've sought to undertake several projects that would be essentially financially, costless.

149
00:20:36.930 --> 00:20:37.919
City of El Cerrito: to the city.

150
00:20:38.100 --> 00:20:43.870
City of El Cerrito: Only to face delays and resistance, sometimes unexplained, sometimes for reasons that seem dubious.

151
00:20:44.210 --> 00:20:57.459
City of El Cerrito: And these experiences, I believe, have raised doubts in the minds of many whether there remains a genuine positive will to take advantage of the ideas and energy that so many individuals in our community want to offer.

152
00:20:57.900 --> 00:21:09.090
City of El Cerrito: Others here have addressed and will address some of these concerns. Barbara talked specifically about a couple of the projects. Some of these issues will be mentioned again in your discussions of the budget issues later in this meeting.

153
00:21:09.770 --> 00:21:27.759
City of El Cerrito: So I would like to simply conclude on a somewhat broader note. Some believe that the only role for the public in governance is to show up for elections every once in a while, and otherwise let the city run the administration like a corporation. I believe that local governments can be more than that.

154
00:21:27.960 --> 00:21:31.980
City of El Cerrito: That it can be a place to unleash the public spirit, and build a community.

155
00:21:32.180 --> 00:21:33.210
City of El Cerrito: It turned…

156
00:21:34.040 --> 00:21:45.640
City of El Cerrito: ourselves into a sum that is greater than the… than the addition of the… of the people who happen to live here. Thank you for your comments. Thank you very much. Our next speaker is Sherry Dropner, and then we'll go to our virtual requests.

157
00:21:48.880 --> 00:21:54.699
City of El Cerrito: Hi, my name's Sherry Dropner. I've been in El Cerrito for probably 27 years also.

158
00:21:54.930 --> 00:22:07.489
City of El Cerrito: I just wanted to share information tonight. It's more of regional nature, but I think it has an impact for all of you up front in the diocese, and all of everyone behind me, and people on Zoom.

159
00:22:07.540 --> 00:22:15.909
City of El Cerrito: I was at a meeting on Sunday with about 500 other folks, and it was a meeting to discuss our airport.

160
00:22:16.080 --> 00:22:23.909
City of El Cerrito: The fact that our airport in Oakland is sending military weapons directly to Israel on a regular basis.

161
00:22:23.920 --> 00:22:39.200
City of El Cerrito: And these are weapons that we actually are paying for with our tax dollars, as we painfully know. And we can do something about that, and we could do something about that individually, we could do something about that.

162
00:22:39.320 --> 00:22:42.799
City of El Cerrito: Collectively, but I really want to make sure the people

163
00:22:42.810 --> 00:22:53.869
City of El Cerrito: have the information, because once you have the information, you can't unhave it. You can decide what you want to do with it. So I'm hoping that people will do something with it.

164
00:22:53.870 --> 00:23:07.100
City of El Cerrito: There is a campaign, it's called the Oakland People's Arms Embargo, and even though it says Oakland, it really is regional for all of us. Thank you. And, that's all I'd like to say tonight on this issue. Thank you.

165
00:23:08.840 --> 00:23:23.270
City of El Cerrito: Okay, I'm just, briefly gonna ask the audience to please not have any audible agreement or disagreement so everyone feels comfortable sharing their, their comments tonight. I'm gonna go to our, virtual request to speak.

166
00:23:24.280 --> 00:23:27.540
City of El Cerrito: I already should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

167
00:23:29.540 --> 00:23:32.240
ira: Irish Aranel, El Cerrito. Can you hear me?

168
00:23:33.240 --> 00:23:36.780
City of El Cerrito: Yes, but barely. If you could try and speak up a little bit, please.

169
00:23:36.940 --> 00:23:43.030
ira: Okay, here is what I would like to see included if the city chooses to be transparent.

170
00:23:43.550 --> 00:23:49.929
ira: Right now, I feel there's an extreme lack of transparency as it relates to the parcel tax proposal.

171
00:23:50.570 --> 00:23:56.319
ira: Explain why the cost increased from $21 million to $37 million.

172
00:23:56.600 --> 00:23:59.980
ira: Will building at the plaza still save $10 million?

173
00:24:00.560 --> 00:24:03.249
ira: Release the data on potential revenue.

174
00:24:03.860 --> 00:24:11.970
ira: clearly explain to the public that tax collections will begin in December 2026, and that there is no end date.

175
00:24:12.140 --> 00:24:17.669
ira: The clock does not start until the bonds are sold, and the bonds may never be sold.

176
00:24:18.210 --> 00:24:20.550
ira: Release the parking management plan.

177
00:24:21.000 --> 00:24:29.729
ira: Given that the tax will likely not cover both bond payments and operating costs, explain which programs the Council intends to cut.

178
00:24:30.110 --> 00:24:35.439
ira: Will you close a fire station, lay off police, or close the swim center?

179
00:24:36.140 --> 00:24:46.380
ira: Also worth noting, the San Rafael language that forms the basis of El Cerrito's tax proposal specifically excludes paying city employees.

180
00:24:46.670 --> 00:24:49.879
ira: That language is noticeably absent from Measure C.

181
00:24:50.430 --> 00:24:55.549
ira: As far as I can tell, there are no published detailed plans on how parcel

182
00:24:55.670 --> 00:24:57.990
ira: Sea West is going to be built.

183
00:24:58.130 --> 00:25:01.320
ira: There cannot be a library in a non-existent building.

184
00:25:01.890 --> 00:25:16.960
ira: Finally, I thank City Manager Karen Pincus for clearly stating at the February 19 Council meeting that the City has not done a seismic analysis of the current site. Has the city done due diligence for any site?

185
00:25:17.790 --> 00:25:19.489
ira: need more transparency.

186
00:25:19.620 --> 00:25:20.510
ira: Thank you.

187
00:25:23.080 --> 00:25:26.220
City of El Cerrito: Okay, I'll go to our next request to speak.

188
00:25:26.460 --> 00:25:29.910
City of El Cerrito: If you could please identify yourself for the record.

189
00:25:30.040 --> 00:25:32.939
City of El Cerrito: You should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

190
00:25:37.280 --> 00:25:44.590
Together We Stand: Hi, yes, my name is Sevgi Fernandez, with Together We Stand.

191
00:25:44.780 --> 00:25:50.100
Together We Stand: I am a lifelong resident of

192
00:25:50.380 --> 00:25:53.260
Together We Stand: the City of El Cerrito,

193
00:25:53.830 --> 00:25:58.120
Together We Stand: I am talking on Measure 8 today,

194
00:25:58.540 --> 00:26:04.470
Together We Stand: My family has been a part of El Cerrito since the 50s. I come before you tonight

195
00:26:04.650 --> 00:26:10.719
Together We Stand: Not only as a resident with deep roots here, but as someone whose family history understands firsthand

196
00:26:11.060 --> 00:26:15.230
Together We Stand: The danger of surveillance when power is abused,

197
00:26:15.370 --> 00:26:21.890
Together We Stand: My grandfather, Clark Kerr, was targeted by government forces during a time of political repression.

198
00:26:22.080 --> 00:26:33.880
Together We Stand: My father, a member of the Black Panzer Party, is also targeted. And…

199
00:26:34.500 --> 00:26:51.460
Together We Stand: We are living in a time when immigrant communities, activists, communities of color, and political dissenters are increasingly being monitored and targeted. The data collected by FLOC and these systems does not exist in a vacuum. Once it is gathered, it can be requested, shared, breached.

200
00:26:51.460 --> 00:26:58.420
Together We Stand: Misused, or accessed by administrations whose values may not reflect the safety and dignity of all people.

201
00:26:58.660 --> 00:27:03.060
Together We Stand: No city can guarantee permanent protection of that data, no contract.

202
00:27:03.270 --> 00:27:09.200
Together We Stand: Can fully shield vulnerable residents from the risks that come with mass surveillance infrastructure.

203
00:27:09.340 --> 00:27:17.079
Together We Stand: When you approve these systems, you are not just installing cameras, you're creating a pipeline of information that others may one day exploit.

204
00:27:17.200 --> 00:27:24.009
Together We Stand: El Cerrito has long prided itself on being a thoughtful, Progressive, and community-centered.

205
00:27:24.390 --> 00:27:28.840
Together We Stand: Place to live, and that means protecting residents before harm occurs.

206
00:27:28.980 --> 00:27:31.209
Together We Stand: Not apologizing after it does.

207
00:27:31.650 --> 00:27:37.689
Together We Stand: I ask you to consider who bears the greatest risk when surveillance expands. It's rarely the powerful.

208
00:27:37.710 --> 00:27:54.800
Together We Stand: It's the undocumented family, the young activist, the black and brown resident, the person already living closest to the edge. Please choose trust over surveillance, accountability over fear, and community safety rooted in human connection, not mass monitoring. Thank you so much.

209
00:27:54.800 --> 00:27:55.580
City of El Cerrito: comments?

210
00:27:55.950 --> 00:28:00.829
City of El Cerrito: Mayor, that concludes our request to speak at this time. Okay, thank you very much.

211
00:28:01.570 --> 00:28:19.879
City of El Cerrito: One thing I wanted to announce is that today I signed a mayoral proclamation in recognition of Tibetan Buddhist Lama Tepu Tolku, who many of you, remember. He used to work at the El Cedar Plaza, so congratulations on, Lama Tepu Tolku.

212
00:28:19.900 --> 00:28:21.709
City of El Cerrito: For his retirement.

213
00:28:22.810 --> 00:28:32.500
City of El Cerrito: I have a, proclamation that, I would like to announce now, and we will,

214
00:28:32.730 --> 00:28:34.080
City of El Cerrito: do this,

215
00:28:34.500 --> 00:28:47.069
City of El Cerrito: Now it's, needs to be voted on, item 6B, a proclamation for education and sharing. This, passed a pro… a motion to approve a proclamation to

216
00:28:47.070 --> 00:29:04.900
City of El Cerrito: declaring March 29, 2026 as Education and Sharing Day in the City of El Cerrito to raise awareness and strengthen the education of our children. Do I have a motion to approve the revised proclamation that was provided with the supplemental materials?

217
00:29:06.780 --> 00:29:07.770
City of El Cerrito: I'll move.

218
00:29:08.460 --> 00:29:15.840
City of El Cerrito: Okay, I have a motion from Motiamo and a second by Mayor Pro Tem Saltzman. All in favor?

219
00:29:16.030 --> 00:29:26.849
City of El Cerrito: Aye. Okay. I will vote yes as well. I'd like to invite up, Rabbi Yankee Bell to say a few words and accept the proclamation.

220
00:29:36.860 --> 00:29:37.689
City of El Cerrito: Nice to see you.

221
00:29:37.800 --> 00:29:38.600
City of El Cerrito: Good evening.

222
00:29:38.780 --> 00:29:39.530
City of El Cerrito: Good evening.

223
00:29:39.740 --> 00:29:43.319
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor and City Council members.

224
00:29:43.650 --> 00:29:47.290
City of El Cerrito: I am Rabbi Yankee Bell, a citizen of El Cerrito.

225
00:29:47.520 --> 00:29:54.420
City of El Cerrito: Alongside my wife, Sharni, we lead the Chabad Center, Chabad Lubilic, here in El Cerrito.

226
00:29:55.750 --> 00:29:58.599
City of El Cerrito: Thank you for this, proclamation.

227
00:30:01.410 --> 00:30:17.560
City of El Cerrito: the Education and Sharing Day is… goes back almost 5 decades to, it's been celebrated for each year by U.S. Congress and, heads of states and school districts and mayors all around… all around America.

228
00:30:17.690 --> 00:30:22.799
City of El Cerrito: marking the Rebbe's Lubavish Rebbe, the Labavisha Rebbe's birthday,

229
00:30:23.110 --> 00:30:29.560
City of El Cerrito: which falls out usually just a couple… falls out each year, a couple days before Passover, as Education and Sharing Day.

230
00:30:30.530 --> 00:30:35.169
City of El Cerrito: The Rebbe was a global spiritual giant and leader.

231
00:30:37.290 --> 00:30:48.509
City of El Cerrito: taught us about the importance… he spoke greatly about the importance of education, how it's not just about what we learn and what we know, but it's also about who we become, how we act.

232
00:30:48.800 --> 00:30:58.020
City of El Cerrito: With today's world, education is often measured by knowledge and information and success and being able to get a career

233
00:30:58.700 --> 00:31:09.579
City of El Cerrito: The true education goes deeper. It goes to… it goes to shaping our character, instilling… instilling values, and giving a person a sense of purpose and responsibility.

234
00:31:09.750 --> 00:31:18.319
City of El Cerrito: just the last… the beginning of this month, we celebrated Passover, which celebrates freedom. Freedom from oppression, exodus.

235
00:31:18.470 --> 00:31:24.480
City of El Cerrito: But, ultimately, freedom without… without guidance, and just… takes us nowhere.

236
00:31:24.710 --> 00:31:35.720
City of El Cerrito: And a society can be free and lack direction, which is why we have another holiday, Jewish holiday, that comes up in the next month, which is Shavuot, when we receive the Torah, which is a…

237
00:31:35.940 --> 00:31:43.020
City of El Cerrito: GPS for life, the guidance under God of how we can live in a healthy way in the world and be good people.

238
00:31:43.840 --> 00:31:44.740
City of El Cerrito: So.

239
00:31:45.800 --> 00:31:54.970
City of El Cerrito: Education is… is about creating a… giving a moral foundation with a clear sense of right and wrong, of responsibility, of purpose, and…

240
00:31:55.870 --> 00:31:59.759
City of El Cerrito: Helping people discover their true value, that they have a mission.

241
00:31:59.840 --> 00:32:17.519
City of El Cerrito: That they have the power to make a difference in the world, and this is something that the Rebbe, the Bhavish Rebbe, believe deeply in the potential of every individual, and every child, and every human being, that they carry their… something unique, something irreplaceable, and that something… something that only they can give to the world, each person, in their unique way.

242
00:32:17.760 --> 00:32:22.790
City of El Cerrito: So, let this proclamation serve as a reminder that we can

243
00:32:22.890 --> 00:32:33.440
City of El Cerrito: If we give our children, and all of those who we are leading, not only skills, but also a moral compass, we're preparing them to lead, to uplift, and to build a better world.

244
00:32:33.680 --> 00:32:39.730
City of El Cerrito: And education has the power to really shape a world of goodness and kindness, which is what we're working towards.

245
00:32:39.940 --> 00:32:55.490
City of El Cerrito: So may God bless all your efforts to make the city a brighter place, creating a brighter future for everyone in El Cerrito and beyond, and thank you for once again proclaiming this important, Education and Sharing Day.

246
00:32:56.450 --> 00:32:59.990
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. We will, have a picture taken in front there.

247
00:33:00.430 --> 00:33:01.180
City of El Cerrito: That's right.

248
00:34:07.490 --> 00:34:18.490
City of El Cerrito: Okay, next, item 5 is, presentations, the El Cerrito Library Update and National Library Week, proclamation. We're going to receive and file an update

249
00:34:18.590 --> 00:34:36.510
City of El Cerrito: from the El Cerrito Library and pass a motion to approve a proclamation declaring this week, April 19th at 25, 2026, as National Library Week in the City of El Cerrito, and encourage all residents to visit the library. We have Heidi Goldstein here.

250
00:34:36.830 --> 00:34:37.889
City of El Cerrito: Welcome, Heidi

251
00:34:50.780 --> 00:34:55.099
City of El Cerrito: Thank you all! Hello, good evening.

252
00:34:55.330 --> 00:35:13.350
City of El Cerrito: Thanks for having me again, and thank you to Mayor, Mayor Pro Tem, and the City Council. I am Heidi Goldstein. I am the Manager, Senior Community Library Manager here in the El Cerrito Library, part of the Contra Costa County Library System. Whoa, my chair just broke.

253
00:35:13.730 --> 00:35:14.510
City of El Cerrito: Cool.

254
00:35:14.640 --> 00:35:15.590
City of El Cerrito: Sorry.

255
00:35:16.250 --> 00:35:19.519
City of El Cerrito: I fell down the trap door that sits here.

256
00:35:21.440 --> 00:35:26.730
City of El Cerrito: And so, I'm here to talk to you about National Library Week, which is celebrated annually.

257
00:35:27.340 --> 00:35:40.280
City of El Cerrito: And this week, we are celebrating, the valuable role that libraries, librarians, and library workers can play in transforming lives and strengthening our communities.

258
00:35:41.700 --> 00:35:51.239
City of El Cerrito: And as you can see here on this first slide, the total circulation is up 9% throughout Contra Costa County Library System.

259
00:35:51.480 --> 00:36:00.150
City of El Cerrito: And you can see it's gone up quite a bit between 24… 2324 and 2425, and it continues to increase.

260
00:36:01.230 --> 00:36:10.020
City of El Cerrito: Our digital circulation is something that really came upon us, the most, probably, during COVID, and it continues to increase as well.

261
00:36:10.980 --> 00:36:16.550
City of El Cerrito: And it's due in large part to us bulking up that part of the collection throughout the whole system.

262
00:36:24.640 --> 00:36:25.840
City of El Cerrito: Please hold.

263
00:37:35.360 --> 00:37:39.210
City of El Cerrito: Thank you for your patience as we're working through how the new system works.

264
00:38:42.120 --> 00:38:45.140
City of El Cerrito: And we're back, folks. Thank you very much for your patience.

265
00:38:48.560 --> 00:38:52.660
City of El Cerrito: Okay, so… Next.

266
00:38:54.820 --> 00:39:13.330
City of El Cerrito: So yes, we did bulk up our digital circulation, our digital collection, excuse me, and so that has increased up to 39%, which is pretty impressive. And if you haven't tried out an e-book or e-audiobook, I highly recommend it. It makes life much easier.

267
00:39:14.380 --> 00:39:23.359
City of El Cerrito: And as you can see, physical visits to the library continue to rise. In person, we're up 10%. Virtually, we're up 2%.

268
00:39:23.550 --> 00:39:33.390
City of El Cerrito: And as a reminder, you don't have to even live in Contra Costa County Library to get a library card, so we get all kinds of visits from all kinds of people all over the state.

269
00:39:39.900 --> 00:39:49.159
City of El Cerrito: Okay, and here are our most popular books from 2025, the always popular Mo Willems with Should I Share My Ice Cream?

270
00:39:49.550 --> 00:39:52.499
City of El Cerrito: To which the answer is always yes, I believe.

271
00:39:53.010 --> 00:40:03.169
City of El Cerrito: the ever-so-popular Dogman series, Holly Jackson's Good Girl's Guide to Murder for the Teens, and Kristen Hanna with The Women.

272
00:40:05.840 --> 00:40:10.620
City of El Cerrito: Another great, improvement that we've had is the… oops…

273
00:40:10.910 --> 00:40:23.499
City of El Cerrito: I just lost my place. The Rolling Reader, which is an all-electric van that provides literacy services to children 0 to 5 years old in our most vulnerable communities.

274
00:40:23.750 --> 00:40:32.490
City of El Cerrito: And in 2025, you can see they served 11,923 people, which is great. They just give away books freely.

275
00:40:36.240 --> 00:40:42.370
City of El Cerrito: We also have some new digital services, and improved digital services.

276
00:40:42.920 --> 00:40:44.080
City of El Cerrito: Sorry.

277
00:40:46.000 --> 00:40:53.650
City of El Cerrito: So, Pebble Go Silence is specifically designed for K-2nd grade students.

278
00:40:53.660 --> 00:41:08.849
City of El Cerrito: This platform engages young students with narrated text, animated highlighting, easy-to-read articles, games, and educational videos to teach them about math, engineering, technology, and life, earth, and space sciences as they learn to read.

279
00:41:09.110 --> 00:41:10.490
City of El Cerrito: Excuse me.

280
00:41:11.050 --> 00:41:25.490
City of El Cerrito: The library now also offers an expanded all-access subscription to the New York Times, which includes news, audio, cooking, games, sports coverage from The Athletic, and expert product reviews from Wirecutter.

281
00:41:25.960 --> 00:41:34.419
City of El Cerrito: And then finally, we're going to be kicking out some new library notice… courtesy notices with Message B in January of 2027.

282
00:41:34.570 --> 00:41:46.749
City of El Cerrito: And all notices will include graphics and book covers whenever possible. The subject lines will start with Contra Costa County Library, and there will be a due date reminder notice indicating your item's due date.

283
00:41:50.350 --> 00:42:10.140
City of El Cerrito: For the summer of 2025, our Lunch at the Library undertakings, we gave away 13,914 summer meals, and this was available at the Antioch, Concord, Crockett, El Cerrito, El Sobronte, Pinole, Pruitt, Rodeo, and San Pablo libraries.

284
00:42:10.550 --> 00:42:14.309
City of El Cerrito: Our annual summer reading program, as you can see.

285
00:42:14.450 --> 00:42:26.519
City of El Cerrito: That we got to touch 9,050 participants of all ages, and so that was a really fun thing that we do every single year, and everyone should take part in it, because it's all good.

286
00:42:29.300 --> 00:42:33.730
City of El Cerrito: We have, revamped our Community Languages webpage.

287
00:42:33.870 --> 00:42:48.289
City of El Cerrito: We now have 9 collections of physical materials in languages other than English, Chinese, both traditional and simplified, Farsi, Filipino, Hindi, Korean, Russian, Spanish, and Vietnamese.

288
00:42:48.850 --> 00:42:57.350
City of El Cerrito: We've also added 3 new vendors to enhance and update the physical collection materials in Farsi, Vietnamese, Korean, and Russian.

289
00:42:58.830 --> 00:43:01.240
City of El Cerrito: Sorry.

290
00:43:01.840 --> 00:43:20.420
City of El Cerrito: Read… oh, sorry. Read Contra Costa, which is a county-wide undertaking that we have, September 2nd to November 8th of 2025. We read James by Percival Everett, and then we had an in-person conversation with the author in November.

291
00:43:20.630 --> 00:43:27.160
City of El Cerrito: More than 800 community members attended the live and streaming program at Los Madanos College.

292
00:43:28.480 --> 00:43:40.859
City of El Cerrito: And we have Tech Exchange, which is thanks to funding from the Measure X Innovation Fund. The library is partnering with Tech Exchange to provide drop-in tech support twice weekly.

293
00:43:40.860 --> 00:43:50.990
City of El Cerrito: the Pittsburgh, San Pablo, and Walnut Creek Libraries. Tech Exchange is a non-profit organization dedicated to building digitally proficient communities throughout the Bay Area.

294
00:43:51.100 --> 00:43:58.010
City of El Cerrito: This partnership delivers specialized tech support that extends beyond what library staff and volunteers can provide.

295
00:44:00.590 --> 00:44:15.979
City of El Cerrito: El Cerrito Library celebrated its 76th year as a library in the Stockton Avenue location. During 2025, we had well over 200 programs for varying audiences, with nearly 5,000 attendees.

296
00:44:16.370 --> 00:44:31.120
City of El Cerrito: You can see our numbers there. Adult programs, we had 90, teen programs, 32, school-age programs, 27, and preschool programs, 60. And overall, 229 programs.

297
00:44:31.260 --> 00:44:32.330
City of El Cerrito: Not bad.

298
00:44:44.930 --> 00:44:53.340
City of El Cerrito: Here I have some story time picks, and so this is story time with some of the fine folks from the El Cerrito Fire Department.

299
00:44:53.680 --> 00:45:04.380
City of El Cerrito: The second one is a fun story time and performance by our own children's librarian, Terry Dix, and the cool cats who perform as part of Oak Town Jazz.

300
00:45:04.820 --> 00:45:07.509
City of El Cerrito: Whoops, I just lost it all.

301
00:45:09.940 --> 00:45:20.469
City of El Cerrito: And the third photo is our annual visit from the East Bay Vivarium, where lots of snakes and reptiles get to get up close to library patrons.

302
00:45:23.280 --> 00:45:30.189
City of El Cerrito: On the left here, we have Making Fairy Houses, which is one of our Lunch at the Library crafts.

303
00:45:31.000 --> 00:45:38.869
City of El Cerrito: In the middle, we have the celebrating… we celebrated the magical mashup of libraries, literacy, and wrestling.

304
00:45:39.590 --> 00:45:49.240
City of El Cerrito: And this is happening again this summer on June 27th in the back parking lot. I highly recommend checking it out, it's extremely fun.

305
00:45:49.950 --> 00:46:01.110
City of El Cerrito: And the last photo was our screen printing class that we had with Chris Granillo, and that is our aide, Marianne, showing her screen printing skills.

306
00:46:03.170 --> 00:46:09.710
City of El Cerrito: Our Read to a Dog program has been consistently popular since we started it in 2017.

307
00:46:09.980 --> 00:46:19.649
City of El Cerrito: All the dogs are therapy dogs certified by the Alliance for Therapy Dogs. They come into the library every other Tuesday at 5.

308
00:46:19.900 --> 00:46:27.490
City of El Cerrito: And they also take part in library outreach at our local schools with our therapy dog friends. Pictured here

309
00:46:29.210 --> 00:46:36.090
City of El Cerrito: Patty and Gracie, Gracie has recently passed on, and Mim and Zach at Fairmont Elementary.

310
00:46:38.940 --> 00:46:41.510
City of El Cerrito: And now I am open for questions.

311
00:46:49.570 --> 00:46:59.160
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor, and thank you for this presentation. It's always nice to get confirmation about how popular our library is, and…

312
00:46:59.960 --> 00:47:15.089
City of El Cerrito: It always amazes me. I have a… just a couple of questions. One is about the tech exchange. Is it only certain places get it, or if we had bigger space, we could get it, or what is the tech exchange rules?

313
00:47:15.660 --> 00:47:24.090
City of El Cerrito: Well, the rule… I'm not sure what the rules are exactly, but it was funded through a Measure X program, which I believe might have been,

314
00:47:24.220 --> 00:47:35.089
City of El Cerrito: city, county-owned buildings at the time, is what the originators were. But it is true that if we had the room for it, we would have it.

315
00:47:35.520 --> 00:47:42.839
City of El Cerrito: You know, without the funding, we would figure out a way to make it happen, because it would definitely be appreciated in our library.

316
00:47:43.060 --> 00:47:54.469
City of El Cerrito: And my second question is, I know, I think the year before, we had closures because it was so hot in the library. Did we have any in this past 12 months?

317
00:47:54.470 --> 00:48:09.259
City of El Cerrito: Not in 2025. We were able to stay open, the weather didn't… the temperature didn't quite rise up quite so high, but in 2024, we did have to close twice. But the last March heatwave was okay.

318
00:48:09.490 --> 00:48:21.730
City of El Cerrito: I believe the Cal OSHA requirement is when it's over 82 degrees inside the building, and last year we just didn't quite make that 82, luckily.

319
00:48:22.000 --> 00:48:23.909
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much. Thank you.

320
00:48:26.190 --> 00:48:39.879
City of El Cerrito: I don't have questions, just want to thank you for everything you do, and encourage anybody who doesn't visit the library regularly to go stop by, and Heidi's often there and can answer the questions you have, and the whole rest of the team there is great, too.

321
00:48:40.130 --> 00:48:42.749
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. I echo, Michael.

322
00:48:45.450 --> 00:48:46.490
City of El Cerrito: Me.

323
00:48:47.240 --> 00:48:53.910
City of El Cerrito: Turn that off. Thank you very much. I echo what the Mayor Pro Chan just mentioned. Know that,

324
00:48:54.290 --> 00:49:05.880
City of El Cerrito: I was at the, in the basement, where we, where you sell, and, and, you're letting residents, turn in books. Very much appreciate that, because,

325
00:49:05.880 --> 00:49:09.329
City of El Cerrito: My home, we go back and forth there all the time, and

326
00:49:09.330 --> 00:49:26.789
City of El Cerrito: dropping off books. My house is a small home with lots of bookcases, so I want to thank you for that, and do we still have the LGBT collection there? We absolutely do, and if you'll recall, when we started it in 2018, it was

327
00:49:27.500 --> 00:49:36.840
City of El Cerrito: This is some library jargon here. It was one bay of a bookcase, and now it is two full sides of an entire

328
00:49:36.840 --> 00:49:48.569
City of El Cerrito: aisle, entire stack, and it's for all ages, and it's… it's great. I'm so proud of it. Yeah, I very much appreciate that. I was at the opening when,

329
00:49:48.690 --> 00:50:03.980
City of El Cerrito: That was, I guess that was 2018. Oh, 2018, yep. Appreciate that, and, I encourage our residents to, drop by the library, and, you will see, what is needed. We need a new

330
00:50:03.980 --> 00:50:08.219
City of El Cerrito: 21st Century Library, and, I'm excited that,

331
00:50:08.220 --> 00:50:25.379
City of El Cerrito: There'll be a possibility if this is passed. So again, let the residents decide up or down if they want to do this, but I encourage our residents. We have a lot of new families that have moved here that are paying the maximum

332
00:50:25.440 --> 00:50:29.189
City of El Cerrito: To live here. I just want to have, the…

333
00:50:30.210 --> 00:50:36.310
City of El Cerrito: Books and the space, that the next generation of families had.

334
00:50:36.500 --> 00:50:43.999
City of El Cerrito: are able to, use. I was able to use the library as a kid growing up down the street there on Lexington.

335
00:50:44.000 --> 00:51:06.859
City of El Cerrito: And, this is what we want. This is what we want to leave for the next generation. And, I know many of you have grandkids. This is a city of families now, not just seniors. So, I want to make sure that, our residents know the importance of voting on June 1st on the library up or down. So, we're going to,

336
00:51:06.860 --> 00:51:19.179
City of El Cerrito: see if we can approve this, and I have a proclamation for you. So, do I have a motion to approve the proclamation? Second. Okay, so I have a motion, a second. All in favor?

337
00:51:19.320 --> 00:51:20.210
City of El Cerrito: Aye.

338
00:51:20.590 --> 00:51:23.509
City of El Cerrito: Okay, motion passes. Okay, so…

339
00:51:23.880 --> 00:51:28.190
City of El Cerrito: we'll get to have a picture with you, because you were not here last year. That's true.

340
00:52:27.820 --> 00:52:31.540
City of El Cerrito: Okay, next we'll have adoption of the consent calendar.

341
00:52:32.600 --> 00:52:44.299
City of El Cerrito: we have… A California Cities Week Proclamation, C, Monthly Disbursement and Check Register Report for March 2026.

342
00:52:44.510 --> 00:52:54.189
City of El Cerrito: 2025-26, third quarter cash and investment report. E is measure C, Senior Exemptions on the Resolution of Clarification and intent.

343
00:52:54.740 --> 00:52:55.400
City of El Cerrito: F.

344
00:52:56.900 --> 00:53:14.390
City of El Cerrito: Senate Bill 1383, Memorandum of Understanding with the West Contra Costa Integrated Waste Management Authority. G, authorization for purchase of a 2026 Chevy Silverado EV, crew cab standard, truck.

345
00:53:14.760 --> 00:53:31.210
City of El Cerrito: And H is to adopt landscape and lighting assessment for fiscal year 2026-27 and adopt resolution of intent to order improvements. Would anyone like to pull an item? Yes. I'd like us to,

346
00:53:31.350 --> 00:53:37.930
City of El Cerrito: Pull Measure E, or number E, Measure C, senior exemption, and I have some questions on D.

347
00:53:38.120 --> 00:53:40.390
City of El Cerrito: So you… I'm sorry, so that is E?

348
00:53:40.650 --> 00:53:41.540
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

349
00:53:41.670 --> 00:53:48.669
City of El Cerrito: Your questions were C, right? Or no? My questions were on D, the quarterly cash and investment report.

350
00:53:49.420 --> 00:53:50.130
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

351
00:53:50.290 --> 00:53:53.050
City of El Cerrito: Anyone else? Would anyone like to follow anything?

352
00:54:02.960 --> 00:54:04.489
City of El Cerrito: See the register.

353
00:54:05.120 --> 00:54:06.329
City of El Cerrito: See? Yeah. Okay.

354
00:54:07.770 --> 00:54:13.030
City of El Cerrito: Let's go first to, did you have anything? Okay.

355
00:54:13.680 --> 00:54:17.820
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we'll go to C first. Go ahead, Councilmember Keith.

356
00:54:18.420 --> 00:54:24.759
City of El Cerrito: I had questions about a couple line item expenses. Sure. And, again, for the public's benefit.

357
00:54:25.040 --> 00:54:43.799
City of El Cerrito: I mentioned this before, that we do get this in advance, and we do often go through our questions with the city manager, and I did this, so most of these that I had highlighted and questions about, I've already answered them. There are a few that I thought might be helpful just for other people to hear the answer as well, so I'm not going to go through all the ones I had questions about, but I will…

358
00:54:43.940 --> 00:54:45.140
City of El Cerrito: Pick out a few.

359
00:54:47.440 --> 00:54:54.560
City of El Cerrito: The first one that stood out to me, or one that I want to mention today, was $80,000

360
00:54:54.680 --> 00:55:00.939
City of El Cerrito: for the Animal Control Services, it's number 95754 on the registry.

361
00:55:01.440 --> 00:55:04.770
City of El Cerrito: And I was… I… We'll address it to the…

362
00:55:05.040 --> 00:55:20.900
City of El Cerrito: to the city manager, but I expressed, you know, just kind of curiosity about what the cost was, and what was entailed in the cost, and what period of time, and as I understood it, it is for a quarterly fee paid to the county, and I will hand it off to the city manager to add more, or to whoever

363
00:55:21.130 --> 00:55:39.200
City of El Cerrito: Please keep that's the case. I will actually hand it off to the police chief to explain our relationship with animal services. And before we start, I will say that I really appreciate your police officers, because we had a deer in front of our house that was mauled by a coyote, apparently, and they came over, and they held their nose, and pulled the carcass to the side of the road, and…

364
00:55:39.200 --> 00:55:44.180
City of El Cerrito: Okay. Didn't seem to enjoy it, but they did their job. Okay, well, thank you. We appreciate that. Thank you for that.

365
00:55:44.210 --> 00:55:58.170
City of El Cerrito: So I'm Paul Keith, your Chief of Police. Good evening, Councilmembers. So, we pay our Animal Control Services fees on a quarterly basis, so the $80,000 represents, coverage for that quarter.

366
00:55:58.210 --> 00:56:11.899
City of El Cerrito: What the coverage includes is, basically, it helps, on a proportional basis, pay for animal control services in Contra Costa County. So, every city in the county, with the exception of Antioch.

367
00:56:11.920 --> 00:56:29.490
City of El Cerrito: contracts with Contra Costa Animal Services for, responses due to animal bites, for stray domestic animals, for enforcement of, domestic animal ordinances. It helps cover adoption costs. Some of the,

368
00:56:29.520 --> 00:56:49.160
City of El Cerrito: components of that fee also include kind of a true-up at the end of the year. So, if there are animals being adopted from El Cerrito, then they do try to rectify some of that, the revenues against the expenses. So, if they have more revenues than they estimated, there is supposed to be a true-up at the end of the agreement.

369
00:56:49.360 --> 00:56:50.220
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

370
00:56:50.420 --> 00:57:10.240
City of El Cerrito: And it is quite a bit of money. It is a lot of money to stand up your own animal services organization. So, compared to what it would cost for us to provide these services as a city, it is a deal. But it is still a lot of money for sometimes what feels like just a few responses. I think they had something

371
00:57:10.360 --> 00:57:28.459
City of El Cerrito: You know, I saw the report, but I don't have it off the top of my head, but they do provide us with a quarterly report as well on what they came out to do. Okay, thank you. And while I have you up here, may I ask you another question? Sure. There were four line items for mileage and meal reimbursement for, I think, about a

372
00:57:28.530 --> 00:57:30.570
City of El Cerrito: 5-week period, if I remember the dates right.

373
00:57:30.800 --> 00:57:36.719
City of El Cerrito: And they were about $1,700 a piece, and I was just curious about that. I did get an answer, but I'll let you address it as well.

374
00:57:36.820 --> 00:57:52.849
City of El Cerrito: So, I believe those are for our, four academy recruits that were attending the academy. So, because they have to commute to the academy, we pay them mileage consistent with the, IRS rate for, government services.

375
00:57:52.940 --> 00:58:06.839
City of El Cerrito: It's to pay for them to commute to the academy, to subsidize their lunch as well at the academy, and to come home at the end of the day. But those, cease once they become police officers, now they're just normal folks like the rest of us commuting to work.

376
00:58:06.920 --> 00:58:23.750
City of El Cerrito: Okay, and the last item that pertains to the police was a reimbursement to the City of Richmond for $72,000, which I understood was for the dispatch services. Is that a quarterly fee, or monthly fee, or how's that worked out? That is a monthly fee that we pay to the City of Richmond, so…

377
00:58:23.750 --> 00:58:42.160
City of El Cerrito: Services overall, doing the math, come out to be about, I think, $850,000 to $860,000 this year. We pay on a monthly basis, it covers, all dispatching costs, so it covers the call center when people call 911, and it also covers their, coordination with our officers, get them to the scenes of crimes and

378
00:58:42.400 --> 00:58:48.029
City of El Cerrito: all of those things. It also, covers after-hours services for our officers, so we have,

379
00:58:48.150 --> 00:59:01.550
City of El Cerrito: a warrant that we've served, or a vehicle that we've towed. Richmond allows us to use their records, their records specialists to enter that information into the California law enforcement system. Okay, thank you. Sure.

380
00:59:02.500 --> 00:59:04.479
City of El Cerrito: Any questions on C?

381
00:59:04.900 --> 00:59:14.480
City of El Cerrito: Okay, Councilmember Mutayama. Go ahead. Thank you, Mayor. So I have some questions on the third quarter cash and investment report.

382
00:59:25.790 --> 00:59:27.899
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, Crystal Reams, Finance Director.

383
00:59:28.280 --> 00:59:30.080
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

384
00:59:30.210 --> 00:59:41.279
City of El Cerrito: I… when looking at the presentation materials in the packet, you know, it was really referring to almost a different economic time, and

385
00:59:41.660 --> 00:59:43.650
City of El Cerrito: are… you know.

386
00:59:43.910 --> 00:59:51.490
City of El Cerrito: so I feel like the stuff that was presented to us from PFM was largely out of date.

387
00:59:52.320 --> 00:59:58.600
City of El Cerrito: Can you also kind of go into detail on what we are investing in, and what the fees are?

388
00:59:58.890 --> 01:00:23.789
City of El Cerrito: Yeah, so that was for, 2025. It was their, the year-end review, and then in the later half of the presentation, there was also, what's… what's happening currently, and where… where we're headed, and what they're looking out for. So it was all very detailed, outlined in there. But our… we are on a passively managed fund, so we're, no direct trading, no direct investments, and it's not directly managed.

389
01:00:23.790 --> 01:00:29.950
City of El Cerrito: They charge us, .25% annually.

390
01:00:29.950 --> 01:00:33.269
City of El Cerrito: For… and then we'd also have,

391
01:00:33.400 --> 01:00:38.380
City of El Cerrito: Other trading fees that happen when they do buy and sell within the investments.

392
01:00:38.490 --> 01:00:48.189
City of El Cerrito: But it's, yeah, all the indices are outlined in the moderately conservative, plan that the Council, had us move forward with.

393
01:00:49.070 --> 01:00:52.560
City of El Cerrito: And is there a total return at this time?

394
01:00:52.770 --> 01:00:57.619
City of El Cerrito: To date, on our… 115 Trust?

395
01:00:57.770 --> 01:01:13.789
City of El Cerrito: To date, I do not have that off the top of my head, I apologize. I can definitely include that with, with the next, or I can pass it along to, City Manager, and she can pass it along as well. And I wanted to ask you a question that came up in public comment.

396
01:01:15.240 --> 01:01:24.580
City of El Cerrito: you know, when do we do the waterfall? Is that based on the aquifer, or based on the close of the fiscal year, or…

397
01:01:24.700 --> 01:01:38.249
City of El Cerrito: When does that happen? So, we did have a surplus, and I apologize, I don't have the, roll forward figure, for the purchase order roll forwards, at the top of my head, but, basically with the…

398
01:01:38.370 --> 01:01:45.069
City of El Cerrito: successor agency, issue that we had. That would have been… that's a prior period correction, so it…

399
01:01:45.230 --> 01:01:49.310
City of El Cerrito: Pretty much wiped out, any type of surplus that, that we had.

400
01:01:49.570 --> 01:01:50.260
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

401
01:01:50.720 --> 01:01:55.190
City of El Cerrito: I had a sinking feeling that that was the case, but thank you. Of course.

402
01:01:55.910 --> 01:02:00.869
City of El Cerrito: Okay. I have questions as well. A question on that. Really, yeah. Yeah.

403
01:02:02.450 --> 01:02:06.570
City of El Cerrito: I have questions also about the… The investment report, so…

404
01:02:10.440 --> 01:02:19.239
City of El Cerrito: Do we… do we know the percentage return on the lathe, and is the lathe the same thing as the pooled investments California Treasurer?

405
01:02:19.240 --> 01:02:34.890
City of El Cerrito: Yes, those are the meetings. So we do know them, 3.88? Yes, yeah, so it's all published on the, on LAFE's website, and it's included in the report what the return was for, March.

406
01:02:36.470 --> 01:02:51.369
City of El Cerrito: Okay, yeah, I saw a… there's a quarterly number here that says 3.88, and it says, pooled investments, California State Treasurer, so I assume that was a leaf, but I wasn't sure. Yeah, it comes directly from… from the state's website. And then, sort of reiterating what you just said about the

407
01:02:51.480 --> 01:02:59.470
City of El Cerrito: the waterfall. There's a graph that shows the, the… what was the title?

408
01:02:59.770 --> 01:03:02.889
City of El Cerrito: contributions to the 115, I believe, and it…

409
01:03:03.140 --> 01:03:11.369
City of El Cerrito: it levels off at the top, into the next time period. That's because of the lack of a pool… lack of a pool, I don't know, flow of funds into that.

410
01:03:11.940 --> 01:03:15.469
City of El Cerrito: Yes, yeah, because we haven't made any additional contributions. Okay.

411
01:03:17.110 --> 01:03:18.260
City of El Cerrito: And then…

412
01:03:26.260 --> 01:03:27.890
City of El Cerrito: Okay, that's all, thank you.

413
01:03:28.810 --> 01:03:33.539
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we'll go to, E, Measure C, Senior Exemption Resolution.

414
01:03:34.310 --> 01:03:42.150
City of El Cerrito: Go ahead. Thank you. I had asked to pull it, but I can just ask my questions. So,

415
01:03:43.560 --> 01:03:58.260
City of El Cerrito: There was language in the staff report about a requirement for at least some responsibility for payment of the ad valorem taxes, and does that need to be included in the language of the resolution?

416
01:04:00.140 --> 01:04:03.400
City of El Cerrito: Because it didn't seem to be included there.

417
01:04:05.340 --> 01:04:10.810
City of El Cerrito: I'm just pulling up the staff report to… Confirm what it says.

418
01:04:15.430 --> 01:04:16.380
City of El Cerrito: I'll have one question.

419
01:04:16.610 --> 01:04:17.290
City of El Cerrito: Brothers.

420
01:04:40.040 --> 01:04:42.029
City of El Cerrito: Yeah, so that,

421
01:04:42.240 --> 01:05:00.979
City of El Cerrito: That is actually part of the proposed ordinance, and so that would stay in place as a requirement under the ordinance. The resolution doesn't have to incorporate that since it's already built into a portion of Measure C.

422
01:05:00.980 --> 01:05:06.870
City of El Cerrito: Okay, and so…

423
01:05:07.850 --> 01:05:17.600
City of El Cerrito: I'm just gonna ask this because I think there's this huge misunderstanding about the senior exemption. Can you talk about,

424
01:05:18.650 --> 01:05:31.889
City of El Cerrito: the qualifications for the state program are not related to qualifications for our Measure H and Measure C. Sure, sure, I'd be happy to do that.

425
01:05:32.030 --> 01:05:41.469
City of El Cerrito: Measure H and the proposed Measure C, both refer… both include an exemption that states that.

426
01:05:41.700 --> 01:05:51.260
City of El Cerrito: Someone who, qualifies to participate in one of two programs offered by the state for property tax relief.

427
01:05:51.260 --> 01:06:05.670
City of El Cerrito: also qualify for an exemption from the city's tax. And the important words there are qualify to participate. It does… neither of the… neither of the ordinances says that somebody must actually participate in either of the two programs.

428
01:06:05.710 --> 01:06:08.000
City of El Cerrito: So, one of the things that,

429
01:06:08.130 --> 01:06:17.970
City of El Cerrito: we brought to Council, and that's incorporated into the proposed resolution is that, those two state programs represent,

430
01:06:18.480 --> 01:06:28.779
City of El Cerrito: criteria that the city would use, to determine whether or not somebody could qualify for an exemption from the city's tax. So…

431
01:06:29.130 --> 01:06:42.649
City of El Cerrito: it does not require that, a city resident who wants to be exempt from one of those two city taxes actually receive the benefit of the state programs. We read it as instructing the city

432
01:06:42.650 --> 01:06:50.010
City of El Cerrito: Look to those state programs for criteria to evaluate whether or not somebody can qualify to be exempted from the city's tax.

433
01:06:50.160 --> 01:07:05.890
City of El Cerrito: you don't have to look… they don't have to check whether or not they're actually participating. And so, when we took direction from Council, to craft a resolution that would express the City Council's intent in interpreting that, we tried to clarify that

434
01:07:05.890 --> 01:07:22.839
City of El Cerrito: while Measure C incorporates those references to those two state programs, it will not be necessary for somebody to participate, actually get relief from the state under either of those two programs. Instead, the city will look to those two programs for criteria.

435
01:07:22.840 --> 01:07:36.400
City of El Cerrito: And then, as stated in the resolution, you have actually directed that some of those criteria you will not look at. It will not matter… someone will be able to apply for and qualify for an exemption from the Measure C tax if it's approved.

436
01:07:36.470 --> 01:07:44.120
City of El Cerrito: Even if they have a reverse mortgage on the property. But they would not be able to qualify under either of the two state programs, if that were true.

437
01:07:44.520 --> 01:07:46.929
City of El Cerrito: So I hope that helps explain this. Thank you.

438
01:07:47.320 --> 01:07:51.689
City of El Cerrito: Okay, thank you very much for that clarification. So,

439
01:07:52.040 --> 01:07:57.470
City of El Cerrito: Now, do I have a motion to approve the consent file.

440
01:07:57.800 --> 01:08:04.509
City of El Cerrito: I move to approve all the consent items that, except for B, which we already passed. I have a second?

441
01:08:04.650 --> 01:08:12.159
City of El Cerrito: Second. Okay, we have a motion by… Second. Second. I didn't say it in the mic. By Weisinger. All in favor? Aye.

442
01:08:12.630 --> 01:08:13.970
City of El Cerrito: Motion passes.

443
01:08:18.890 --> 01:08:30.679
City of El Cerrito: So next, we have a public hearing, and that's an annual review and renewal of the military ordinance… equipment ordinance. Paul Keith, our Chief of Police, has a presentation.

444
01:08:31.540 --> 01:08:32.260
City of El Cerrito: Huh.

445
01:08:35.550 --> 01:08:38.960
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, Mayor and Council Members. My name's JT Warat, like.

446
01:08:39.240 --> 01:08:43.750
City of El Cerrito: I'm a lieutenant with the police department, and I oversee our administrative and support division.

447
01:08:43.960 --> 01:08:47.629
City of El Cerrito: I'm here tonight to request renewal of our military equipment ordinance.

448
01:08:47.810 --> 01:08:51.219
City of El Cerrito: This ordinance was originally passed by Council in 2022.

449
01:08:51.390 --> 01:08:57.660
City of El Cerrito: California state law requires that the City Council review the use of the military equipment report.

450
01:08:58.029 --> 01:09:04.669
City of El Cerrito: The inventory of the military equipment held in the local police department, and renew the ordinance yearly.

451
01:09:05.520 --> 01:09:08.889
City of El Cerrito: As part of our… as part of our renewal process.

452
01:09:09.040 --> 01:09:14.259
City of El Cerrito: We publish our military equipment report for the year 2020-25,

453
01:09:14.680 --> 01:09:21.670
City of El Cerrito: We published our new draft military equipment policy, and we published our military equipment inventory.

454
01:09:21.800 --> 01:09:29.599
City of El Cerrito: All of these documents were posted to the El Cerrito Police Department website on February 19th, 2026.

455
01:09:30.100 --> 01:09:39.590
City of El Cerrito: Some items to note, we are requesting one additional, drone to be purchased in this upcoming fiscal year, pending budget approval.

456
01:09:39.750 --> 01:09:43.249
City of El Cerrito: Munitions will be replenished.

457
01:09:43.370 --> 01:09:47.530
City of El Cerrito: Based on expenditures in training and deployments.

458
01:09:47.649 --> 01:09:55.059
City of El Cerrito: And just generally speaking, replacement costs and maintenance costs have… More or less gone unchanged.

459
01:09:56.480 --> 01:10:00.030
City of El Cerrito: California law requires we host one public meeting

460
01:10:00.260 --> 01:10:08.620
City of El Cerrito: We actually hosted two. The first one occurred on March 2nd, 2026, and we… at that time, we presented to the Community Safety Committee.

461
01:10:09.160 --> 01:10:14.779
City of El Cerrito: The second in the main public meeting was on March 30th, 2026.

462
01:10:15.020 --> 01:10:19.450
City of El Cerrito: This meeting was publicized through Nixle, as well as on the city website.

463
01:10:19.610 --> 01:10:23.929
City of El Cerrito: And it was published in 30 days in advance of the meeting.

464
01:10:24.080 --> 01:10:41.109
City of El Cerrito: This meeting is an opportunity for the community members to come and express any complaints or concerns that they might have with military equipment, ask questions about military equipment, and just generally discuss the equipment and its use. Should be noted that no members did attend this meeting.

465
01:10:41.930 --> 01:10:45.889
City of El Cerrito: So, we are requesting renewal of our existing military equipment ordinance.

466
01:10:46.640 --> 01:10:49.709
City of El Cerrito: At this time, if you have any questions, I'd be happy to field any.

467
01:10:50.030 --> 01:11:05.039
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much. Do we have any questions? Councilmember… No, no, no, no, we'll start with you. Go ahead, Councilmember Mojayama. Thank you, Mayor, and thank you, Officer Warlick, for, your presentation.

468
01:11:05.040 --> 01:11:13.809
City of El Cerrito: I have some questions, particularly about, the tear gas and other projectiles. So.

469
01:11:15.050 --> 01:11:22.000
City of El Cerrito: Do we ever… have we ever used them in El Cerrito? And if we haven't, why do we need to train people to use them?

470
01:11:22.160 --> 01:11:26.470
City of El Cerrito: And, has it… is it really effective?

471
01:11:29.140 --> 01:11:32.100
City of El Cerrito: If you don't mind, I'm gonna step in to take this question.

472
01:11:32.320 --> 01:11:37.899
City of El Cerrito: So, in my 25-year career, we've never used tear gas in El Cerrito.

473
01:11:38.250 --> 01:11:51.320
City of El Cerrito: The reason that we retain a stock of tear gas is, well, I'll tell you my overall philosophy. So, I'm an Eagle Scout. I spent a lot of years in Boy Scouts. The Boy Scout motto was to be prepared.

474
01:11:51.580 --> 01:11:58.600
City of El Cerrito: So, while we haven't used it in 25 years, that's a testament to the lack of civil unrest in our community.

475
01:11:58.640 --> 01:12:12.479
City of El Cerrito: But there have been times in the history of the United States, within, you know, the decade of the 60s and 70s, where there has been wide-scale civil unrest. So we have tear gas available in the event that we had violent unrest in El Cerrito.

476
01:12:12.620 --> 01:12:25.739
City of El Cerrito: are members of our mobile field force, so we have a contingent of officers that participate with the county's Mutual Aid Mobile Field Force. They train rarely with tear gas, with the county.

477
01:12:25.910 --> 01:12:36.190
City of El Cerrito: Do I ever anticipate in my career it being used? No, I don't. I think that it's, probably going to be a rare occurrence, but we do have people that have been trained in its use.

478
01:12:36.470 --> 01:12:50.569
City of El Cerrito: When it comes to projectile-based weapons, these are sponge rounds and drag-stabilized beanbags. In 24 and 25, we didn't have any uses of those. We didn't use them, as in fire them at anybody.

479
01:12:50.660 --> 01:12:58.999
City of El Cerrito: But we do have them as an alternative to lethal force in longer-range encounters with violent individuals. So…

480
01:12:59.000 --> 01:13:12.319
City of El Cerrito: It is available as a tool for our officers. I believe that it's an important risk management component of our use of force options, because it does give officers a long-range alternative to using lethal force.

481
01:13:12.320 --> 01:13:29.639
City of El Cerrito: I think that the fact that we haven't used it is a testament to our officers' use of de-escalation skills, and really working through taking the time in incidents involving people that present a lethal threat to officers, and not resorting to the use of them is a testament to their… the skills that they have.

482
01:13:29.660 --> 01:13:32.430
City of El Cerrito: But once again, it's another,

483
01:13:32.490 --> 01:13:38.019
City of El Cerrito: It's another element of being prepared for multiple potential, threats that we might face.

484
01:13:38.420 --> 01:13:45.910
City of El Cerrito: And my last question is, why do you think we need more drones? We have, like, 6 drones. That's a lot of drones.

485
01:13:46.220 --> 01:13:59.270
City of El Cerrito: We have 6 drones. So, two of the drones are interior drones, those are for clearing the inside of residence. Of the remaining 4 that we have currently, one is an old drone, it's…

486
01:13:59.270 --> 01:14:08.309
City of El Cerrito: used as a training drone. We have one drone assigned to investigations, so they can have their own piece of equipment that's always ready for them, and we have two drones that are assigned to patrol.

487
01:14:08.360 --> 01:14:24.029
City of El Cerrito: So this drone would go into that pool of exterior drones. Basically, it's always a good idea to have two drones on any given deployment, because there's a number of things that could knock a drone out of service. As an example, the first time we used an interior drone, it was during a

488
01:14:24.030 --> 01:14:33.820
City of El Cerrito: Resolution of a home invasion robbery. We sent the interior drone into the house, and it was doing great, and then it got into the bathroom, and it hit the shower curtain, and the drone was out of commission.

489
01:14:33.820 --> 01:14:52.730
City of El Cerrito: got tangled up in the shower curtain. At the time, we didn't have a second interior drone, so it was time to send the officers in, because we didn't have another tool to clear the inside of the house. But the same goes for exterior drones as well. A drone can hit a tree branch, it can hit part of a roof, it can hit power lines and get knocked out of the air, or it could suffer a mechanical failure.

490
01:14:52.730 --> 01:15:03.759
City of El Cerrito: So, the main, intent behind this drone is to give us the possibility of having a little more depth in our deployments, making sure that we can regularly send two out when we're deploying a drone.

491
01:15:04.000 --> 01:15:23.139
City of El Cerrito: I will also say, just to reiterate what the lieutenant said, this is pending the budget for these items. Now, that is yet to be presented to Council. If the budget in the upcoming fiscal year does not include enough funding for this drone, then it's not going to happen. It's just going to remain something that we'll continue to seek, but may not obtain.

492
01:15:24.420 --> 01:15:25.810
City of El Cerrito: Great. Thank you very much.

493
01:15:26.020 --> 01:15:42.670
City of El Cerrito: Okay, I gotta ask a question, regarding the drones. You know, with what's going on across the country and the federal government, and, are any of our drones made in China? And, are you to be forced to.

494
01:15:42.670 --> 01:15:56.650
City of El Cerrito: get rid of the ones that, supposedly are from China, and, because of, what's happening on the federal level, dealing with, you know, drones made in China.

495
01:15:57.040 --> 01:16:02.039
City of El Cerrito: So that is a very timely question. Yes, we do have drones that are made in China.

496
01:16:02.060 --> 01:16:17.330
City of El Cerrito: They are continued to allow to fly under previous FAA authorization. So, what the FAA has determined is that no new drones can enter the United States, I believe, effective January of this year. So, all of our drones were…

497
01:16:17.330 --> 01:16:32.319
City of El Cerrito: brought into the United States before that restriction went into place. At this point, it doesn't sound like there's going to be a grounding order for Chinese-made drones, so they're going to be able to continue to fly. However, getting new drones from China does not sound like it's going to be happening in the immediate future.

498
01:16:32.320 --> 01:16:50.999
City of El Cerrito: One of the reasons why the drone this year has a higher price tag attached to it is that we're trying to spec the price as an American-made drone. So, the model that we specified, or similar, we're trying to kind of estimate the cost that an American-made drone would be. It's about…

499
01:16:51.280 --> 01:16:59.009
City of El Cerrito: Well, it's about another $15,000 over the price of a Chinese-made drone, but that's Americans putting it together, so…

500
01:16:59.610 --> 01:17:02.070
City of El Cerrito: Thank you for that. Mayor Pro Tem, go ahead.

501
01:17:02.280 --> 01:17:21.030
City of El Cerrito: Just first, thank you for this report. I think it's great that… I know we have to do it, but it's great that we're transparent with the public and explain what all this equipment is. On the tear gas, I also hope you will never have to use it, but what are the policies, because you've made it sound like these have…

502
01:17:21.030 --> 01:17:37.430
City of El Cerrito: nobody else… but people… other agencies are using tear gas in our country now, so it's good that we haven't had that situation, but I guess, what is the training about when you would potentially use it, and what the guardrails are on that?

503
01:17:37.490 --> 01:17:52.340
City of El Cerrito: So, we do have a use of force policy that covers when we would use tear gas, and the training that they go through regularly typically involves violent resistance, so when people's lives are in danger, that's when they typically would deploy it.

504
01:17:52.340 --> 01:18:00.680
City of El Cerrito: Property damage is another area where the Mutual Aid Mobile Field Force might, deploy it, depending on the circumstances.

505
01:18:00.890 --> 01:18:09.290
City of El Cerrito: So, there's a lot that goes into, use of force during First Amendment protests. There's,

506
01:18:09.840 --> 01:18:25.829
City of El Cerrito: announcements that have to be made to inform people present that this is an unlawful gathering. You have to provide for a manner of egress so people can leave the scene. You can't just surround people and then decide you're gonna tear gas them. So there are a lot of considerations that go into it. We, follow a…

507
01:18:25.830 --> 01:18:40.140
City of El Cerrito: basically state guidelines on when we would use it. Like I said, it would be a rarity, and for us to use it, it would really have to involve violence. Otherwise, we're going to rely on a call out to the Mutual Aid Mobile Field Force for assistance.

508
01:18:40.580 --> 01:18:58.890
City of El Cerrito: That is good to hear. Unfortunately, some of our neighboring cities in the past decade have not totally followed all those rules, and so sometimes the announcements have not been loud enough. I mean, when you're in a situation like this with a lot of people, not everybody heard. Sometimes people heard the announcement, but there was no way out, so…

509
01:18:58.890 --> 01:19:09.449
City of El Cerrito: it's good to hear that you're… you're training on all of those things, and I… I hope we are able to find the funds for another drone, because they do seem effective, and when I've…

510
01:19:09.450 --> 01:19:21.209
City of El Cerrito: when I first got on the council and got the tour, heard about, you know, how they were helpful to keep officers out of a situation where you could have to pull a weapon. Like, this is actually protecting

511
01:19:21.390 --> 01:19:32.349
City of El Cerrito: both anybody who's involved and the officers, in terms of sending a drone in, the worst that can happen is the drone gets hurt instead of a person getting hurt, so I think

512
01:19:32.350 --> 01:19:43.919
City of El Cerrito: it is a good way forward, and it does make sense to use them. I would much rather have a drone get hurt. And I also want to add, you know, you used a drone in my neighborhood.

513
01:19:43.920 --> 01:19:47.940
City of El Cerrito: I guess it was last year or sometime, and I want to thank you for that, because,

514
01:19:47.940 --> 01:19:59.169
City of El Cerrito: you know, you were protecting our residents, and, so… and this was the safest way to, take care of that situation. So again, thank you for,

515
01:19:59.190 --> 01:20:24.109
City of El Cerrito: that. Let's go to Councilmember Weissinger. Yes, thank you so much, Mayor. Thank you, Chief, for that presentation. This is one of those presentations that I always think it can be very interesting, but I think it's also very important because a lot of people will look on the agenda and see that word, military, and wonder exactly what that is. This year, I did not hear the rumor that we have a tank, so I'm happy about that. I didn't…

516
01:20:24.110 --> 01:20:36.760
City of El Cerrito: I didn't hear that this year. And thank you to Mayor Pro Tem and Councilmember Motuayama, who did actually start the conversation about drones. One question that I had that I don't think that you've spoken to yet, or maybe

517
01:20:36.760 --> 01:20:49.919
City of El Cerrito: you can expand on is how does our use of drones align with our current policy in oversight? And also, secondary, how is data on deployment and use of the equipment tracked and shared with the public?

518
01:20:50.580 --> 01:21:00.810
City of El Cerrito: Okay, so I'm gonna cover the last part of it first. We put a drone log under the aerial operations page of the police department's webpage, so…

519
01:21:00.810 --> 01:21:21.070
City of El Cerrito: Anybody interested in how and why we deploy our drones can go there to get at least a synopsis of why we use a drone. We include training on there, too, and one of the reasons why we include training is that there's a lot of drones that might be flying around L Street on any given day, so we want people to know that if they saw a drone on a particular day.

520
01:21:21.340 --> 01:21:33.070
City of El Cerrito: If it's on our log, maybe it was us training, but then again, maybe it wasn't us at all. So it could have been a private party flying a drone. So we really want people to have a reference material, if they see a drone, to know whether or not it was a police drone.

521
01:21:33.500 --> 01:21:40.729
City of El Cerrito: We also post our policy online, so if people want to know what the uses of the drones are, those are on there as well.

522
01:21:41.060 --> 01:21:53.910
City of El Cerrito: Anytime we deploy a drone, it's always a two-person team. It's in connection, typically, with a law enforcement investigation. We do help neighboring agencies quite a bit, so, as it turns out,

523
01:21:53.960 --> 01:22:13.360
City of El Cerrito: We seem to have drone availability a lot more frequently than the Richmond Police Department does, so we do about a drone deployment a month in support of the Richmond Police Department, typically involving a search of an area for a suspect that they're chasing. But we've also used it for missing people, we've used it for documenting evidence.

524
01:22:13.480 --> 01:22:23.639
City of El Cerrito: I believe in both of the crashes involving pedestrians, we put our drones up to take aerial footage of the collision scene, the evidence on the ground, that sort of thing.

525
01:22:24.840 --> 01:22:25.530
City of El Cerrito: Canada.

526
01:22:25.860 --> 01:22:32.909
City of El Cerrito: About the deployment data, do we have that available, and is that something that the public is able to access?

527
01:22:33.340 --> 01:22:40.229
City of El Cerrito: So the usage log, they are able to access. The data about deployments, not necessarily.

528
01:22:40.310 --> 01:22:56.500
City of El Cerrito: We do retain footage for a 366-day period before it's deleted. Any footage from a drone deployment gets stored in our secure evidence, online evidence storage systems, evidence.com, run by the company Axon.

529
01:22:56.600 --> 01:23:02.950
City of El Cerrito: So those elements are not available to the public, but when we use them is available.

530
01:23:03.060 --> 01:23:09.990
City of El Cerrito: And we're always available to answer questions, too. If somebody says, why was there a drone in my neighborhood? If they call, we'll tell them. Thank you, Chief.

531
01:23:10.690 --> 01:23:20.460
City of El Cerrito: Councilmember Quesamas. Okay, we will go to, public, we're gonna open the public, hearing and announce.

532
01:23:20.850 --> 01:23:31.699
City of El Cerrito: The public hearing is now open. Now is the time for members of the public who wish to provide public comments regarding this item. Requests to speak can be submitted to the City Clerk by completing a speaker card.

533
01:23:31.700 --> 01:23:42.830
City of El Cerrito: Public comments will be taken in person only. Please remember to identify yourself and your city of residence at the beginning of your comments. City Clerk, please proceed.

534
01:23:42.830 --> 01:23:57.850
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor, and apologies, there was a typo in your script. We will take in-person and remote requests to speak on this hearing. Okay. We do have two, requests to speak. Can you confirm if you want to carry forward the 2-minute time limit, or if you want to revert to three? Wait, please. Okay.

535
01:24:08.090 --> 01:24:20.659
City of El Cerrito: Okay, so we will go to… we don't have any in-person requests, so we'll go to our remote requests to speak, starting with Jason Martins. Jason, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

536
01:24:21.520 --> 01:24:26.660
Jason Martens (he/him): Hi, thank you for taking the time to listen to me. I'm a resident of Berkeley,

537
01:24:26.700 --> 01:24:41.080
Jason Martens (he/him): And we have our own discussion happening right now about tear gas, and I just wanted to make sure everyone's aware tear gas is banned by the Geneva Convention for wartime use, so it's really shocking to me that we would consider

538
01:24:41.080 --> 01:24:55.919
Jason Martens (he/him): using such a weapon against our own citizens. So I hope you reconsider that use, and I'm happy to hear that it hasn't been used frequently, but maybe it's time to consider that this is just not a thing that we want to consider using, period.

539
01:24:55.940 --> 01:24:56.820
Jason Martens (he/him): Thank you.

540
01:24:57.960 --> 01:24:59.060
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

541
01:24:59.370 --> 01:25:05.229
City of El Cerrito: Go to our next request to speak, which is Ira. Ira, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

542
01:25:05.630 --> 01:25:11.629
ira: Yes, I wanted to speak on the library issue, and… but I was not allowed to speak.

543
01:25:11.870 --> 01:25:15.349
ira: So, I'm gonna, I'm gonna give that speech now.

544
01:25:15.770 --> 01:25:30.779
ira: With library usage in steep decline, please stop by our library and let our librarians know they are valued, even if relatively few people actually visit libraries to borrow physical books anymore.

545
01:25:30.980 --> 01:25:36.729
ira: I stopped by the library today to wish our excellent staff A happy National Library Week.

546
01:25:37.060 --> 01:25:40.510
ira: There were very few patrons there, as is so typical.

547
01:25:41.200 --> 01:25:46.980
ira: Here are some statistics for Contra Costa Library System from the State Library website.

548
01:25:47.230 --> 01:25:58.720
ira: I compared 2014 to the most current data on the state site, 2024, since the Measure C proposal is based on a 2014 needs analysis.

549
01:25:59.060 --> 01:26:00.770
ira: Library visits.

550
01:26:00.940 --> 01:26:02.790
ira: 2014?

551
01:26:02.910 --> 01:26:04.619
ira: 4.1 million.

552
01:26:04.840 --> 01:26:10.500
ira: 2024, $2.5 million. Change is a 40% deduction.

553
01:26:11.130 --> 01:26:12.649
ira: visits per hour.

554
01:26:12.930 --> 01:26:16.120
ira: 2014, 73 visits per hour.

555
01:26:16.260 --> 01:26:21.810
ira: 2024, 42 visits per hour. The change? A 43% reduction.

556
01:26:22.260 --> 01:26:25.109
ira: Now, there is one area where there was an increase.

557
01:26:25.310 --> 01:26:28.310
ira: Total operating expenditures per borrower.

558
01:26:28.570 --> 01:26:32.869
ira: 2014, $49.28.

559
01:26:33.110 --> 01:26:40.050
ira: 2024, $122.65. That's a 149% increase.

560
01:26:41.630 --> 01:26:46.970
ira: Now, I do have some El Cerrito-specific data, physical circulation.

561
01:26:47.090 --> 01:26:55.530
ira: I only have 2016 And 2024. 2016, 156,573.

562
01:26:55.870 --> 01:26:59.789
ira: And 2024, $121,247.

563
01:27:00.080 --> 01:27:02.309
ira: That's a 29% reduction.

564
01:27:03.270 --> 01:27:06.349
ira: For those who think Measure C will produce a new library.

565
01:27:06.820 --> 01:27:09.830
ira: Please provide the following basic information.

566
01:27:10.230 --> 01:27:12.110
ira: Where will the library be?

567
01:27:12.970 --> 01:27:14.989
ira: When will the library be built?

568
01:27:15.580 --> 01:27:18.569
ira: What services do you want to cut? Police?

569
01:27:18.780 --> 01:27:21.320
ira: Fire. Swimming pool closure?

570
01:27:21.820 --> 01:27:28.509
ira: The tax is not sufficient to pay for bond repayments and operating costs. What services do you want to cut?

571
01:27:28.790 --> 01:27:30.220
ira: Thank you very much.

572
01:27:33.890 --> 01:27:34.730
ira: Thank you.

573
01:27:36.140 --> 01:27:39.360
City of El Cerrito: We'll go to our next request to speak, is David Hatton.

574
01:27:39.810 --> 01:27:42.660
City of El Cerrito: David, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

575
01:27:53.390 --> 01:27:55.140
City of El Cerrito: Are you… are you there, David?

576
01:27:56.380 --> 01:27:58.559
City of El Cerrito: We're not hearing any audio from you.

577
01:28:03.930 --> 01:28:12.579
City of El Cerrito: Okay, looks like there might be some challenges on the speaker's end we're not able to hear, and that is the last request to speak on this item, Mayor. Okay.

578
01:28:18.610 --> 01:28:21.240
City of El Cerrito: So, do I have a motion to close the public hearing?

579
01:28:22.620 --> 01:28:28.429
City of El Cerrito: Second. I have a motion by Mayor Pro Tem and a second by Councilmember Motayama. All in favor?

580
01:28:29.090 --> 01:28:30.490
City of El Cerrito: Aye. Aye.

581
01:28:30.720 --> 01:28:37.869
City of El Cerrito: Motion passes. Next we'll bring it to the Council. Any comments? Lasting comments?

582
01:28:41.040 --> 01:28:41.720
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

583
01:28:42.770 --> 01:28:44.379
City of El Cerrito: Do I have a motion to approve?

584
01:28:46.050 --> 01:28:47.320
City of El Cerrito: Move approval?

585
01:28:47.910 --> 01:28:49.580
City of El Cerrito: Do you have a second? Second.

586
01:28:49.730 --> 01:28:57.530
City of El Cerrito: We have a motion by Mayor Pro Tem Saltzman and a second from Councilmember Motayama. All in favor? Aye. Aye.

587
01:28:58.320 --> 01:29:01.390
City of El Cerrito: Any nays? Abstentions? Motion passes.

588
01:29:01.840 --> 01:29:03.079
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much.

589
01:29:03.400 --> 01:29:09.489
City of El Cerrito: Next, we'll go to Policy Matters, and that is the flock safety agreement renewal.

590
01:29:10.840 --> 01:29:12.679
City of El Cerrito: Maybe I have a staff report.

591
01:29:20.290 --> 01:29:24.279
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, Mayor and Council. I have returned. I'm Paul Keith, your Chief of Police.

592
01:29:24.840 --> 01:29:31.849
City of El Cerrito: So I'm here tonight, and I have a representative from Flock Safety also in the meeting. Her name is Katie Dauphine.

593
01:29:32.490 --> 01:29:38.329
City of El Cerrito: The reason I'm here is to discuss the renewal of the Flock License Plate Reader Services Agreement.

594
01:29:38.980 --> 01:29:41.620
City of El Cerrito: So, let's start off by talking about what is Flock?

595
01:29:41.850 --> 01:29:47.920
City of El Cerrito: So we contract with a company called Flock Safety for the provision of license plate reader cameras in El Cerrito.

596
01:29:48.130 --> 01:29:53.739
City of El Cerrito: In total, we have 40 cameras positioned around town, and they serve a dual purpose.

597
01:29:53.990 --> 01:30:03.789
City of El Cerrito: First is that they act as an early warning system when a vehicle passes… sorry, the first is they act as an early warning system, and the second is they act as an investigative aid.

598
01:30:03.990 --> 01:30:19.650
City of El Cerrito: As an early warning system, they check license plates on vehicles against state hot lists. So when a vehicle comes by, a camera, and it's a wanted vehicle or a stolen vehicle, it'll send an alert to our police officers notifying of the time

599
01:30:19.650 --> 01:30:29.330
City of El Cerrito: the vehicle description, and the location the vehicle was seen. It gives our officers an opportunity to confirm the wanted nature of the vehicle, and also intercept the vehicle.

600
01:30:29.800 --> 01:30:38.079
City of El Cerrito: As an investigative aid, these cameras take photographs of the rear of vehicles and retain those photographs for a period of 30 days.

601
01:30:38.480 --> 01:30:47.939
City of El Cerrito: In the aftermath of a crime, it allows our investigators to obtain suspect vehicle information, to search for the vehicle using our license plate reader system.

602
01:30:48.070 --> 01:30:56.120
City of El Cerrito: And ideally, identify a person of interest in the crime, or at least confirm whether a vehicle was involved in a crime.

603
01:30:57.140 --> 01:31:03.370
City of El Cerrito: License plate reading cameras and power officers act on data and intelligence, and not punches and intuition.

604
01:31:03.700 --> 01:31:08.200
City of El Cerrito: The system helps them target and identify vehicles that have been linked to crime with strong evidence.

605
01:31:08.340 --> 01:31:13.209
City of El Cerrito: LPR systems increase the likelihood that officers are stopping the right car and the correct people.

606
01:31:14.290 --> 01:31:18.750
City of El Cerrito: The item before you tonight is renewal of agreements with Block Safety.

607
01:31:19.270 --> 01:31:23.430
City of El Cerrito: So, there are at least 3 alternatives before you tonight.

608
01:31:23.770 --> 01:31:28.849
City of El Cerrito: The first alternative is to renew the existing agreement that we currently have with Flock.

609
01:31:29.740 --> 01:31:35.649
City of El Cerrito: The second alternative is to decline to renew the existing agreement and enter into a new agreement with Flock.

610
01:31:35.790 --> 01:31:40.659
City of El Cerrito: As has been added as a supplemental material to the meeting tonight.

611
01:31:41.320 --> 01:31:47.980
City of El Cerrito: And the third alternative is to decline to renew the existing agreement, and also decline to enter into a new agreement.

612
01:31:48.780 --> 01:31:51.330
City of El Cerrito: So first, let's talk about the existing agreement.

613
01:31:51.750 --> 01:31:56.680
City of El Cerrito: Current agreement was signed in March of 2023. It was approved by City Council.

614
01:31:57.050 --> 01:32:02.089
City of El Cerrito: The term began with the installation of our first camera on June 7th, 2023.

615
01:32:02.570 --> 01:32:08.590
City of El Cerrito: The agreement runs for a term of 3 years and expires on June 6th of 2026.

616
01:32:08.830 --> 01:32:18.990
City of El Cerrito: This agreement has a renewal clause, meaning they will auto-renewal for an additional 3-year term if the city has not indicated that they do not want to renew.

617
01:32:19.440 --> 01:32:23.009
City of El Cerrito: Before 30 days before the expiration of the term.

618
01:32:23.320 --> 01:32:32.240
City of El Cerrito: In other words, we need to tell Flock Safety if we do not want to renew before May 6, 2026, otherwise the agreement will automatically renew.

619
01:32:33.280 --> 01:32:39.730
City of El Cerrito: Flock has provided us with new rates for the renewal of the existing agreement, and rates for a new agreement.

620
01:32:40.430 --> 01:32:48.420
City of El Cerrito: These rates would be $105,000 annually, which is $1,500 more per year than the current agreement.

621
01:32:49.700 --> 01:32:53.180
City of El Cerrito: Staff have also been working with Flock to put together a new agreement.

622
01:32:53.460 --> 01:32:57.719
City of El Cerrito: In the event that the city does not want to move forward with an automatic renewal.

623
01:32:58.100 --> 01:33:08.110
City of El Cerrito: Staff's focus in these negotiations has been on adding protections against unwanted sharing with federal or out-of-state agencies, or including language to penalize sharing.

624
01:33:10.270 --> 01:33:15.420
City of El Cerrito: The current proposed agreement is the outcome of

625
01:33:15.970 --> 01:33:18.940
City of El Cerrito: Coming up on 2 months of negotiation with Flock.

626
01:33:19.610 --> 01:33:23.690
City of El Cerrito: It includes, as its most compelling feature.

627
01:33:23.850 --> 01:33:30.320
City of El Cerrito: A $34,500 penalty if Flock shares data without our authorization.

628
01:33:30.830 --> 01:33:40.329
City of El Cerrito: So the idea is that this penalty would serve as a strong disincentive to Flock to share with other law enforcement agencies that we do not approve of.

629
01:33:41.350 --> 01:33:46.169
City of El Cerrito: The agreement also allows for termination in the event of a violation of law.

630
01:33:46.470 --> 01:34:04.479
City of El Cerrito: However, another thing to think about is that the agreement also includes a survival clause. So, if we were to terminate the agreement, Block would still be bound by that penalty clause during the period that the cameras are still up in El Cerrito before they're taken down.

631
01:34:04.840 --> 01:34:14.060
City of El Cerrito: So it does provide some additional coverage to us, or at least a penalty for sharing, should the sharing occur after an agreement is terminated.

632
01:34:14.770 --> 01:34:25.700
City of El Cerrito: Now, the current agreement on the termination clause, we would still be obligated to pay for the agreement if we were to terminate the agreement. However, it allows us to terminate the agreement.

633
01:34:26.420 --> 01:34:37.600
City of El Cerrito: Is this everything we asked for in agreement? No, it is not. But it is, a compromise that came as a result of back-and-forth negotiations with Flock.

634
01:34:39.790 --> 01:34:48.019
City of El Cerrito: On March 10th, I held a meeting to talk to the public about, unauthorized access to our data.

635
01:34:48.240 --> 01:34:59.890
City of El Cerrito: And, I also took as an opportunity to hear community concerns, in the hope that I could help voice some of those concerns tonight, and talk about ways that the police department has tried to address those concerns.

636
01:35:00.280 --> 01:35:02.640
City of El Cerrito: So, on March 10th, we held a meeting.

637
01:35:03.290 --> 01:35:05.959
City of El Cerrito: to hear concerns.

638
01:35:06.490 --> 01:35:09.920
City of El Cerrito: So, first I'd like to talk about access to the system.

639
01:35:10.080 --> 01:35:17.009
City of El Cerrito: So, flock safety and our own recent experience with this system, have demonstrated that the newest iteration of flock safety

640
01:35:17.150 --> 01:35:20.889
City of El Cerrito: The program has increased protections against unwanted sharing.

641
01:35:21.100 --> 01:35:27.909
City of El Cerrito: The system no longer allows California departments to opt-in to sharing with agencies outside of the state of California.

642
01:35:28.170 --> 01:35:31.450
City of El Cerrito: Literally can't click a button to make that happen.

643
01:35:31.920 --> 01:35:41.090
City of El Cerrito: It also includes disclaimers for users about authorized use of the system, identifying that the use of the system for immigration or reproductive enforcement is prohibited when you log in.

644
01:35:42.340 --> 01:35:51.760
City of El Cerrito: We have confirmed that these settings now make it so that we cannot change settings to allow out-of-state access. There's no way for us to make that happen.

645
01:35:52.360 --> 01:35:58.249
City of El Cerrito: In addition, the system also uses multi-factor authentication to increase data security.

646
01:35:59.600 --> 01:36:11.800
City of El Cerrito: Other concerns were voiced by the public, relating to access, revolved around the Foreign Intelligence and Surveillance Act of 1978, particularly Section 702 of that act.

647
01:36:12.110 --> 01:36:21.849
City of El Cerrito: So this section allows for surveillance of foreign powers and foreign agents, typically involving investigations into international terrorism and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction.

648
01:36:22.030 --> 01:36:33.080
City of El Cerrito: Recent changes to the Act also allow for the use for the surveillance of lone wolf actors in the United States that might be acting in support of foreign terrorist organizations.

649
01:36:34.040 --> 01:36:47.070
City of El Cerrito: The target of an investigation like this must be a foreign power or an agent of a foreign power, or a lone wolf actor, as I described. And the surveillance has to be done to obtain foreign intelligence information.

650
01:36:47.540 --> 01:37:00.800
City of El Cerrito: Some community members worry the federal government could use this act, FISA, to access El Strita license plate reader business records to target people inside the United States. This use of the act would really be outside of the scope of FISA,

651
01:37:01.630 --> 01:37:20.020
City of El Cerrito: Additionally, when it comes to investigations into international or domestic terrorism, there's nothing in California law that prevents California law enforcement agencies from cooperating with federal investigators on investigations into domestic criminal cases.

652
01:37:20.240 --> 01:37:26.199
City of El Cerrito: Police departments all across California currently team up with the FBI and other federal agencies to investigate serious crimes.

653
01:37:26.490 --> 01:37:35.850
City of El Cerrito: FBI, for example, had a case involving international or domestic terrorism that had a root in El Cerrito, then we would be there to assist with their investigation.

654
01:37:37.370 --> 01:37:51.609
City of El Cerrito: Other community members shared concerns about physical hardware, and they helpfully pointed me to a video on YouTube. It's about a 43-minute video that describes how a person was able to circumvent some of the controls on a flock camera.

655
01:37:51.610 --> 01:38:04.740
City of El Cerrito: I talked with Flock about that, and Flock is… and I have a member of Flock here, so I will admit that I am not the hardware guru of the entire world. But I had talked to Flock about, those,

656
01:38:04.740 --> 01:38:16.729
City of El Cerrito: Methods of defeating security issues on flock cameras, and they believe that they've connected any… they've corrected any security issues, that would have been, possible through following the video.

657
01:38:17.710 --> 01:38:26.859
City of El Cerrito: But one thing that is important to remember is that, flock cameras are physical installations, so these are cameras that are mounted 7 to 9 feet at poles around town.

658
01:38:27.030 --> 01:38:37.599
City of El Cerrito: They, basically consist of a power supply, which is a solar panel, a cellular connection, a camera, and a processor. So, if a person were to steal or tamper with these units.

659
01:38:37.600 --> 01:38:51.379
City of El Cerrito: there's a possibility they could put any of these components to use. They might be able to tap into the camera feed, much like they could with any other security camera installation, if someone came in and tampered with the cameras in and around the city hall.

660
01:38:51.470 --> 01:39:00.949
City of El Cerrito: They could potentially, you know, reuse the components of those cameras, hijack feeds, or see what the camera's seeing through being there physically.

661
01:39:01.480 --> 01:39:20.899
City of El Cerrito: But tampering with the camera does not allow a person to gain access to the license plate image database. So they may be able to see what the camera sees, they may be able to see processing happening at the site of the camera, but it doesn't allow them to access Flock's database. It just allows them to basically see what the camera's doing.

662
01:39:22.370 --> 01:39:25.950
City of El Cerrito: But I also have somebody here from Flock to explain in detail if you need more detail.

663
01:39:27.000 --> 01:39:37.370
City of El Cerrito: The committee also expressed concerns about audits. One of the ideas presented by committee members involved a third-party audit of system use.

664
01:39:37.640 --> 01:39:42.740
City of El Cerrito: Something that might be included in a contract with Flock, or something that we might do on our own.

665
01:39:43.020 --> 01:39:50.909
City of El Cerrito: Certainly auditing data is something that has been high on our radar ever since we found that some federal agencies had access to our data.

666
01:39:51.940 --> 01:40:04.710
City of El Cerrito: So, one thing that's important to know is that after we turned on our account controls, we had two unauthorized accesses by federal agents. One was the U.S. Postal Service Investigations Unit.

667
01:40:04.890 --> 01:40:09.990
City of El Cerrito: And the other was the Veterans Affairs Police Department for the Loma Linda Healthcare Systems.

668
01:40:10.680 --> 01:40:18.330
City of El Cerrito: We have no evidence that any other federal or out-of-state agencies have been accessing our data since we had control over the account.

669
01:40:18.780 --> 01:40:26.169
City of El Cerrito: We believe that those audit logs are accurate because they helped us detect the two federal agencies' access

670
01:40:26.590 --> 01:40:33.860
City of El Cerrito: during our audits. So, they, detected what we intended for them to detect, unauthorized access to the system.

671
01:40:34.340 --> 01:40:43.779
City of El Cerrito: To help respond to the public's concern about regular audits, we now post the… we posted all of our back audit logs from the initiation of the system to present.

672
01:40:44.050 --> 01:40:57.139
City of El Cerrito: And we're also going to be posting monthly audits from this point forward, and importantly, conducting thorough monthly audits to make sure that the use of the system is in line with our permissions and authorizations.

673
01:40:58.400 --> 01:41:13.339
City of El Cerrito: The system has been, in my opinion, very successful. I list 9 different cases in the report that I felt highlighted over the time we've had the system, some great, cases that were helped… that were solved with the help of the system.

674
01:41:13.390 --> 01:41:29.989
City of El Cerrito: But there are some other kind of impacts of the system. One of them, I was looking at clearance rates, because I said, well, what are some other ways we might be able to see the impact of license plate reader systems? And I will say, I haven't used any kind of control agencies against this. I'm just looking at our data.

675
01:41:30.050 --> 01:41:46.009
City of El Cerrito: So between 23, when we installed the cameras, and 2024, we had a 10% increase in our violent crime clearance rate. It's actually the highest our violent crime rate… clearance rate has been in 10 years. 31% of all violent crimes solved.

676
01:41:46.250 --> 01:41:49.630
City of El Cerrito: Looking for it to go higher. This is a good start.

677
01:41:49.910 --> 01:42:00.840
City of El Cerrito: We also had a 100% increase in our clearance rate for property crimes. 10% could be higher, we're working on that. We had a nice bump from 23 to 2024.

678
01:42:01.300 --> 01:42:12.280
City of El Cerrito: We also experienced, and last year, in 2025, we experienced the lowest burglary rate we've had in 40 years, the lowest car theft rate we've had in 40 years, and the second lowest robbery rate we've had in 40 years.

679
01:42:12.920 --> 01:42:17.760
City of El Cerrito: So, I want to reiterate the actions before you tonight.

680
01:42:17.920 --> 01:42:25.610
City of El Cerrito: at least 3 of your options. There may be other options I haven't thought of as well. But, 3 of your options tonight. You can approve the renewal as is.

681
01:42:25.790 --> 01:42:32.389
City of El Cerrito: You can decline the renewal and approve a new agreement as included in the packet, or you can decline the renewal and decline the new agreement.

682
01:42:33.440 --> 01:42:44.989
City of El Cerrito: These cameras have been an excellent tool to give our officers accurate intelligence to investigate serious crimes in El Cerrito. We have not found any other modern tool that has had the same impact on our ability to solve crime.

683
01:42:45.120 --> 01:42:49.230
City of El Cerrito: Particularly the crimes of robbery, burglary, vehicle theft, and hit-and-runs.

684
01:42:50.090 --> 01:43:00.790
City of El Cerrito: I and my staff recommend declining to renew the existing agreement and approving the City Manager to enter into the new proposed agreement with Block Safety.

685
01:43:01.640 --> 01:43:05.180
City of El Cerrito: Of course, I'm available to answer any questions that you might have.

686
01:43:05.530 --> 01:43:12.880
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Chief. We'll start to my left over here. Who would like to, ask to… Councilmember Cosanis, go ahead.

687
01:43:14.770 --> 01:43:19.949
City of El Cerrito: Chief, thank you very much for your presentation, and thank you, too, for

688
01:43:20.150 --> 01:43:30.040
City of El Cerrito: the March 10th information meeting with the community, I attended that, and thank you for taking note of the concerns that people had and addressing at least some of them, if not many of them.

689
01:43:30.330 --> 01:43:31.940
City of El Cerrito: I just want to say.

690
01:43:32.090 --> 01:43:34.979
City of El Cerrito: I expressed this at the last council meeting, I requested

691
01:43:35.300 --> 01:43:39.020
City of El Cerrito: to have, a study session on this issue. And the reason is.

692
01:43:39.380 --> 01:43:41.660
City of El Cerrito: And I've been on the council a year and a half, and I think

693
01:43:41.980 --> 01:43:51.449
City of El Cerrito: this is the most consequential item that's come before us, for me. And I look at it that way because I know it's contentious, I know there are two sides.

694
01:43:51.620 --> 01:44:10.559
City of El Cerrito: But at the core, it is asking people to agree to give… give up some of their civil liberties. And we do that every day. We do it in different ways, and there are times when, you know, people's comfort with that level… comfort with that is across the spectrum. There are people who are extreme on either end, and most people are somewhere in the middle.

695
01:44:10.800 --> 01:44:22.540
City of El Cerrito: I don't feel informed to take a vote on it. I've read and read, I've talked to people, I've sat in your information sessions, I've sat in another information session with the Public Safety Committee.

696
01:44:22.830 --> 01:44:31.619
City of El Cerrito: And I just… I feel very strongly still that we need to get more information. I appreciate that you're here, I appreciate that the representative from Flock is here.

697
01:44:31.680 --> 01:44:44.150
City of El Cerrito: But what I see missing is any representation from the groups of people who are concerned about civil liberties and have that perspective. I'm not saying one is right and one is wrong, I just feel incomplete in terms of the information I've gotten.

698
01:44:45.750 --> 01:44:58.269
City of El Cerrito: And it really bothers me that we would, you know… I've been told that, okay, we've already done this before, this is a renewal of a contract that happened 3 years ago, and I appreciate that it's not on the consent calendar, I think initially that was a possibility.

699
01:44:58.420 --> 01:45:03.470
City of El Cerrito: But I wasn't here 3 years ago, so I haven't been… you know, I didn't have that kind of in-depth

700
01:45:03.670 --> 01:45:08.059
City of El Cerrito: education about it. And I've tried to get that education on my own.

701
01:45:08.280 --> 01:45:11.140
City of El Cerrito: I don't… you know, I still feel…

702
01:45:11.320 --> 01:45:18.310
City of El Cerrito: that I'm not there. So I just want to let you know that I appreciate your work on it, absolutely. I understand the value to you.

703
01:45:18.440 --> 01:45:30.220
City of El Cerrito: But I also understand there's another perspective that we've not heard that I think we deserve to ourselves, whatever our position is going to end up being, to have heard that perspective. And I'll leave it at that. That's where I stand.

704
01:45:30.460 --> 01:45:31.460
City of El Cerrito: Understand.

705
01:45:34.580 --> 01:45:37.840
City of El Cerrito: Thank you so much for your presentation.

706
01:45:38.260 --> 01:45:50.420
City of El Cerrito: Chief, and, you know, this is definitely an important issue. I understand all the questions that have been raised around privacy, and they are very serious. They're very serious issues.

707
01:45:50.440 --> 01:46:06.890
City of El Cerrito: You know, I know that there's been a lot of information about who did or didn't access the system, which, whoever it was, it's very important, and very serious that it was accessed. I understand that the people who did access it was only

708
01:46:06.890 --> 01:46:31.890
City of El Cerrito: the postal service, and, you know, it concerns me that there are people out there saying that it was directly the FBI. You know, that's always a big thing for me, is I want people to have accurate information. El Cerrito is definitely one of those cities where we're very active and engaged, especially in national issues. We're not always as active and engaged in what's actually happening in El Cerrito, so that's a concern for me. But also, what I did in my research on the issue is I wanted to

709
01:46:31.890 --> 01:46:56.869
City of El Cerrito: listen to the perspectives of cities who've already had their conversation, cities like Richmond, cities like Oakland, who have actually, had this presentation. I wanted to really listen to… I'll be very honest and transparent. I want to listen to the perspectives of council members who represent the folks who I represent, you know, Black women, queer women, queer people, and kind of a nod to our soon-to-be conversation

710
01:46:56.870 --> 01:46:58.579
City of El Cerrito: Later on in the agenda.

711
01:46:58.710 --> 01:47:14.920
City of El Cerrito: I live in the area where the majority of the cameras are. I live right on the avenue in the place not only where the majority of the cameras are, but where we're going to be building more housing for, low-income communities, POC communities, young families.

712
01:47:14.920 --> 01:47:33.400
City of El Cerrito: I think, though, that while I have a lot of questions, I don't… I'm not gonna ask those questions tonight, because I am appreciative that there were other options that were given to us, but the downside of having a working council is I got those updated options at noon, and I was working. So I've read them.

713
01:47:33.470 --> 01:47:53.629
City of El Cerrito: Unfortunately, sometimes supplemental information comes later, and we don't have time to read it, and this is a very important issue that we're going to be going over, so if it becomes the will of the Council to delay this item, as long as… the concern I have is I don't want us to be in a situation like they were in Richmond, where their cameras are off, so if we decide that we don't want to vote on this tonight, does that

714
01:47:53.630 --> 01:47:56.440
City of El Cerrito: turn off the cameras. I don't want to be in that situation.

715
01:47:56.800 --> 01:48:04.629
City of El Cerrito: So no, it won't turn off the cameras. Just as an example, the next council meeting, May 5th.

716
01:48:04.750 --> 01:48:07.180
City of El Cerrito: We'll bring us down to the wire, but…

717
01:48:07.180 --> 01:48:25.409
City of El Cerrito: will give us time to say we don't want to renew in the event. And making a decision not to renew means that the cameras will stay on through the natural term of the agreement, so through June 6th. Because I think there were a lot of questions about what the accountability measures would be, what the new,

718
01:48:25.410 --> 01:48:44.909
City of El Cerrito: I love the fact that we are going to be making sure that we're at least making them pay if they do actually access the cameras when they're not supposed to, et cetera, et cetera. But I don't think that we have enough of the information, and now we have additional options to consider. I just don't feel comfortable voting up or down tonight. I don't feel comfortable renewing tonight.

719
01:48:44.910 --> 01:48:49.680
City of El Cerrito: So… And, just for those listening at home who maybe didn't read the packet.

720
01:48:49.680 --> 01:49:14.419
City of El Cerrito: Our negotiations with Flock continue through the weekend, so for the new proposed agreement, we've got our legal review completed yesterday, so we attached it today and sent it to Council, but, it really was going on all during the process of putting this agenda item together and through the weekend. And then, to be clear, that's not an up or down yay or nay. I don't want anyone to leave out of here saying, you know, this is…

721
01:49:14.420 --> 01:49:17.079
City of El Cerrito: This is the road towards a down or an up.

722
01:49:17.080 --> 01:49:25.520
City of El Cerrito: But I think that this does require a little bit more thoughtfulness and a few more questions than the one that I even had today, and I'm just not ready to do that right now.

723
01:49:25.960 --> 01:49:27.660
City of El Cerrito: With that, I am complete, Mayor.

724
01:49:27.830 --> 01:49:29.870
City of El Cerrito: Let's go to Councilmember Gautiana.

725
01:49:30.850 --> 01:49:31.550
City of El Cerrito: Okay?

726
01:49:31.690 --> 01:49:35.719
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Chief, for,

727
01:49:36.710 --> 01:49:40.300
City of El Cerrito: going into this really thorough presentation, and I really…

728
01:49:40.890 --> 01:49:56.219
City of El Cerrito: appreciate the new, agreement that you've negotiated. And, you know, I do agree with Councilmember Weisinger. I think, you know, I would like to have the public have a chance to read how different this new agreement is from the past one.

729
01:49:56.440 --> 01:50:03.909
City of El Cerrito: So, I do have a bunch of questions. I think they're mostly to the flock representative.

730
01:50:04.560 --> 01:50:10.889
City of El Cerrito: So, should I just… Go… okay. Sure. Okay, so…

731
01:50:12.140 --> 01:50:20.170
City of El Cerrito: Katie, can you further describe the advanced optional features in our, order form.

732
01:50:20.940 --> 01:50:22.220
City of El Cerrito: Or a contract.

733
01:50:22.630 --> 01:50:35.069
City of El Cerrito: They are convoy analysis, multi-geo search, visual search, cradle point integration for automatic vehicle location, and common plate analysis.

734
01:50:37.140 --> 01:50:41.670
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): I can defer to, Chief Keith on that, but I believe it's enhancements in our ALPR software.

735
01:50:43.410 --> 01:50:45.810
City of El Cerrito: So I… I can't answer those questions.

736
01:50:46.180 --> 01:50:55.350
City of El Cerrito: So, I'm gonna just kind of walk through each of those items. So, the convoy search mode basically allows a user to enter a license plate.

737
01:50:55.460 --> 01:51:09.620
City of El Cerrito: And the system will see what other vehicles it recognized in the vicinity of that vehicle. The idea is, if you have multiple vehicles traveling to the path of a crime, it may give you some investigative leads as to who else was a co-conspirator in the crime.

738
01:51:09.700 --> 01:51:25.489
City of El Cerrito: How it might be used, you can, well, there's one incident in El Cerrito where we had a burglary of a cigarette shop. I can't remember if they arrived in Convoy, but we did have two different vehicles. We identified the second vehicle, lookout vehicle, through our flock system.

739
01:51:25.510 --> 01:51:37.759
City of El Cerrito: But you can also think about the jewelry store robbery in San Ramon, where there was multiple vehicles that traveled to this jewelry store in San Ramon, did a big, takeover robbery at the store. That feature would be used for cases like that.

740
01:51:38.320 --> 01:51:58.210
City of El Cerrito: Multi-geo search. I have to say, I was kind of trying to figure out how I would use this one, but basically it allows you to look for a plate that appeared in more than one location. So you can specify a number of different camera locations and say, I want you to search these camera locations for this plate, as opposed to doing a normal search where you put a plate in there and it gives you every location.

741
01:51:58.210 --> 01:52:01.620
City of El Cerrito: So, you would specify locations that the vehicle passed by.

742
01:52:02.020 --> 01:52:14.499
City of El Cerrito: A visual search, I mean, thank you for this. I'm not a normal, regular user of the system, so I had to jump in and figure out what some of these things did. A visual search allows you to take a photograph of a car.

743
01:52:14.700 --> 01:52:27.870
City of El Cerrito: upload into the system, and it'll do a visual analysis of that image and try to locate that in the database. So, if you give it a white Honda Accord, it's going to try to find that particular white Honda Accord through its database of images.

744
01:52:28.150 --> 01:52:43.679
City of El Cerrito: Cradle Point is an automatic vehicle locating application. We don't currently use it. While it might be available to it, we just don't use it. It basically tracks our own fleet's location, through the Flock app, so we can see, kind of, live time where our vehicles are going.

745
01:52:44.010 --> 01:52:50.479
City of El Cerrito: And common plate analysis refers to the core functionality of the system. It allows you to put into a license plate, search for it.

746
01:52:50.600 --> 01:52:53.090
City of El Cerrito: So that's kind of a summary of those.

747
01:52:54.060 --> 01:53:03.859
City of El Cerrito: Okay, thank you. My next question is, have there been any instances of hacking into our system since it's web-based?

748
01:53:04.780 --> 01:53:08.569
City of El Cerrito: So, no instances that we know of of hacking into our system.

749
01:53:08.680 --> 01:53:13.289
City of El Cerrito: I will let Flock answer whether or not they feel that their system has ever been hacked.

750
01:53:14.410 --> 01:53:32.079
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): Thank you, Chief. Our system has never been hacked. We are aware of the videos that are circulating on social media, TikTok and YouTube, and we take the claims that were made in those videos very seriously, and so once we saw those, we immediately sprung into action to partner with trusted agencies like the Miami-Dade Electronics Crimes Task Force.

751
01:53:32.080 --> 01:53:52.529
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): to go through the claims that were made in this video, examine our hardware to see if they're true, and they found, through, video testimony, that none of the claims in these videos about hacking are true. In addition, because we know that it is a constant battle with cybersecurity, we've implemented, and deployed Sitecode, which is a tool that scans all of our source code for security issues.

752
01:53:52.530 --> 01:54:07.880
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): We also are on offensive testing, and we've engaged with the, Bishop Fox, which is a premier security firm, to conduct full-stack penetration testing and be proactive about fixing, and finding potential weaknesses in our system. That's a long story, just to say that, no, we have not been hacked.

753
01:54:09.650 --> 01:54:26.150
City of El Cerrito: So, I know in the current agreement, hacking is considered force majeure, and I did see that in the new agreement, it's not there anymore. So, what was your… if the system is so good, why would you include that as force majeure?

754
01:54:29.400 --> 01:54:45.580
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): I believe it's, and I can defer to Chief Keith, because he's been directly involved with these negotiations, but it's, I believe, just a goodwill on our side, just to say that we do take these offenses very seriously, and so, just to show that we do believe in our product, and we believe that security is top of mind, that we want to ensure that that does not happen in these systems.

755
01:54:45.840 --> 01:54:48.320
City of El Cerrito: Okay, thank you.

756
01:54:50.380 --> 01:54:58.320
City of El Cerrito: Have we ever been notified by Flock of any use of the data as part of a legal requirement from a third party?

757
01:54:58.590 --> 01:55:00.979
City of El Cerrito: No. Okay, and…

758
01:55:01.340 --> 01:55:13.530
City of El Cerrito: What safeguards have you implemented since CalMatters found data sharing with Homeland Security and Border Patrol in LA, Orange County, and San Diego in June of last year?

759
01:55:14.150 --> 01:55:16.919
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): I'm so sorry, my internet broke up. Can you repeat the question?

760
01:55:17.110 --> 01:55:31.869
City of El Cerrito: Okay, so there was an article in CalMatters, they found data sharing with Homeland Security, Border Patrol in Los Angeles, Orange County, and San Diego in June of 2025. So…

761
01:55:32.460 --> 01:55:34.989
City of El Cerrito: What have you done since then, so that doesn't happen?

762
01:55:35.530 --> 01:55:59.160
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): Yeah, so we've worked directly with agencies to ensure that there's no, you know, automatic opt-in to these things. We give the agency 100% control, and there's no default setting that says, okay, you're automatically opted into all these federal sharing programs. The agency themselves have to decide what agencies and federal programs to opt into. For example, in the El Salido Transparency Portal, you can see that you are opted into the Amber Alerts.

763
01:55:59.160 --> 01:56:09.459
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): But no other federal sharing programs. And so, we rely on the agency because they're the ones that directly know what agencies they want to partner with, what they're legally allowed to partner with, and the community values to ensure that doesn't happen.

764
01:56:11.290 --> 01:56:14.529
City of El Cerrito: So… so how did that happen in the first place?

765
01:56:15.490 --> 01:56:32.560
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): I can talk to our technical team on that. I just believe that it was more, it's… it's ever-evolving about how the users are using the agencies are using the product, and so, we believe it might have just been an oversight, but again, I can get more technical information from our team if that's helpful.

766
01:56:33.300 --> 01:56:36.780
City of El Cerrito: So, basically, it would be bad actors sharing the data.

767
01:56:36.890 --> 01:56:46.050
City of El Cerrito: Themselves, from these, entities, okay? And… My last question is.

768
01:56:46.190 --> 01:56:54.510
City of El Cerrito: in the… and this is probably a Chief Keith question, is the aggregated data provision still included in the new agreement? I couldn't see that.

769
01:56:54.820 --> 01:56:57.409
City of El Cerrito: If it was there. Oh, I'd have to…

770
01:56:57.560 --> 01:57:09.370
City of El Cerrito: do my read-through of it. I don't remember seeing it in there. Okay. It was in the original agreement, though. Yes, I did see that. So I did… I didn't… do not remember seeing it in the new agreement. Okay.

771
01:57:09.680 --> 01:57:13.809
City of El Cerrito: Great. Yeah, so I…

772
01:57:14.390 --> 01:57:33.830
City of El Cerrito: I do think that we do need time for, like, the rest of the Council to get a chance to read in detail the new agreement, and like I said, I would like the public to have a chance to read that as well. And, you know, I want to thank you and your staff for really pushing on all these things that are really important for us.

773
01:57:34.550 --> 01:57:39.149
City of El Cerrito: I understand, thank you. And thank you, Katie.

774
01:57:39.150 --> 01:57:39.609
Katie Dauphinais (FLOCK): Thank you.

775
01:57:39.610 --> 01:57:41.209
City of El Cerrito: Next is, the mayor part-time.

776
01:57:41.620 --> 01:58:04.049
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. First, just want to thank you, Chief, and anybody at the City who worked on the revised agreement. You did make some important progress, and it sounds like you put a lot of work into that, so I really appreciate that you listen to the community, and we're trying to improve the agreement. That said, I, like many of the other council members, I also work, and I

777
01:58:04.050 --> 01:58:16.949
City of El Cerrito: I read your memo, but I could not read the whole new agreement, the new contract, so I'm not prepared to vote on this tonight, and would propose we bring this back on

778
01:58:16.950 --> 01:58:25.270
City of El Cerrito: May 5th, but when we bring it back, I'd like to see there to be more options, so I'd like you to do some more negotiating with Flock.

779
01:58:27.770 --> 01:58:43.499
City of El Cerrito: I haven't read it yet, but based on your memo, I don't think I'm gonna be comfortable with it, because, like you said, you didn't get everything you wanted, and then, you know, I'm glad to see that there would be repercussions for unauthorized sharing.

780
01:58:43.610 --> 01:58:52.620
City of El Cerrito: But the problem with this is, is the penalty does not apply to what are called lawful processes, emergencies, or regulatory compulsion.

781
01:58:52.840 --> 01:59:02.619
City of El Cerrito: And we know that our federal government currently is not to be trusted. We know that Donald Trump does not believe in the rule of law, and very…

782
01:59:02.640 --> 01:59:27.590
City of El Cerrito: unfortunately, and maybe slightly more surprising, the Supreme Court doesn't either. So these things could change in the next 3 years. So if we get into this 3-year contract, a few months in, they could just change things, and all of a sudden, it's lawful for them. We've… we're out of the money. Even if we decide and vote to turn off the agreement, we still paid all the money. They keep it. They don't have to pay any penalty, because all of this

783
01:59:27.590 --> 01:59:29.120
City of El Cerrito: All of a sudden is lawful.

784
01:59:29.190 --> 01:59:31.359
City of El Cerrito: So, it just doesn't…

785
01:59:31.390 --> 01:59:38.889
City of El Cerrito: It doesn't really have any teeth, how it's written right now. Under another administration, maybe I'd feel like it had more teeth.

786
01:59:38.890 --> 01:59:57.170
City of El Cerrito: But currently, it just… it doesn't. And again, I'm not faulting you, like, I feel like you really tried and are trying to make this better, but it… it doesn't make me feel comfortable under the current situation we're in, which is very different than situations we've been in in the past many years.

787
01:59:57.910 --> 02:00:13.589
City of El Cerrito: I'd like to see you come back on the 5th with some more options, which would have to be negotiated with Flock. Either some… some more teeth to this, or if you can't do that within a couple weeks, because I get you've been working on this for 2 months, and this is where you've gotten.

788
02:00:13.740 --> 02:00:19.710
City of El Cerrito: some alternate options of some shorter-term options, so…

789
02:00:19.720 --> 02:00:37.640
City of El Cerrito: I hear from you that you think the flock cameras have been really effective. It's hard to know what's causation just because crime's been going down everywhere, but your clearance rates have gone up, so that's not nothing, and I'm hearing that, and I saw the specific cases you pointed out in the agenda bill.

790
02:00:37.640 --> 02:00:41.760
City of El Cerrito: So I'd like to have some options when we come back on May 5th.

791
02:00:41.760 --> 02:00:48.730
City of El Cerrito: To have a shorter-term contract, like 6 months, or 3 months, or something, that would then give us an opportunity

792
02:00:48.730 --> 02:01:04.610
City of El Cerrito: two, if we wanted to go forward after that short term to negotiate a stronger agreement. I also know there are some other cities that… I know Richmond and Oakland have already approved their contracts, but Berkeley is in the midst of trying to figure this out, probably

793
02:01:04.610 --> 02:01:25.149
City of El Cerrito: lots of cities around the country are in similar situations, and maybe some of these bigger cities that have more staffing capacity will figure something out, either with Flock or another vendor. I just want to keep some options open so we're not stuck for 3 years with Flock in a situation that is uncomfortable for our residents, and that might become

794
02:01:25.270 --> 02:01:41.770
City of El Cerrito: terrorizing to our residents if federal law changes, which we sadly have very little control over right now. So is that something you'd be comfortable going offline in the next couple weeks and trying to negotiate with Flock some shorter-term options that could be considered?

795
02:01:42.140 --> 02:01:50.850
City of El Cerrito: I will do my best with that. I will say that the current agreement did benefit from different cities' negotiations with WAC, so…

796
02:01:50.970 --> 02:01:54.919
City of El Cerrito: We were trying to kind of get alignment with what Richmond had negotiated.

797
02:01:55.110 --> 02:02:01.599
City of El Cerrito: Knowing that they had just gone through this process. So, we will see what kind of flexibility we have on different terms.

798
02:02:01.870 --> 02:02:03.340
City of El Cerrito: Let's see what we can do.

799
02:02:03.560 --> 02:02:12.719
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. And I'll see what else, you know, Block is on the call, and they see that, you know, maybe it's a hard sell, so they may be more willing to move on some of the other

800
02:02:12.720 --> 02:02:37.539
City of El Cerrito: provisions that we offered. Well, I can just say to the public and flock that I would be very surprised if, come March 5th, I was able to vote to approve a 3-year agreement, so maybe that will be some motivation. I don't know where the other council members are, but I just… I think we need something with more teeth if we're gonna go through with a long-term agreement, or we need something short-term that, again, doesn't have the cameras turned off.

801
02:02:37.540 --> 02:02:42.050
City of El Cerrito: For a few months, doesn't have some experiment with what that means.

802
02:02:42.190 --> 02:03:02.120
City of El Cerrito: let's figure out a way we can move forward, see what other options there are, either with Flock or another company. So yeah, I'd like to see this come back, and I look forward to hearing from all the members of the public tonight, and I've read many of your comments you sent in, but some of them were sent to us quite late this afternoon, so I've skimmed them, but we'll read them after this meeting.

803
02:03:02.420 --> 02:03:04.220
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we'll go back to,

804
02:03:04.380 --> 02:03:20.240
City of El Cerrito: Councilmember Watson? Yes, one of my questions I do want to go ahead and ask, and as I said, I listened to some of the other council meetings, and one of the things that Councilmember Robinson in Richmond said that really stuck out to me is that we're being asked to put trust in flock

805
02:03:20.490 --> 02:03:32.689
City of El Cerrito: But Flock didn't… I mean, these breaches apparently happened in 2023 when we first rolled out, and were just discovered when the city discovered them, and that creates a huge amount of distrust.

806
02:03:32.690 --> 02:03:43.940
City of El Cerrito: In the institution, it makes it very hard to vote yes, because it's, you know, it's like when you tell your child, yeah, you didn't tell me you did what you did, you just got caught.

807
02:03:44.060 --> 02:03:59.050
City of El Cerrito: So, I think that that's the concern for me, is why did that happen? How do we ensure that if something does happen, which we're trying to make sure it doesn't, but if that does happen, that flock will be up front with us and say, this is what happened, this is how we're going to fix it.

808
02:03:59.050 --> 02:04:22.629
City of El Cerrito: And the second question I have is for our city attorney. I don't know if this would be relevant or not, but there has been some… some conversation about other jurisdictions where they have faced risk. Has the city attorney actually looked into potential risk if we did go further and faced exposure? So if we could first answer the question about why it took so long for us to find out about the breaches, and then we can come back to the city attorney.

809
02:04:23.340 --> 02:04:31.119
City of El Cerrito: Well, I can say, internally to the department, our early use of the audit system was really focused on our own officers' behavior.

810
02:04:31.170 --> 02:04:45.170
City of El Cerrito: So, we were looking at why do our officers use the system? Are they valid reasons? What reasons are they putting in there? Do we need more detail? It was things like that. So we really looked at our own officers' behavior. We… while we did do…

811
02:04:45.170 --> 02:04:56.710
City of El Cerrito: network audits from time to time, they're only a snapshot in time, so from that point on, we're not looking back, you know, years, we're looking at, like, the present month, and what kind of use there's been in the present… use in the present month.

812
02:04:56.790 --> 02:05:12.769
City of El Cerrito: So that was one of the reasons why we missed the incidents involving the Veteran Affairs Police, because it was two different days and two different searches in one month, and we just… Well, I'm not even talking about you, Chief, but did Flock know this back then and not tell us? That's my question.

813
02:05:13.380 --> 02:05:16.070
City of El Cerrito: Do we know that? That's a good question, yeah. Okay.

814
02:05:16.070 --> 02:05:35.500
City of El Cerrito: See, the fact that… I don't know that they knew. I don't know that they knew that we had the U.S. Postal Service and the Veterans Affairs Police Departments looking at our data. I think that we were the ones who brought that revelation forward. When it comes to the access prior to when we took admin control of the system.

815
02:05:35.500 --> 02:05:38.100
City of El Cerrito: It's clear Flock did know that

816
02:05:38.120 --> 02:05:47.429
City of El Cerrito: early settings in the system allowed for wide viewing prior to agencies setting up their own restrictions. This is one of the things that they tried to correct early on.

817
02:05:47.540 --> 02:05:52.010
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Chief. And City Attorney, have we looked into any possible risk

818
02:05:52.820 --> 02:06:04.389
City of El Cerrito: We have. The primary risk to the city from exposure of data would result from an intentional sharing of data in violation of state law. Inadvertent exposure

819
02:06:04.470 --> 02:06:28.550
City of El Cerrito: is not particularly… is potentially actionable, but it's not a significant source of risk, at least not in addition to any other exposure of city data that would result from inadvertent exposure of data that the city's holding. It would be the same risk that already exists. The significant one is there are state laws that prohibit the intentional sharing of the data that's in the database, and if

820
02:06:28.550 --> 02:06:31.569
City of El Cerrito: Somebody with access to it on the city side.

821
02:06:31.570 --> 02:06:43.879
City of El Cerrito: intentionally shared it with a recipient who was not entitled to receive that data under state law, that would be the primary risk to the city. Thank you, Mayor. But just to add on, while we

822
02:06:43.940 --> 02:06:44.750
City of El Cerrito: can't…

823
02:06:44.820 --> 02:06:56.370
City of El Cerrito: We can't, always prevent things, it would be a violation of the city's internal policies, its personnel policies, there would be risk to the individual, so…

824
02:06:56.600 --> 02:07:04.159
City of El Cerrito: There are rules already in place to, significantly inhibit somebody from intending to be that kind of bad actor.

825
02:07:04.390 --> 02:07:06.090
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. Mayor and please.

826
02:07:06.390 --> 02:07:15.149
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much. Chief, I appreciate the, the conversation, and also, I was not able to look at the supplemental,

827
02:07:15.200 --> 02:07:30.580
City of El Cerrito: emails and letters, so I look forward to looking at that. I'm hoping we can look into continuing this until the May 5th meeting. But, you know, I wanted to let, folks know, our residents especially,

828
02:07:30.760 --> 02:07:40.099
City of El Cerrito: You know, the data proves and shows that crime has gone down with the cities, that have, flocked.

829
02:07:40.180 --> 02:07:54.620
City of El Cerrito: So, again, that includes El Cerrito. And, know that, we've always had one of the highest property crime rates in all of Contra Costa County. Chief, can you let us know how much property crime has gone down?

830
02:07:54.860 --> 02:07:56.839
City of El Cerrito: Since using the cameras.

831
02:07:57.000 --> 02:07:59.599
City of El Cerrito: Okay, well, now you've got me,

832
02:07:59.740 --> 02:08:02.230
City of El Cerrito: On the spot with the actual number.

833
02:08:02.420 --> 02:08:12.860
City of El Cerrito: I don't remember that off the top of my head, but it's gone down a significant amount, year over year, from 23, 24 to 25. Each year, we've had declines in overall property crimes.

834
02:08:13.290 --> 02:08:19.229
City of El Cerrito: And the same goes for the other cities that have flock as well. And,

835
02:08:19.230 --> 02:08:33.670
City of El Cerrito: you know, I was at Climate Week with my colleagues from Oakland and Berkeley, and they're dealing with the same thing. But they also know the importance of having public safety to deter crime.

836
02:08:33.670 --> 02:08:40.220
City of El Cerrito: know that in our largest city here in the East Bay, their corporations are not in downtown yet.

837
02:08:40.220 --> 02:08:48.120
City of El Cerrito: The corporations refused to move back to the city of Oakland, and they're in Contra Costa County and Tri-Valley.

838
02:08:48.120 --> 02:09:03.170
City of El Cerrito: the importance of making sure our cities have public safety so their corporations can return. If they don't have it, they're going to stay in San Ramon and Tri-Valley, so just wanted to point that out.

839
02:09:03.170 --> 02:09:11.539
City of El Cerrito: with our city next door, they have defunded the police twice, tried to do it a third time. This affects cities like El Cerrito, and

840
02:09:11.540 --> 02:09:25.240
City of El Cerrito: I and, Councilman Cassanis, you mentioned about surveillance. I live in a neighborhood where we had, deaths. We've had, people shot in armed robberies, dead.

841
02:09:25.240 --> 02:09:35.200
City of El Cerrito: One was a neighbor that lived on Mana that owned, the Indian restaurant near the Vietnamese restaurant there in Mira Vista.

842
02:09:35.200 --> 02:09:48.829
City of El Cerrito: The other was when I first moved here, I think it was 2002 or 2003, when the owner, the husband of the Red Onion, when he was shot dead, and, the… and his worker

843
02:09:48.830 --> 02:09:53.279
City of El Cerrito: was… was hurt, and had to go to the hospital. There was also

844
02:09:53.560 --> 02:10:07.670
City of El Cerrito: a young Asian man working the night shift at the gas station who was killed. Another one was a drive-by shooting on Mira Vista Avenue on the north side of town. So, know that every shot

845
02:10:07.670 --> 02:10:22.680
City of El Cerrito: And every store, every restaurant, every medical office here in El Cerrito has surveillance, and I thank the previous councils for doing that. This has dropped killings, and dropped killings,

846
02:10:22.680 --> 02:10:26.169
City of El Cerrito: To an all-time low, and… and…

847
02:10:26.290 --> 02:10:31.629
City of El Cerrito: products like flock. It may not be perfect, but it is deterring crime.

848
02:10:31.630 --> 02:10:55.069
City of El Cerrito: The last thing I want is to, follow what some of my other cities did here and purchase armed tanks. We are certainly not going to do that, and… but I want to make sure that, we are transparent at everything that we do, so I do support the continuance of this, to the May 5th meeting. I also wanted to say, Chief, thank you,

849
02:10:55.190 --> 02:11:01.440
City of El Cerrito: Now, who in our city has access to the FLAC data? Does IT have that?

850
02:11:02.100 --> 02:11:08.830
City of El Cerrito: access to the FLOC database is through our police officers, so system administrator is a police employee as well.

851
02:11:08.950 --> 02:11:12.890
City of El Cerrito: Okay, and they have access, and they can audit.

852
02:11:13.110 --> 02:11:21.289
City of El Cerrito: If, that is needed to have either a third party or, someone from the city to audit

853
02:11:21.460 --> 02:11:23.070
City of El Cerrito: The data, is that correct?

854
02:11:23.700 --> 02:11:37.719
City of El Cerrito: So we do do audits internally to the police department. The data does contain law enforcement sensitive information when you do a raw audit of it, so we do have to be careful of who we allow access to the raw data.

855
02:11:37.990 --> 02:11:56.959
City of El Cerrito: So, for now, we use a law enforcement officer for that. Okay, I very much appreciate that. So, you know, know that public safety, we have a new generation of young families that have moved here, and they moved here paying over, you know, more than most cities. Our homes are unavailable.

856
02:11:56.960 --> 02:12:13.209
City of El Cerrito: Because they're too expensive. So, a lot of families have moved here from bigger cities because they know the importance of El Cerrito, maintaining a pro-public safety stance on everything, and that includes tech.

857
02:12:13.270 --> 02:12:29.489
City of El Cerrito: And tech helps because we're getting less of our residents hurt, and we're having less police officers getting injured or killed. So, we have to have an equal balance on things, so I look forward to listening to

858
02:12:29.970 --> 02:12:35.949
City of El Cerrito: open comment and to listening from our residents here on what they have to say during this matter, so…

859
02:12:36.020 --> 02:12:49.949
City of El Cerrito: Let's go to open comment time. Now is the time for members of the public who wish to provide public comments on this item. Requests to speak can be submitted to the City Clerk by completing a speaker card, using the raise hand feature on Zoom.

860
02:12:49.950 --> 02:13:00.779
City of El Cerrito: or dialing 9 if joining by phone. In-person requests will be taken first. Please remember to identify yourself and your City of Residence at the beginning of your comments. Madam City Clerk.

861
02:13:00.780 --> 02:13:13.509
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor. We currently have 27 requests to speak on this item. Would you like to utilize the time reduction waterfall in the Council policy for 21 to 30 speakers and reduce the time to 1 minute per speaker? Sure, 1 minute.

862
02:13:37.800 --> 02:13:40.260
City of El Cerrito: May I ask you to consider 2 minutes, Mayor?

863
02:13:41.410 --> 02:13:42.170
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

864
02:13:47.000 --> 02:13:48.120
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

865
02:13:48.300 --> 02:14:01.929
City of El Cerrito: We will go… we will start with our in-person request to speak. That'll give our online requesters an opportunity to raise their hand, which I'm already seeing an increase there. So we'll go with our first speaker is Catherine Kimsey, followed by Rye Crawford.

866
02:14:05.600 --> 02:14:12.339
City of El Cerrito: Good evening. All right, good evening. My name is Katherine Kimsey, I go by Rin, and I live at the Del Norte Place Apartments in El Cerrito.

867
02:14:12.640 --> 02:14:22.920
City of El Cerrito: I think I may have been scooped, because it turns out the police chief has a whole other plan, but I'm here to ask you not to vote to renew the contract with Flock tonight. And I think…

868
02:14:22.950 --> 02:14:31.249
City of El Cerrito: I'm gonna ask, for the time for us to review this alleged new contract. I can't say I'm excited, but…

869
02:14:31.250 --> 02:14:45.790
City of El Cerrito: I wanted to point out, respectfully, that there isn't actually any proof that Flock has reduced crime in El Cerrito. The most recent public information that I could find was from 2024. We are in the midst of a worldwide crime drop.

870
02:14:45.990 --> 02:15:02.050
City of El Cerrito: And finally, I just want to ask, please review the lawsuits that I sent to you, because I don't think the city attorney has fully emphasized the risk to the city. Do not vote to renew tonight. Do not subject El Cerrito to unnecessary legal risk for no provable reason. Thank you.

871
02:15:02.290 --> 02:15:05.989
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Rye Crawford, followed by Cindy McPherson.

872
02:15:10.800 --> 02:15:16.260
City of El Cerrito: I really appreciate that people are not just rushing to judgment on this.

873
02:15:16.510 --> 02:15:22.789
City of El Cerrito: I feel the issues surrounding the clock surveillance cameras go far beyond

874
02:15:23.060 --> 02:15:25.889
City of El Cerrito: You know, and the data collected go far beyond.

875
02:15:26.560 --> 02:15:33.350
City of El Cerrito: Stolen cars, and missing persons, and… Involve serious issues of…

876
02:15:34.080 --> 02:15:41.160
City of El Cerrito: the security of our citizens, our city, potentially. And that flock has

877
02:15:41.420 --> 02:15:45.360
City of El Cerrito: Responsibility to be able to show to us.

878
02:15:45.840 --> 02:15:48.550
City of El Cerrito: How that will be respected.

879
02:15:50.410 --> 02:15:52.500
City of El Cerrito: And we don't have that right now.

880
02:15:53.580 --> 02:15:56.010
City of El Cerrito: And just saying, like, I'm not sure.

881
02:15:56.350 --> 02:15:57.749
City of El Cerrito: It's not enough.

882
02:15:58.400 --> 02:16:00.100
City of El Cerrito: We need to be sure.

883
02:16:00.930 --> 02:16:01.840
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

884
02:16:02.640 --> 02:16:07.259
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Cindy McPherson, followed by Talia Davido.

885
02:16:11.350 --> 02:16:17.319
City of El Cerrito: Hi, my name is Cindy McPherson, and I'm a resident of El Cerrito, and I'm here to ask you tonight

886
02:16:17.340 --> 02:16:27.690
City of El Cerrito: to, do not vote to renew the flock contract. We are a sanctuary city, and I'm very much appreciative that the Council and the police department uphold that.

887
02:16:27.690 --> 02:16:40.620
City of El Cerrito: However, under FISA, it is possible that a federal subpoena could override any of those boundaries or settings that El Cerrito, the police department, Flock, or even the Amazon web servers claim to have.

888
02:16:40.959 --> 02:16:55.549
City of El Cerrito: El Cerrito's flock data could be subpoenaed without El Cerrito even knowing. Cost. At least one court has held that flock camera data are subject to public record requests, which, you know, can be costly to respond to.

889
02:16:55.750 --> 02:17:05.220
City of El Cerrito: You all have worked so hard to put the city on firm financial footing, and this technology opens us up to expenses that will undermine that.

890
02:17:05.469 --> 02:17:21.970
City of El Cerrito: Don't put our city's financial stability at risk. And trust, you heard that the cameras are easily hackable. Thank you for your comments. Please give the public safety issue more consideration. Thank you for your comments. Our next speaker is Talia Davido, followed by Sandy Davis.

891
02:17:22.920 --> 02:17:30.489
City of El Cerrito: Hi, I'm Talia Davidau, I live on Stockton, I'm here as your neighbor, urging you not to renew El Cerrito's contract with Flock.

892
02:17:30.600 --> 02:17:36.470
City of El Cerrito: Right now, when so much feels out of our control nationally, what you do locally really matters.

893
02:17:36.480 --> 02:17:53.160
City of El Cerrito: Renewing this contract puts our community at risk, our data, our privacy, and the trust we place in you. This company has already shown it cannot keep our information safe or within our control, and once that data is out there, it's out there, potentially accessible to federal agencies in ways we can't even see.

894
02:17:53.330 --> 02:18:02.440
City of El Cerrito: This directly conflicts with our values as a sanctuary city. Values that mean something. They mean we do everything we can to keep our neighbors safe.

895
02:18:02.580 --> 02:18:08.579
City of El Cerrito: Especially our most marginalized neighbors, who data shows are targeted disproportionately by flock surveillance.

896
02:18:08.820 --> 02:18:16.509
City of El Cerrito: As a sanctuary city, we must act with additional caution in relation to the federal government right now, given its lawlessness and vindictiveness.

897
02:18:16.860 --> 02:18:27.770
City of El Cerrito: Please don't vote to renew this contract, slow this down, listen to your constituents, and make a decision that truly protects this community. Thank you. Thank you. Our next speaker is Sandy Davis, followed by Laura Paulin.

898
02:18:34.209 --> 02:18:38.779
City of El Cerrito: Good evening. Hello, my name is Sandy Davis. I'm also an El Cerrito resident.

899
02:18:38.910 --> 02:18:47.680
City of El Cerrito: And I'd like to echo the concerns raised by others tonight about the risks to the privacy and safety of members of our community that is posed by our partnership with Block.

900
02:18:47.799 --> 02:18:51.939
City of El Cerrito: That are largely beyond the control of our city and our police department.

901
02:18:52.120 --> 02:19:00.239
City of El Cerrito: I'm asking you to vote not to renew today so the City Council has more time to look into these concerns, which it seems like you are all inclined to do. Thank you for your time.

902
02:19:01.320 --> 02:19:04.889
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Laura Paulin, followed by Joanna Lauren-Shrenk.

903
02:19:08.889 --> 02:19:13.900
City of El Cerrito: Hello. I'm Laura Palin. I'm a resident of El Cerrito.

904
02:19:14.010 --> 02:19:16.580
City of El Cerrito: I'm a retired middle school math teacher.

905
02:19:16.910 --> 02:19:21.020
City of El Cerrito: I strongly urge you, the City Council, not to renew.

906
02:19:21.510 --> 02:19:23.020
City of El Cerrito: the flock contract.

907
02:19:23.559 --> 02:19:28.809
City of El Cerrito: I understand the flock technology is a tool for bringing lawbreakers to justice.

908
02:19:29.190 --> 02:19:31.880
City of El Cerrito: And I appreciate feeling safe in El Cerrito.

909
02:19:32.860 --> 02:19:35.000
City of El Cerrito: But this is an issue of trust.

910
02:19:35.510 --> 02:19:38.660
City of El Cerrito: We're in a time when I do trust our…

911
02:19:38.850 --> 02:19:42.719
City of El Cerrito: El Cerrito Police. I trust Chief Keith.

912
02:19:43.080 --> 02:19:46.839
City of El Cerrito: But… beyond that, I don't have trust.

913
02:19:47.420 --> 02:19:50.580
City of El Cerrito: And I don't feel like this is a time

914
02:19:50.690 --> 02:19:54.810
City of El Cerrito: When we can… we kind of, unfortunately, have to give up our safety.

915
02:19:55.120 --> 02:20:00.959
City of El Cerrito: Because we don't trust Beyond our own little wonderful community here.

916
02:20:01.830 --> 02:20:02.710
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

917
02:20:03.550 --> 02:20:07.579
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Joanna Lawrence-Schrenk, followed by Eric Lawrence Schrenk.

918
02:20:13.630 --> 02:20:31.729
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, city leaders. My name is Reverend Joanna Lawrence Schenk. I'm a resident of El Cerrito. I'm a pastor at First Mennonite Church of San Francisco, and I have congregants who live in this lovely city. I'm particularly concerned about how flock surveillance betrays our cherished commitment to being a sanctuary city.

919
02:20:31.750 --> 02:20:49.040
City of El Cerrito: Flock endangers the safety of our non-citizen neighbors, as well as anyone who supports them or speaks out against the federal government's illegal policies of terror and detainment. Because FLOC shares data with the federal government, there is only the thinnest of barriers to ICE's acquisition of such data.

920
02:20:49.040 --> 02:21:13.110
City of El Cerrito: Undoubtedly, Flock's AI-enhanced ability to gather and analyze such data facilitates and makes more efficient overreaches of power. El Cerrito is a sanctuary city, and I'm grateful that Chief Keith affirms that our police does not collaborate with ICE. However, due to Flock's data sharing and untrustworthy practices, ECPD sadly cannot ensure that our data

921
02:21:13.110 --> 02:21:19.880
City of El Cerrito: And our community will be safe. Thank you for your comments. Our next speaker is Eric Lawrence Schenk, followed by Tom Parks.

922
02:21:22.400 --> 02:21:30.929
City of El Cerrito: Eric Lorenshank, I'm a resident of El Cerrita. I'm a teacher at Middle College High School and chair of the science department there.

923
02:21:31.180 --> 02:21:40.029
City of El Cerrito: I want to say that I resonated with the wise words of the council today, along with the mayor, and

924
02:21:40.260 --> 02:21:47.870
City of El Cerrito: As a person who's also very deeply concerned with the safety of our citizens, I do 1…

925
02:21:48.000 --> 02:21:51.869
City of El Cerrito: A way for us to be able to keep everyone safe.

926
02:21:52.270 --> 02:21:59.289
City of El Cerrito: But I also, at this time, don't feel like it would be best for us to renew the contract.

927
02:21:59.400 --> 02:22:02.129
City of El Cerrito: I would like to see an independent investigator.

928
02:22:02.300 --> 02:22:05.029
City of El Cerrito: Give us some more information. Not…

929
02:22:05.240 --> 02:22:13.150
City of El Cerrito: from just Flock's perspective, or the department's perspective, because their vested interests will lead them to

930
02:22:13.460 --> 02:22:20.140
City of El Cerrito: conclusions that are favorable to them. I always like to hear more information about this and what we're getting into. Thank you.

931
02:22:20.670 --> 02:22:23.970
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Tom Parks, followed by Destry Miller.

932
02:22:27.320 --> 02:22:40.470
City of El Cerrito: Hi, Tom Parks, 23 a year resident of El Cerrito. So, amendment number 4, the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated.

933
02:22:40.730 --> 02:22:46.210
City of El Cerrito: And no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation.

934
02:22:46.320 --> 02:22:51.179
City of El Cerrito: And particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized.

935
02:22:51.330 --> 02:22:52.190
City of El Cerrito: flock.

936
02:22:52.290 --> 02:22:55.520
City of El Cerrito: As a mass surveillance system, by design.

937
02:22:55.910 --> 02:22:59.219
City of El Cerrito: Is a con… is a fundamental contradiction.

938
02:23:00.250 --> 02:23:01.640
City of El Cerrito: to the Fourth Amendment.

939
02:23:02.070 --> 02:23:04.629
City of El Cerrito: and directly confronts the First Amendment.

940
02:23:05.070 --> 02:23:10.180
City of El Cerrito: the citizens, the people, the community of El Cerrito's right to peaceably assemble.

941
02:23:12.720 --> 02:23:14.589
City of El Cerrito: Mass surveillance isn't a joke.

942
02:23:15.000 --> 02:23:18.860
City of El Cerrito: Particularly when we have a Pentagon led by

943
02:23:19.070 --> 02:23:21.870
City of El Cerrito: Somebody that apparently is a joke.

944
02:23:22.290 --> 02:23:25.019
City of El Cerrito: And when we have a, you know.

945
02:23:26.000 --> 02:23:31.770
City of El Cerrito: a president that would like to use and has used troops in the streets. Thank you for your comments.

946
02:23:32.060 --> 02:23:35.450
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Destry Miller, followed by Rashi.

947
02:23:40.990 --> 02:23:58.519
City of El Cerrito: Hello, Councilmembers. My name is Adestry Miller. I've been a resident of El Cerrito for over 10 years. I… my major concern about Flock is that the… what the Councilmember had mentioned about the federal subpoenas being changed, that made it lawful.

948
02:23:59.040 --> 02:24:03.969
City of El Cerrito: Gathering information there for whatever purpose,

949
02:24:04.280 --> 02:24:11.770
City of El Cerrito: And for that reason, I would hope that the city does not renew the flock, Subscription there.

950
02:24:13.660 --> 02:24:17.200
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Rashi, followed by Stephanie Singer.

951
02:24:20.140 --> 02:24:33.129
City of El Cerrito: Hi, my name is Roshi Surjanye, I've been a resident of El Cerrito for over 10 years, and I want to urge you to follow the money, and see who funded Flock, and why.

952
02:24:33.570 --> 02:24:37.409
City of El Cerrito: the top two funders of Flock that took it from a

953
02:24:37.610 --> 02:24:41.420
City of El Cerrito: You know, $300 million company to over…

954
02:24:41.630 --> 02:24:49.540
City of El Cerrito: $500 million company, where Peter Thiel, And… Mark Anderson.

955
02:24:49.780 --> 02:25:00.019
City of El Cerrito: These are the two advisors to the present president, and they took the profile of this company and raised it and made it a major contender

956
02:25:00.170 --> 02:25:03.160
City of El Cerrito: In the, intelligence market.

957
02:25:03.500 --> 02:25:11.109
City of El Cerrito: I urge you to look at that. This is absolutely in line with Project 2025.

958
02:25:11.400 --> 02:25:17.510
City of El Cerrito: And if you haven't seen the reviews about Project 2025, Please do.

959
02:25:17.690 --> 02:25:30.079
City of El Cerrito: It concerns all of us, the safety of all of us. Today, it's immigrants. Thank you for your comments. Thank you. Our next speaker is Stephanie Singer, followed by Jay Geronimo.

960
02:25:32.290 --> 02:25:49.350
City of El Cerrito: Stephanie Singer, I've been a resident of El Cerrito for a little over a year now. My professional life has been concerned for the last decade and a half with cybersecurity for election systems. There are a lot of parallels here.

961
02:25:49.360 --> 02:26:07.129
City of El Cerrito: a decade ago, most voters in this country were voting on electronic voting machines. We were assured that they were safe. The people who sold them to us assured us that they were safe, that they had done all these security checks. You cannot trust the vendor

962
02:26:07.130 --> 02:26:22.340
City of El Cerrito: to be your source of truth on how secure something is. The other thing I know from my experience is that security is a goal. You never attain security. Security is a process. So.

963
02:26:22.340 --> 02:26:29.799
City of El Cerrito: get independent information, not from the vendors, as good as they are, they don't bite the hand that feeds them.

964
02:26:29.890 --> 02:26:32.589
City of El Cerrito: So, thank you very much for your service.

965
02:26:33.100 --> 02:26:36.700
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Jay Geronimo, followed by Bill Barish.

966
02:26:39.440 --> 02:26:50.090
City of El Cerrito: Hi, my name's Jiggy Geronimo. I live near Castro Park with my husband and my 1 and 3-year-old, and I know that you all really care about the safety of our community. I do, too. I have two really little kids.

967
02:26:50.090 --> 02:27:14.950
City of El Cerrito: But I really want us to interrogate what safety means in the year 2026 in El Cerrito. The idea of mass surveillance by the federal government, the same federal government that is kidnapping both immigrants and citizens alike, does not make me feel safe. It's actually terrifying to me. The chief also mentioned that they work with the government on investigating domestic terrorism. The government has now classified anyone that disagrees with them as domestic terrorists.

968
02:27:14.950 --> 02:27:23.849
City of El Cerrito: So the idea that our data might not be shared, I find to be very, unbelievable. They've already accessed our data, and

969
02:27:23.850 --> 02:27:44.659
City of El Cerrito: I know that a lot of the residents here are deeply uncomfortable with this. We put together a letter that you all received that got 150 signatures in under 24 hours. So, people here in El Cerrito are really, really concerned about this, and I'm really heartened to hear that you all are going to be doing more investigating into this issue, but we're relying on you to keep us safe, so…

970
02:27:45.150 --> 02:27:48.959
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Bill Barish, followed by Tora Feldmenstern.

971
02:27:50.900 --> 02:27:52.840
City of El Cerrito: Bill Barish, El Cerrito.

972
02:27:52.950 --> 02:28:11.450
City of El Cerrito: You should have absolutely nothing to do whatsoever with Flock. Not as a tool, not as a company. As a tool, it's nothing but a surveillance system, and as a company, it's a known bad actor that routinely breaks rules on giving its information to people who are not authorized to have it.

973
02:28:11.800 --> 02:28:17.989
City of El Cerrito: Flock is a, as somebody pointed out, a member of the surveillance community.

974
02:28:17.990 --> 02:28:32.339
City of El Cerrito: It is not something that any self-respecting community that aspires to be democratic should have anything to do with. And I will tell you, as a 20-year veteran of the tech industry.

975
02:28:32.360 --> 02:28:45.499
City of El Cerrito: that the owner of the code can flip any switch they want without your knowledge to provide any data that they want to anyone they want. Thank you.

976
02:28:46.180 --> 02:28:49.840
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Tora Feldman Stern, followed by Sue Hansen.

977
02:28:51.920 --> 02:29:07.899
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, City Council. My name is Toba Feldman-Stern, and I'm a local resident of El Cerrito. Thank you for your time and attention. I live in North El Cerrito with my wife and 3-year-old, and I'm one of those, families who paid a lot of money to live here. I've been here 10 years, and, just…

978
02:29:07.900 --> 02:29:13.609
City of El Cerrito: of value, and I… I am so happy to have the privilege of paying that money to live in a place like this.

979
02:29:13.610 --> 02:29:20.329
City of El Cerrito: with all of you. This is… this is an amazing, incredible gift to have.

980
02:29:20.490 --> 02:29:29.170
City of El Cerrito: These people, us. Which includes our neighbors, who may, like, in a second be taken away from us.

981
02:29:29.440 --> 02:29:36.280
City of El Cerrito: Because a company like this is profiting from taking those people away from us. It was designed

982
02:29:36.450 --> 02:29:41.109
City of El Cerrito: It was designed to put money in the hands of billionaires. More money.

983
02:29:41.180 --> 02:29:52.390
City of El Cerrito: Just because… just because they can disappear people. And I hear that, yes, lives have been saved by these cameras in a few instances, but that's not what they were designed for, and that's not…

984
02:29:52.390 --> 02:30:03.990
City of El Cerrito: That is absolutely not what your comments are after. Thank you for your comments. Thank you. Our next speaker is Sue Hansen, followed by Nakisha Koss.

985
02:30:06.330 --> 02:30:07.280
City of El Cerrito: I'm sorry?

986
02:30:09.200 --> 02:30:12.959
City of El Cerrito: Okay, so our next speaker is Nakisha Koss, followed by Yoku.

987
02:30:13.090 --> 02:30:14.020
City of El Cerrito: Yoko?

988
02:30:16.150 --> 02:30:24.410
City of El Cerrito: My name is Nakisha, I live in El Cerrito with my 8-year-old daughter just up the hill from Del Norte Bart, and we also, we love this community.

989
02:30:24.710 --> 02:30:43.879
City of El Cerrito: It does not matter what the parameters ECPD sets. It doesn't matter if we're only sharing to the 322 California municipalities who currently have access to our data. It doesn't matter if Lock somehow manages to create a system that works exactly and only as expected.

990
02:30:44.170 --> 02:30:56.040
City of El Cerrito: As long as El Cerrito has a contract with Flock, its surveillance is readily available to federal agencies, including ICE, through the… through FISA, which is the Federal Intelligence Surveillance Act.

991
02:30:56.320 --> 02:31:08.289
City of El Cerrito: FISA courts authorize warrants to collect information without any public record. Such a warrant would be served to Flock, or its data cloud, server. Our El Cerrito would,

992
02:31:08.320 --> 02:31:21.449
City of El Cerrito: would not be informed. This issue is not how secure ECPD thinks our data is. Our community in a sanctuary city, within a sanctuary state… Thank you for your comments. …is at risk. Our next speaker is…

993
02:31:21.670 --> 02:31:24.810
City of El Cerrito: Yuko, followed by Kate Bolton-Schmuckler.

994
02:31:27.880 --> 02:31:47.149
City of El Cerrito: Hi, I'm Yuko. I've lived almost 15 years in El Cerrito. Please do not renew our Flock contract or accept any new agreements, and now is the right time to cut ties with this private AI surveillance company and any similar technologies and companies. Mountain View City Council unanimously voted to terminate its contract with Flock.

995
02:31:47.770 --> 02:32:02.290
City of El Cerrito: when we contracted with FLOC in 2023, not many of us really knew what it was or understood the true dangers. And 3 years later, the government is relying on similar and related surveillance tech, and ISIS kidnapped countless immigrant citizens.

996
02:32:02.410 --> 02:32:03.380
City of El Cerrito: repressed…

997
02:32:03.560 --> 02:32:11.570
City of El Cerrito: Our government has repressed students and other protesters, and we can't say now that we don't know what this leads to. Our PD's audit

998
02:32:11.600 --> 02:32:26.860
City of El Cerrito: found that two federal agencies accessed or flocked cameras without the knowledge of ECPD, and this is not an isolated incident. We constantly hear similar reports around California and around the country. And, council members, you pledged after Trump is re-elected that

999
02:32:26.900 --> 02:32:32.060
City of El Cerrito: You reconfirmed that we are a sanctuary City, so one important… Thank you for your comments. …that you can take is to reject

1000
02:32:32.130 --> 02:32:38.139
City of El Cerrito: Thank you for your comment. Our next speaker is Kate Bolton-Schmuckler, followed by Timothy Keller.

1001
02:32:39.150 --> 02:32:47.350
City of El Cerrito: Hello, I'm Kate Boltage-Spunkler, I've been a resident of El Cerrito since rent was $750 a month for a one-bedroom, and… Loma Prieta happened.

1002
02:32:47.820 --> 02:32:55.149
City of El Cerrito: I would rather get robbed multiple times than have my neighbors get kidnapped by a fascist organization that is funded by ICE.

1003
02:32:55.270 --> 02:33:12.420
City of El Cerrito: And that's just where I stand. I, you know, yeah, nothing is perfect, we can't ever guarantee safety, but right now, we are living in fascist times, and we are a so-called sanctuary city, so I am strongly encouraging you to not renew this contract with ICE. Cops will find a way to still fight crime. Thank you.

1004
02:33:13.130 --> 02:33:21.289
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. Our next, just a reminder for the audience, please note audible disruption. Our next speaker is Timothy Keller, followed by Brian Fogg.

1005
02:33:23.160 --> 02:33:30.749
City of El Cerrito: I'm, Timothy Keller, I'm born and raised in El Cerrito, and I gotta say, it's kinda nice having company for once.

1006
02:33:31.610 --> 02:33:47.749
City of El Cerrito: I'm just wanting to, thank City Council for asking the right questions, finally, and, especially about bad actors, because no matter what you do, as long as you're able to search these… the camera network, you're gonna be able to use it.

1007
02:33:47.870 --> 02:33:52.390
City of El Cerrito: for… Bad stuff. I forgot my notes.

1008
02:33:52.710 --> 02:33:59.460
City of El Cerrito: And, yeah, we… we should… we shouldn't have these, we shouldn't have had them in the first place, and it's…

1009
02:33:59.730 --> 02:34:04.869
City of El Cerrito: I mean… In their first patent, Flock describes itself as

1010
02:34:05.070 --> 02:34:09.660
City of El Cerrito: A surveillance system that might take pictures.

1011
02:34:09.950 --> 02:34:11.820
City of El Cerrito: Of cars with license plates in them.

1012
02:34:12.130 --> 02:34:15.500
City of El Cerrito: like… We shouldn't have had it.

1013
02:34:17.800 --> 02:34:21.200
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Brian Fogg, followed by Miguel Gravel.

1014
02:34:26.230 --> 02:34:42.049
City of El Cerrito: Hello, I'm a third-generation resident of El Cerrito. I'm lucky enough to live in a house that my grandfather built in 1950. I wanted to give you a quick briefing on a few federal laws. Under the Cloud Act, enacted in 2018, federal law enforcement can compel any U.S. company

1015
02:34:42.530 --> 02:34:57.539
City of El Cerrito: to produce data they possess, including data held on behalf of the local police department. Under FISA, intelligence agencies can obtain the same data through secret court order, and the company is legally prohibited from disclosing that the order exists. Not to you, or the city.

1016
02:34:58.140 --> 02:35:13.529
City of El Cerrito: Under national security letters codified in 1986, expanded under the Patriot Act, the FBI can demand subscriber data with no court involvement at all, again, with mandatory gag orders attached. I've prepared quite a long briefing for anyone who'd like to read it.

1017
02:35:13.600 --> 02:35:28.069
City of El Cerrito: And, you know, we don't need that many votes to overturn this, so I suggest that we organize a little bit. I'll be collecting emails. We only need to oust a couple people off the council to get what we want. We could start with the guy who only gives us one minute to speak.

1018
02:35:28.480 --> 02:35:33.429
City of El Cerrito: Thank you for your comments. Our next speaker is Miguel Gravel, followed by Raya Long.

1019
02:35:38.960 --> 02:35:39.919
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

1020
02:35:40.370 --> 02:35:54.379
City of El Cerrito: I strongly urge the city to permanently discontinue the flock cameras due to the risk to El Ciritans and anybody who passes through our city. At the hands of a radically far-right and increasingly fascist government.

1021
02:35:54.860 --> 02:36:03.939
City of El Cerrito: Flot cameras share data with over 100 federal agencies, which matters as Trump moves to criminalize people where Democrats

1022
02:36:04.100 --> 02:36:12.969
City of El Cerrito: for celebrating LGBTQ pride, standing up against illegal policies of immigration enforcement, or even going to No Kings protests.

1023
02:36:13.510 --> 02:36:25.500
City of El Cerrito: The info captured in flock cameras about such people could lead to them being placed on domestic terrorist lists, prohibited from being flying on commercial airlines, costly court battles, and potential imprisonment or disappearance.

1024
02:36:26.170 --> 02:36:34.230
City of El Cerrito: No $450 penalty to flock a $8.4 billion company will stop them from giving information to what they want to give.

1025
02:36:34.880 --> 02:36:35.650
City of El Cerrito: And…

1026
02:36:36.140 --> 02:36:45.379
City of El Cerrito: It is naive to think that any of us would be safe from the federal government using FLOX data. Thank you for your comments. Thank you. Our next speaker is Raya Long, followed by Arielle Gold.

1027
02:36:48.650 --> 02:36:59.009
City of El Cerrito: Council members, we are told… oh, I'm Rhea, live in El Cerrito for 13 years. We are told that the 40 cameras are for public safety and only capture license plates. This is a half-truth.

1028
02:36:59.010 --> 02:37:23.999
City of El Cerrito: The Safe Flock only photographs places like saying a smartphone only makes calls. It ignores… it uses AI fingerprinting that tracks vehicle color and unique markings and wide-angle lenses that capture the faces of drivers and bystanders. This isn't a plate reader, it is a pattern of life tracker feeding directly into federal dragnets. Advanced tech, as queried by Councilmember Motayama, shows this and the need for public discourse, or no public discourse, just on

1029
02:37:24.000 --> 02:37:45.380
City of El Cerrito: do it at all. The other thing we were told that I want to address is that there is a $450 penalty for unauthorized data sharing, but let's be honest, Flock Safety is an $8.4 billion corporation. To them, $450 is the price of a mid-range office chair in less than 0.5% of our total budget, of $313,000, whatever we discussed.

1030
02:37:45.540 --> 02:37:49.940
City of El Cerrito: Yeah, keep negotiating that, please. Oh, shoot. Thank you for your comment.

1031
02:37:51.000 --> 02:37:54.369
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Ariel Gold, followed by Leah Carroll.

1032
02:37:58.090 --> 02:38:01.500
City of El Cerrito: Good evening, my name's Arielle Gold, and I'm a resident in El Cerrito.

1033
02:38:01.920 --> 02:38:05.599
City of El Cerrito: I want to thank Chief Keith for pursuing additional safeguards.

1034
02:38:05.820 --> 02:38:11.070
City of El Cerrito: But a fine for unauthorized access doesn't undo a privacy violation.

1035
02:38:12.660 --> 02:38:16.100
City of El Cerrito: Once ICE has located a neighbor, that can't be undone.

1036
02:38:16.700 --> 02:38:23.639
City of El Cerrito: Chief Keith himself confirmed federal agencies have accessed flock data without El Cerrito Police ever being notified.

1037
02:38:24.250 --> 02:38:28.090
City of El Cerrito: I hear the mayor on crime deterrence, and I want a safe community.

1038
02:38:28.640 --> 02:38:32.729
City of El Cerrito: But we don't have proof that flock is the reason crime has gone down.

1039
02:38:32.860 --> 02:38:36.950
City of El Cerrito: And we don't adopt every tool that might reduce crime, like curfews.

1040
02:38:38.530 --> 02:38:49.470
City of El Cerrito: The question is whether mass tracking of every resident shared with 322 agencies and no warrant required is a price our most vulnerable neighbors should pay.

1041
02:38:50.290 --> 02:38:57.810
City of El Cerrito: Finally, if the new agreement was added today, this vote should not happen tonight. The public deserves time to read it. Please vote no. Thank you.

1042
02:38:58.370 --> 02:39:04.140
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Leah Carroll, followed by Kamel… Mutiani?

1043
02:39:05.210 --> 02:39:09.009
City of El Cerrito: I'm Leah Carroll, El Cerrito resident since 2000,

1044
02:39:09.310 --> 02:39:13.380
City of El Cerrito: And, please vote not to renew this.

1045
02:39:13.540 --> 02:39:19.840
City of El Cerrito: We cannot trust the federal government right now. There's ample evidence of that.

1046
02:39:20.320 --> 02:39:24.550
City of El Cerrito: Ice has killed nonviolent protesters.

1047
02:39:25.020 --> 02:39:27.839
City of El Cerrito: They're completely out of control.

1048
02:39:27.960 --> 02:39:36.759
City of El Cerrito: We cannot trust the federal government to do the right thing with our data, and Flock cannot be trusted to not share

1049
02:39:37.590 --> 02:39:42.670
City of El Cerrito: the flock data with the federal government, so we shouldn't do this. Thanks.

1050
02:39:43.340 --> 02:39:48.599
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Kamal Mutiano, followed… and then we'll go to our virtual request to speak.

1051
02:39:51.150 --> 02:40:02.659
City of El Cerrito: Hi, this is Kamo Motialu, resident of El Cerrito for about 23 years, a former administrative law judge. What I want to comment on is, essentially.

1052
02:40:03.270 --> 02:40:06.079
City of El Cerrito: You're looking for facts and evidence to make your…

1053
02:40:06.180 --> 02:40:09.899
City of El Cerrito: decision, and it's apparent that you don't have that information.

1054
02:40:10.000 --> 02:40:19.279
City of El Cerrito: What I'm calling for for you to do, is to issue an information request, get a signed attestation from FLOC. It's going to take longer than

1055
02:40:19.630 --> 02:40:22.629
City of El Cerrito: making that decision on May 5th, right?

1056
02:40:22.820 --> 02:40:32.110
City of El Cerrito: Because to me, based on the information I've received here, you're not going to get the information you need to make a valid, reasonable decision.

1057
02:40:32.200 --> 02:40:43.600
City of El Cerrito: And I think you also have to look at legal risk as well. So I really urge you to work with all stakeholders to figure out what that process is, because I don't believe

1058
02:40:43.750 --> 02:40:47.760
City of El Cerrito: We need to have something signed, a written attestation from Flock.

1059
02:40:48.030 --> 02:40:51.269
City of El Cerrito: Questions, answers, before you make a decision.

1060
02:40:51.510 --> 02:40:58.219
City of El Cerrito: Thanks. Thank you for your comments. We have one additional in-person request, Sherry Dropner, and then we'll go to our remote requests.

1061
02:41:00.840 --> 02:41:13.100
City of El Cerrito: Okay, this will be quick. I'm Sherry Dropner. I just want to, first of all, say I'm very grateful to the community behind me, who's given forth such incredible, important information for all of you.

1062
02:41:13.110 --> 02:41:29.319
City of El Cerrito: I want to thank all of you for not just running in and making a decision on this. I also want to just add, someone mentioned about Mountain View. They didn't think about more options, they didn't think about a contract. They absolutely stopped

1063
02:41:29.400 --> 02:41:46.180
City of El Cerrito: the contract, and it was a solid vote across the board for the City Council. And the mayor said, public safety must be grounded in community trust, and the program did not reflect community priorities. And I think we see that in this evening. Thank you.

1064
02:41:47.160 --> 02:41:54.929
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we're going to go to our remote request to speak, starting with Jason Martins. Jason, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

1065
02:41:55.870 --> 02:42:08.209
Jason Martens (he/him): Hi, thank you. I'm a resident of Berkeley, and I've been working on our own flock contract there. I did want to read something from the Brennan Center for Justice about the FISA court.

1066
02:42:08.210 --> 02:42:18.529
Jason Martens (he/him): and how it operates. They say, although the surveillance may only be targeted at foreigners abroad, it inevitably sweets in large amounts of Americans' phone calls, texts, and emails.

1067
02:42:18.590 --> 02:42:28.980
Jason Martens (he/him): Congress and the FISA Court have attempted to limit the government's access to these communications, but the government has engaged in widespread violations of those limits. To give just a few examples.

1068
02:42:28.980 --> 02:42:46.089
Jason Martens (he/him): The FBI has conducted warrantless searches of Section 702 acquired information to access communications of Black Lives Matter protesters, U.S. government officials, journalists, political commentators, and 19,000 donors to a single congressional campaign.

1069
02:42:46.310 --> 02:42:56.120
Jason Martens (he/him): So whatever the contracts and restrictions are that we think we have in place, it's not enough to prevent access to this data. We shouldn't collect it in the first place. Thank you.

1070
02:42:59.510 --> 02:43:03.840
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Peter. Peter, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

1071
02:43:05.690 --> 02:43:12.420
peter: Hi, thank you. Peter Bernhardt, resident of Albany, where we're also tracking this particular issue.

1072
02:43:12.420 --> 02:43:26.810
peter: A lot's been said. I'm just going to cover a couple technical issues. First, if you go to the transparency Portal, which I would invite all your council members to do, you'll find that, actually, data is shared with over a thousand agencies across the state of California.

1073
02:43:26.880 --> 02:43:37.069
peter: Every individual in each of those agencies represents a vector of risk, and systems like this are primarily, fallible to humans.

1074
02:43:37.230 --> 02:43:42.420
peter: In my years of software development, that's the thing I would say, everything works fine until people get involved.

1075
02:43:42.490 --> 02:43:46.930
peter: And you've got far too many people with access to this to begin with. You can fix that today.

1076
02:43:46.950 --> 02:44:06.140
peter: Also, you're also… Flock also devolves security responsibility to the communities, so you have to do your own auditing. They could add a feature to their system that would provide alerts to flag unauthorized access, access from agencies that shouldn't be looking at their data, but they don't do that, because they want you to do it.

1077
02:44:06.310 --> 02:44:10.770
peter: And they hope that things will be forgotten, overlooked, as they were in Mountain View until they were.

1078
02:44:12.050 --> 02:44:14.040
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is Hope Dixon.

1079
02:44:14.530 --> 02:44:17.740
City of El Cerrito: Hope you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

1080
02:44:19.290 --> 02:44:21.860
Hope Dixon (She/They): Hi, thank you for hearing me. Can you hear me okay?

1081
02:44:22.470 --> 02:44:24.749
City of El Cerrito: We can't… can you speak up, please?

1082
02:44:25.050 --> 02:44:26.940
Hope Dixon (She/They): Hello, can you hear me okay?

1083
02:44:27.450 --> 02:44:29.460
City of El Cerrito: David, that's better, go ahead and begin.

1084
02:44:29.460 --> 02:44:41.900
Hope Dixon (She/They): Thank you, I appreciate it. My name is Hope Dixon, I'm an educator at the local community college as a basic needs coordinator. I have to say, just like as an LGBT community member in West Contra Costa.

1085
02:44:42.010 --> 02:44:52.130
Hope Dixon (She/They): I'm pretty terrified these days of what's happening in our community, and these flaw cameras terrify me. I know my friends and I are just kind of planning for the worst.

1086
02:44:52.360 --> 02:45:00.110
Hope Dixon (She/They): Our immigrant communities, they need and care and matter, and they make a difference, and so we… we can do better.

1087
02:45:00.110 --> 02:45:15.490
Hope Dixon (She/They): I know you're up against some hard decisions right now, but I hope that you can, like, take a long look at that beautiful community in front of you, because they are amazing, and they said some great things, and really listen to your constituents, and I hope that you can vote no this evening. Thank you so much for your time.

1088
02:45:18.060 --> 02:45:23.590
City of El Cerrito: Okay, our next speaker is Jane Hood. Jane, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

1089
02:45:24.870 --> 02:45:33.649
Jane Hood: Hi, my name is Jane. I am an El Cerrito resident, and I, like everyone else, I'm calling for you to not renew the flock contract.

1090
02:45:33.650 --> 02:45:54.420
Jane Hood: I want to specifically point out what a previous speaker mentioned, that this is not just a license plate reader. They have advanced AI capabilities, which are basically designed to track people. It is not just about a car, it is about the person driving the car, and what locations they've been to. The police chief mentioned that this can track

1091
02:45:54.420 --> 02:46:15.580
Jane Hood: a car in multiple locations, so that might be multiple sensitive locations that the driver visits, like a health clinic, a protest, a meeting, their job, their home. So I'm against any, expansion of this program or continuation of it, and I was just personally unimpressed by the answers that the flock representative gave tonight on many of the City Council's good questions.

1092
02:46:17.630 --> 02:46:20.169
City of El Cerrito: Our next speaker is WB.

1093
02:46:22.340 --> 02:46:27.610
City of El Cerrito: If you could please identify your name for the record, and you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

1094
02:46:28.230 --> 02:46:29.580
WB: Hi, I'm Nina.

1095
02:46:29.580 --> 02:46:52.110
WB: I, take, client meetings in El Cerrito, shop in El Cerrito, and I want to let everyone know I've worked in tech for 10 years with the brightest minds in cybersecurity, working for the largest tech companies, who will tell you no amount of amendments, contracts, SOC 2 audits can keep this data safe from hackers. Additionally, in Oakland.

1096
02:46:52.110 --> 02:46:59.109
WB: There is a missing woman named Amy Hillard. There are 21 flock cameras within a 1.3 mile radius of where she was last seen.

1097
02:46:59.610 --> 02:47:01.670
WB: This presentation has stated that

1098
02:47:01.760 --> 02:47:11.919
WB: This technology is used for public safety and help with missing persons cases, so… so where's Amy Hillard? How has this technology not found her… helped find her in the city of Oakland?

1099
02:47:11.920 --> 02:47:28.920
WB: Last, I want to speak to the police officers in the room. From my experience, the implementation of automation and AI technology has always led to a loss of jobs. This tech will absolutely be used later to justify not hiring more police officers, because they have the tech that can do the job, quote-unquote, more efficiently. Thank you.

1100
02:47:28.920 --> 02:47:42.360
City of El Cerrito: Thank you for your comments. Mayor, that concludes our request to speak on this item. Okay, very good. We'll bring it back to the Council. I just want to let our residents know and our audience know here that we heard you loud and clear. Any final thoughts? We'll start over here to my left.

1101
02:47:43.340 --> 02:47:54.749
City of El Cerrito: I want to go ahead and make a motion that we continue this item to further discussion, and even possibly a study session on it, if possible, for the… what was it, the May 5th meeting that we said that it had to be?

1102
02:47:54.900 --> 02:48:04.139
City of El Cerrito: So that's… I think that's the only thing left to be said. Can I ask if you'd be open to an amendment on the motion to… to ask for… I mean, I don't…

1103
02:48:04.140 --> 02:48:28.210
City of El Cerrito: I mean, we could make it a study session slash vote, but it sounds like we have to make some level of decision on May 5th, just based on the deadline. My request, and I think it'd be fine to have, sort of, study session, like, where we could have more of a conversation, though we, I think, have had a good conversation tonight. But my main amendment is to ask for some more options to be brought back, not

1104
02:48:28.210 --> 02:48:42.199
City of El Cerrito: just the 3-year option, if that is possible, and I know, I mean, if Flock says no, then we'll just have to vote up or down, so it's sort of up to them if they want to play ball or not, but if the Chief could attempt that.

1105
02:48:42.200 --> 02:48:46.559
City of El Cerrito: I'm okay with that amendment. Do we need to specify how many options?

1106
02:48:46.560 --> 02:49:02.510
City of El Cerrito: Or just more options? I just… what I want to see, and I think I said this pretty clearly before, is some shorter-term options, so that we could then have some time to either negotiate a better contract or figure out another solution.

1107
02:49:02.510 --> 02:49:05.310
City of El Cerrito: Because I do understand that the department

1108
02:49:05.560 --> 02:49:12.259
City of El Cerrito: does depend on these cameras right now, and I understand it would be challenging to all of a sudden have them turned off.

1109
02:49:12.380 --> 02:49:28.750
City of El Cerrito: I also don't think that this is a good solution, but I want to figure out some interim, because I can understand that probably much of the council would not be comfortable just turning them off right away. So I'd like some other options. If there aren't, I'll…

1110
02:49:28.750 --> 02:49:39.480
City of El Cerrito: you know, probably vote against that. I would add that amendment, and also if there's any information about other vendors, just so that we have everything on the table that is available to us.

1111
02:49:39.520 --> 02:49:51.499
City of El Cerrito: I will… I'm okay with that amendment. Do you still want to second that, Councilmember? I'll second that, but can I also add a small amendment? I would like Flock to send someone that can answer the question. Yeah, oh, yes!

1112
02:49:52.130 --> 02:50:11.059
City of El Cerrito: That… that… I don't know if that district… should we put that in the… in the IDL? Yeah. Or can we just direct… say… say, Chief, have a better representative? Yes. I just want to make sure we have both sides, though. We've talked a lot about FLOC and their representation. I would also like someone like the American Civil Liberties… Civil Liberties Union to come.

1113
02:50:11.950 --> 02:50:28.970
City of El Cerrito: They're welcome to come. This is an open meeting, and they have been here in the past, so, so, they're welcome to speak and open comment, but if we want to do a study session… That's… that was going to be in my question to the city manager, city attorney. If we do a study session, can we also include the vote?

1114
02:50:30.840 --> 02:50:46.139
City of El Cerrito: I believe that, first of all, you don't need to make a motion to continue the item. That could be just a Council direction to continue the item, first and foremost. But secondly, and we're certainly hearing your direction, and we're taking notes for that,

1115
02:50:46.140 --> 02:50:52.729
City of El Cerrito: A study session implies that there is no vote, that usually we have a study session that is a

1116
02:50:52.730 --> 02:51:11.530
City of El Cerrito: a conversation, a discussion, and provides direction to staff. This would be… continuing this item means it would continue to be a policy discussion, and then, again, there would be… because we have a deadline in order to either… to give Flock, notice if we're not going to renew this contract.

1117
02:51:11.610 --> 02:51:26.729
City of El Cerrito: we would need to have a decision by the City Council on the 5th. So I do propose that we continue the item. I suspect, Councilmember, that someone will probably show up from the ACLU. You don't think so? I don't think that a minute gives them an opportunity to…

1118
02:51:26.750 --> 02:51:41.009
City of El Cerrito: go into the complexities of this issue. Can I clarify something on public comment? My understanding is if we do, especially if an expert speaker shows up who's a public speaker, we could ask questions of them, is that correct?

1119
02:51:41.550 --> 02:51:45.110
City of El Cerrito: And I guess that would be up to the mayor, somewhat.

1120
02:51:45.850 --> 02:51:48.980
City of El Cerrito: Yeah, the, the…

1121
02:51:49.020 --> 02:52:13.840
City of El Cerrito: it's not Council policy to ask questions of speakers, but the mayor does have discretion to grant additional time to anybody that the Council feels they'd like to hear more. So you're telling us if we want to talk to the ACLU, we all need to do it individually, because we can't ask them any questions if they come and speak here? The public comment policy is for the public to be able to address the Council, not

1122
02:52:13.840 --> 02:52:16.240
City of El Cerrito: for… Or questions from the Council.

1123
02:52:17.040 --> 02:52:29.449
City of El Cerrito: Is there any… That's not how everybody treats it. I mean, that's the part where we ask questions of public commenters all the time, so it's not the rule of law that requires that. I'm not suggesting it's a law, I'm just saying that's council policy.

1124
02:52:30.670 --> 02:52:47.589
City of El Cerrito: I'm thinking in my mind, is there any other… I don't know another mechanism… and I'm speaking like I'm the mayor, I'm not the mayor anymore. One thing, know the importance of what we're discussing, and I'm, let's table this, and we will deal with this at the next meeting.

1125
02:52:47.590 --> 02:52:52.030
City of El Cerrito: We have a deadline on May, May 6th, so,

1126
02:52:52.030 --> 02:53:01.719
City of El Cerrito: our May 5th meeting, we'll be able to discuss it. So, let's, so I support tabling this for the next council meeting.

1127
02:53:03.340 --> 02:53:04.659
City of El Cerrito: Are you guys good with that?

1128
02:53:04.790 --> 02:53:08.610
City of El Cerrito: I'm okay with that. Okay. Is there anything that you need?

1129
02:53:08.830 --> 02:53:19.170
City of El Cerrito: Well, there was a motion on the floor, so even if we heard it all, I… I mean, the motion was for us to continue the item, but we apparently don't need a motion to continue the item.

1130
02:53:20.130 --> 02:53:38.569
City of El Cerrito: If the attorney agrees, I think we have sufficient direction from the City Council to bring this back on May 5th to continue the discussion. We should clarify that you're withdrawing the motion. And the seconder was agreeable to that, okay. I would like to make a motion, then, to invite the ACLU to come as part of our study session.

1131
02:53:38.880 --> 02:53:40.549
City of El Cerrito: Not a slit session.

1132
02:53:40.830 --> 02:53:51.380
City of El Cerrito: That's not a discussion. We're… this is a council meeting that will… Oh, that's my motion. But they're welcome to join us. They… as an ACLU member, they're welcome to join us. So,

1133
02:53:51.630 --> 02:54:00.300
City of El Cerrito: And they have attended these meetings in the past, and I look forward to having them back. I would like to make a motion to invite them to make a presentation.

1134
02:54:03.710 --> 02:54:05.269
City of El Cerrito: I'll second that motion.

1135
02:54:05.690 --> 02:54:13.589
City of El Cerrito: But again, not as part of a study session, because I understand it can't be a study session. So let's, city attorney.

1136
02:54:19.160 --> 02:54:43.110
City of El Cerrito: I mean, if the City Council would like to have, would like to… if the Council as a whole would like to have, somebody from a particular body come to speak on this item and give them additional time beyond the… whatever the amount of time that's allotted for public speakers, City Council has the authority to do that. This is important, so I will support this for May 5th, and

1137
02:54:43.290 --> 02:54:44.450
City of El Cerrito: We'll go from there.

1138
02:54:46.100 --> 02:54:49.359
City of El Cerrito: So there's a motion on the floor. Yes.

1139
02:54:50.110 --> 02:54:51.349
City of El Cerrito: No, we don't need one.

1140
02:54:51.690 --> 02:55:00.590
City of El Cerrito: So, Councilmember, are you okay with that and withdrawing your motion? I'm really moderating like I'm the mayor. I don't understand. There's a motion on the floor.

1141
02:55:00.990 --> 02:55:08.180
City of El Cerrito: to invite the ACLU to do a presentation? Is that the understanding? And it was seconded?

1142
02:55:09.400 --> 02:55:22.520
City of El Cerrito: Correct? So, either the council will vote, I… I mean, I think… I believe that in this case, staff, because this is not typical council policy, I believe staff would benefit from the direction of a vote.

1143
02:55:24.460 --> 02:55:27.529
City of El Cerrito: And you seconded that? No. Okay, all in favor?

1144
02:55:27.780 --> 02:55:29.210
City of El Cerrito: Aye. Aye.

1145
02:55:30.190 --> 02:55:33.019
City of El Cerrito: Any… any opposed?

1146
02:55:33.130 --> 02:55:39.649
City of El Cerrito: Motion carries. So, Bob, we will continue this on… our main meeting. Thank you.

1147
02:55:39.940 --> 02:55:50.500
City of El Cerrito: Next, we'll go to… fiscal year 2026-27, and fiscal year 27-28 biannual. A couple minute recess.

1148
02:55:50.810 --> 02:55:51.700
City of El Cerrito: It's true.

1149
02:55:52.420 --> 02:55:56.889
City of El Cerrito: We're requesting a bio break for 5 minutes. Make it 10 minutes.

1150
02:55:59.250 --> 02:56:01.980
City of El Cerrito: Or for a while longer.

1151
03:06:33.470 --> 03:06:38.599
City of El Cerrito: I just want to make sure it didn't help. I bet my teeth are all black here.

1152
03:06:42.140 --> 03:06:46.250
City of El Cerrito: Okay, it's, 9-10, we're gonna start now.

1153
03:06:46.580 --> 03:06:57.880
City of El Cerrito: We have the fiscal year 2026-27, and fiscal year 2027-28 Biannual budget study session. And we have,

1154
03:06:58.270 --> 03:07:00.720
City of El Cerrito: Claire, and we have Crystal here. Welcome.

1155
03:07:01.710 --> 03:07:13.899
City of El Cerrito: Hello, good evening, Mayor and Council. Claire Coleman, Budget and Financial Services Manager. I'm new to this microphone. Is this volume okay? All right, and I promise I will try to speak a little slower.

1156
03:07:13.920 --> 03:07:32.839
City of El Cerrito: So, this evening, we are going to be talking about the biennial budget. So, we are in the midst of the biennial budget development process. So, to begin with, I want to give a brief reminder and overview of where we are in the process currently. So, if you recall, in January, we had the Council Priority Setting Retreat.

1157
03:07:32.850 --> 03:07:56.870
City of El Cerrito: And then we also have had the budget survey and community workshops and the department head presentations. So right now, we have been in the data gathering, and then now in the context-setting portion of this budget process. So first, we had the department head presentations to provide the context of what departments do, what city services we provide, to underpin the understanding of what this budget does, and all of the services that it provides for the community.

1158
03:07:57.020 --> 03:08:08.510
City of El Cerrito: This evening, my presentation will focus on the greater context for this budget. So, again, looking at, where we're going to be looking at the feedback that we've received in our community outreach work.

1159
03:08:08.510 --> 03:08:21.110
City of El Cerrito: We will be looking at some revenue and expenditure numbers, so early… not really early trends, these are the underlying budget estimates and the major expenditures that the city doesn't necessarily have control over at this time.

1160
03:08:21.110 --> 03:08:22.270
City of El Cerrito: And then…

1161
03:08:22.270 --> 03:08:41.189
City of El Cerrito: Later on in the process, on May 5th, I'm going to return to you. So this is the first of five meetings in a row where you're gonna get to hang out with me for a lot of time talking about the budget, so I hope we're in for a good time, or at least some good discussions. So on May 5th, in 2 weeks, I will be back talking with you, and that will be the second study session.

1162
03:08:41.190 --> 03:08:53.869
City of El Cerrito: At that meeting, we're going to be discussing actual budget scenarios. So we're going to come with different possible scenarios of ways to balance the budget. There are a few different ways that the Council can consider based on different priorities that have been expressed over time.

1163
03:08:53.870 --> 03:09:03.580
City of El Cerrito: Based on that discussion, we will either then develop the budget book for the June 2nd meeting, or we would potentially come back again for discussion on May 19th.

1164
03:09:03.580 --> 03:09:10.609
City of El Cerrito: But also on May 19th, I will be back either way, because we will also be reviewing and discussing the master fee schedule for adoption.

1165
03:09:10.640 --> 03:09:25.590
City of El Cerrito: The master fee schedule does impact the fiscal year 26-27 budget, but it's also based on the fiscal 26-27 budget, so we really kind of need the basis of some of those numbers to be able to even develop those master fee schedule, those master fee estimates.

1166
03:09:25.590 --> 03:09:44.449
City of El Cerrito: Then, on June 2nd, the City Council will review the draft budget book, so we will have the full budget book for review. Our dream goal, if we can possibly do it, is to get it to you before Memorial Day weekend, but given the number of other… given the number of meetings and things, it may get pushed to a week later. But our goal is to get that to you as early as possible, to review the draft budget book.

1167
03:09:44.450 --> 03:09:59.999
City of El Cerrito: for the June 2nd meeting, and then come back one… two weeks later for what we hope will be the formal and official adoption of the budget book, and that's adoption of the two-year budget, but as a reminder, we do legally adopt the appropriation limit on an annual basis.

1168
03:10:00.300 --> 03:10:05.960
City of El Cerrito: So that's where we've been, that's where we're going. As I noted this evening, we're going to talk about public engagement results.

1169
03:10:05.960 --> 03:10:21.150
City of El Cerrito: revenue and expenditure trends, and some information, some preliminary capital information, capital improvement program budget information. We've been working really hard on some improvements to our capital improvement program and our capital improvement program budget document.

1170
03:10:21.150 --> 03:10:31.970
City of El Cerrito: I'm going to call that CIP moving forward, just because it's a bit of a mouthful, but we're really excited to start rolling out some of those CIP document, improvements, especially in the way that we communicate CIP to the public.

1171
03:10:32.650 --> 03:10:35.049
City of El Cerrito: So first, public engagement results.

1172
03:10:35.260 --> 03:10:55.829
City of El Cerrito: So we did two primary things. We did a budget survey that was online and available to the public, and then we did two different budget workshops, which were the same content, but held in two different mediums. So first, on the budget survey, it was open from January 16th through March 31st. It had 173 respondents, 96% of whom self-reported as living in El Cerrito.

1173
03:10:55.980 --> 03:11:05.110
City of El Cerrito: We don't have a way to verify that, and we trust people to tell us honestly. There were 4 primary questions that looked at the investment levels of 16 core city services.

1174
03:11:05.110 --> 03:11:16.089
City of El Cerrito: Top 3 budget priorities for the next 2 years. There was an activity where respondents could allocate points across different infrastructure categories, and then there was an opportunity for open-ended comments.

1175
03:11:17.550 --> 03:11:40.589
City of El Cerrito: This is a very large, list, because as you can imagine, 16 services, there were a lot of different things to choose from. The ones at the bottom actually received the highest amount of points. So those are open space and trails, parks and facilities, fire safety and wildfire, economic development, and business. So those are the top four vote-getters, and those are the ones that both received either needs or investment at a very high, high frequency.

1176
03:11:40.590 --> 03:11:49.249
City of El Cerrito: or received needs less investment at a low frequency. So those are the ones that were considered either in a good place or needed more investment, overwhelmingly so.

1177
03:11:49.250 --> 03:12:02.580
City of El Cerrito: Very few, as you can see, were marked as needing less investment. So I think in general, resident, or at least survey respondents, believe that these services are important and should either receive the same amount or more investment.

1178
03:12:02.690 --> 03:12:20.859
City of El Cerrito: This is question number one. Question number two looked at the most important needs for the city in the next two-year budget. The top three in this case were parks and facility maintenance, fire safety and wildlife prevention, economic development, and business support. As you can see, there's a theme among many of these respondent… responses.

1179
03:12:22.260 --> 03:12:32.560
City of El Cerrito: Next, there was an alloc… this was the allocation activity where residents allocated 10 votes across different core areas, so they could allocate multiple votes for certain categories if they wanted.

1180
03:12:32.560 --> 03:12:46.670
City of El Cerrito: So this is the weighted result. This is the average number of votes that respondents gave to each of these categories. So, by far, number one was parks and Recreation facilities, so that received an average of 2.87 votes per respondent.

1181
03:12:46.670 --> 03:12:50.949
City of El Cerrito: Followed by streets and transportation with 2.21 average votes per respondent.

1182
03:12:51.890 --> 03:13:14.839
City of El Cerrito: I do think stormwater management is a little tough one in my experience with other public agencies and with peers at other agencies. Things like stormwater and sewer are often lowest priority until they overflow, and then you realize that, oh, shoot, those are pretty important. Just because one that works well, you don't… you don't notice it. But that was the lowest priority, is stormwater management, and then other capital investments, which I know can be a little hard to vote for when it's that nebulous.

1183
03:13:16.100 --> 03:13:35.649
City of El Cerrito: So these were overall themes from comments and feedback. As you can see, these are the same core themes that you've seen through the other responses. We received a wide variety of different types of comments, but in order to summarize them for this presentation, I just, I put them into some key theme areas. So you see wildfire prevention, public safety, both police and fire.

1184
03:13:35.650 --> 03:13:37.020
City of El Cerrito: Parks and Recreation.

1185
03:13:37.020 --> 03:13:44.419
City of El Cerrito: Roads, sidewalks, and traffic, tree maintenance, economic development and business support. And then we did hear a lot about concerns about fiscal sustainability of the city.

1186
03:13:46.250 --> 03:14:00.749
City of El Cerrito: For the budget workshops, we held two workshops. One was in person on March 7th, which had 11 attendees, plus two council members. And then we had a virtual workshop on March 25th, 2026, which three people came to, which was,

1187
03:14:00.790 --> 03:14:14.190
City of El Cerrito: It was all right, so it was in the evening on a Wednesday, and I know people are very busy, and we also did note that it would be recorded and published, so the recording is available on the City's website. The respondent… the attendees who we started with were not the same attendees who we ended with.

1188
03:14:14.190 --> 03:14:27.960
City of El Cerrito: which I won't take personally, but we ended up not doing the survey activities because it just wasn't enough people for us to get good data and anonymize it well. But I do have the results to present from the in-person workshop on March 7th.

1189
03:14:28.350 --> 03:14:46.920
City of El Cerrito: In these two workshops, it was both a review of city finances and a review of some of the core city services. And then we did two activities, one which was a survey to consider different trade-offs, and the other was a prioritization activity of core service areas, pretty similar to that points allocation activity that was a part of the online survey.

1190
03:14:48.140 --> 03:15:02.829
City of El Cerrito: I do want to note for both of these, we do our best to publicize these opportunities. We publicize them on social media, we put them in the city manager's newsletter, we put them out in every… in all of the different mediums, on posts or physical posters around the city.

1191
03:15:03.540 --> 03:15:21.739
City of El Cerrito: That being said, we only receive the feedback that we receive, and we know that there are sometimes groups and people who may not be represented, or certain groups who are very active and engaged who we may be more represented than typically would be representative of the full city population. So this is not necessarily a statistically significant sampling.

1192
03:15:21.740 --> 03:15:37.869
City of El Cerrito: But it is valuable feedback, in my opinion, to present to the Council about what residents' preferences and priorities are at this time. But I do want to note that this is not considered statistically significant from a data analysis and data science and surveying

1193
03:15:37.870 --> 03:15:39.710
City of El Cerrito: polling perspective.

1194
03:15:40.770 --> 03:15:57.830
City of El Cerrito: So for the workshop survey, we asked four questions. So the first was, if expenditures continue to grow faster than revenues, and infrastructure continues to deteriorate, which should be prioritized first? Maintaining current services and deferring maintenance, or beginning addressing the backlog, even if it requires service reductions? I…

1195
03:15:57.830 --> 03:16:07.759
City of El Cerrito: We asked some pretty tough questions of our workshop respondents, and in this case, it was over… it was unanimous that the city should begin addressing the backlog of deferred maintenance, even if it requires service reductions.

1196
03:16:08.110 --> 03:16:22.420
City of El Cerrito: The second question is, with rising costs, should the City prioritize preserving service levels, even if reserves decline, or preserving… or protecting financial stability, even if service levels must adjust? Not unanimous this time, but there was a majority in favor of protecting financial stability.

1197
03:16:23.840 --> 03:16:39.130
City of El Cerrito: For the third question, if reserves fell below policy targets due to rising costs, should the city restore reserves before expanding services, or restoring services, or keep lower reserves in order to maintain services? Again, not unanimous, but a majority voted for A, which is restoring reserves first.

1198
03:16:39.300 --> 03:16:48.580
City of El Cerrito: And then finally, if the city identifies one-time funding, how would respondents prefer it to be used? And this had a mixed group, and there was one person who voted for two.

1199
03:16:48.580 --> 03:17:01.100
City of El Cerrito: But typically, the most popular response was addressing one-time infrastructure or capital needs only, with some voting for saving in reserves, and a few also voting for, temporarily supporting ongoing services.

1200
03:17:02.980 --> 03:17:08.520
City of El Cerrito: Moving on to revenues and expenditures. These are the estimates, for the

1201
03:17:08.820 --> 03:17:17.649
City of El Cerrito: upcoming budgets. We have completed our revenue estimates, and so these… some of these things are going to be included in the presentation on May 5th as well.

1202
03:17:17.980 --> 03:17:31.390
City of El Cerrito: First, I want to note some of the economic conditions. We are in an uncertain economy. Seems like every time we make a budget, it's an uncertain economy for about the past 6 years. It's been a pretty wild ride. As you can imagine if you've read the paper recently.

1203
03:17:31.390 --> 03:17:43.970
City of El Cerrito: there's a lot going on, and there's a lot that we really don't know. We have international conflicts that are really wrecking havoc on both financial markets, but also commodities markets. We have a lot of uncertainty around tariffs and litigation surrounding those.

1204
03:17:43.970 --> 03:17:50.229
City of El Cerrito: We have a very complex interest rate environment, we have potentially a new Fed chair, and some big unknowns regarding that.

1205
03:17:50.230 --> 03:18:09.630
City of El Cerrito: We have some consumer confidence issues where there's just a lot of insecurity and uncertainty around where the economy is going right now. And you can see that in the financial markets. March was a very down year. For example, in the S&P 500, you see it was very down, and then in April, it has predominantly rebounded, and then it was down a bit today. So we're just on a little bit of a financial rollercoaster right now.

1206
03:18:09.630 --> 03:18:21.509
City of El Cerrito: Inflation is stabilizing relative to a few years ago, but inflation is still significantly impacting costs, especially in areas where we may have locked into contracts, and those contracts are now expiring and up for renegotiation.

1207
03:18:21.570 --> 03:18:28.009
City of El Cerrito: We also have some volatile and costly insurance markets, and I'll speak more to insurance in a moment.

1208
03:18:28.010 --> 03:18:50.210
City of El Cerrito: Here in El Cerrito, El Cerrito has a very stable and a very diverse tax base. When you've seen the graph of… I don't have it for you today, but the graph of where El Cerrito's revenues come from, especially in the general fund, it's a rainbow, and it's a very, mixed rainbow, and we're very lucky. Many of our peers are very concentrated in one area, and the diversity of our revenues gives us more stability, than we might otherwise have.

1209
03:18:50.280 --> 03:19:02.870
City of El Cerrito: Many of our taxes are received on a lag. For example, property taxes are on an 18-month lag, so that somewhat insulates us, like many of our peers, from recessionary impacts immediately, and gives us a bit of runway if something were to happen.

1210
03:19:02.870 --> 03:19:13.240
City of El Cerrito: Currently we are seeing steady real estate markets, and over the past few years since I've been here, sales taxes in El Cerrito have either been outperforming or meeting state sales tax trends.

1211
03:19:13.990 --> 03:19:21.820
City of El Cerrito: Like I mentioned, we are somewhat insulated because we have a very, stable revenue base. Property taxes are 34% of our general fund.

1212
03:19:21.940 --> 03:19:30.599
City of El Cerrito: But both equity markets and other financial markets, like commodity markets, impact a lot of different things in the community, so things like discretionary spending.

1213
03:19:30.600 --> 03:19:48.640
City of El Cerrito: Property transfer taxes, if interest rates significantly change, property markets and real estate markets are significantly impacted by that. Equity markets and other financial markets affect CalPERS returns and our pension liabilities, and so there are all kinds of different ways that these volatile markets might impact city finances over time, so there are things that we consider

1214
03:19:48.640 --> 03:20:02.269
City of El Cerrito: But we also have to be careful about finding the balance between considering this potential volatility while also doing the best we can, because at some point, we have to create a budget. So we have to do the best budget that we can right now with the information that we have available.

1215
03:20:03.380 --> 03:20:26.439
City of El Cerrito: So on the tax side, property taxes, we use HDL, which is… oh, it stands for, I think, Hindelater Delamas, but we always call them HDL. There's two different pieces. There's actually a property tax company, and then an all the other taxes company, but we just refer to them as HDL, and they're our expert consultants on sales tax, utility taxes, and property taxes. So they provide our expert forecasts for many of these revenue areas.

1216
03:20:26.440 --> 03:20:37.470
City of El Cerrito: We are currently expecting a 5% annual increase in property taxes over the next 2 years. Excuse me, that's a 5% annual increase, so it's not 5% over 2 years, it's 5% each year.

1217
03:20:37.470 --> 03:20:47.639
City of El Cerrito: And that's the result of both the 2% increase allowable under Proposition 13, and the significant increases that we see from properties when they are sold and reassessed at the new valuation.

1218
03:20:48.150 --> 03:21:00.240
City of El Cerrito: We did complete the successor… the dissolution of the successor agency to the redevelopment agency this year. We are very excited about that. We expect to start to see those financial impacts in the coming fiscal year.

1219
03:21:00.840 --> 03:21:17.510
City of El Cerrito: We, on the property transfer tax side, we are currently expecting to see a 6% increase, in next fiscal year over the current year budget, and that's because we are currently outperforming the current year budget. So that's not a 6% increase over actuals, but a 6% increase over budget.

1220
03:21:17.510 --> 03:21:31.959
City of El Cerrito: Another piece is that we would expect to see a 3% increase in fiscal 28 over 27. Property transfer tax is one of our most volatile revenue sources, so this is one of the ones that we track very carefully, but is one of the more difficult ones to forecast two years out.

1221
03:21:32.760 --> 03:21:41.440
City of El Cerrito: Our business license and operations tax is very stable. It has a small annual increase per the city's municipal code, but has very low volatility in that tax revenue side.

1222
03:21:42.090 --> 03:21:55.350
City of El Cerrito: On the sales taxes, we are expecting our Bradley Burns, which is our 1% sales tax that we get that every single city in California gets. We're expecting that to increase by 5% in fiscal 27, and 2.6% in fiscal 28.

1223
03:21:55.350 --> 03:22:09.180
City of El Cerrito: The 2.6% is for all forms of transactions and use tax or sales tax, which is… TUT is transactions and use tax, which is a form of sales tax. A question might be, why are these different? Why would the Bradley Burns 1%

1224
03:22:09.180 --> 03:22:31.359
City of El Cerrito: sales tax be different than the locally adopted transactions and use taxes, and I will not bore you with the conversation about CITUS and whether something's in-state versus out of state when you buy it online, and which warehouse it's located, and all of those fun things, but the skinny of it all is that they're a little bit different, and so they behave a little differently, and because we have HDL's expert forecasts, we're able to get a little more granularity in our forecasting.

1225
03:22:31.780 --> 03:22:33.599
City of El Cerrito: On the utility tax side.

1226
03:22:33.600 --> 03:22:58.370
City of El Cerrito: We're expecting 5% increase in energy costs next year in energy as electric and gas. And that is a result of a couple of pieces. That's both PG&E's rate structure changes, which we're expected to balance out for the most part, but then they also received approval from the CPUC to allocate about $1.6 billion across, their ratepayers for wildfire costs. We are also seeing some major volatility and shakeups in the natural gas.

1227
03:22:58.370 --> 03:23:11.539
City of El Cerrito: markets right now that are expected to last for at least 18 months to 2 years. Now, granted, those are not immediately passed on to consumers, because PG&E has to go through the CPUC, but we want to be realistic about the ways that some of these utility markets are moving.

1228
03:23:11.540 --> 03:23:32.110
City of El Cerrito: So that's our expectation on electric and gas. Water is a lot easier because East Bay Mud tells us. So we're estimating 7% because that's the approved rate, and then in the second year, we estimate about 6.5%, because that's the average of the past few years of East Bay Mud rate changes. We are expecting a decrease of 5% in telecom, which is consistent with trends over the past,

1229
03:23:32.210 --> 03:23:44.499
City of El Cerrito: probably 5 to 10 years as cable cutting continues. There is some new litigation in the streaming world that we are paying attention to, but we are not engaging in until there's a little bit more settled case law.

1230
03:23:45.200 --> 03:24:02.610
City of El Cerrito: Hotel taxes are a really insignificant source of revenue for El Cerrito. They're very, very small. We don't have very many taxes. We are not Anaheim, who has, I think, $50 million a year, at least. I think it's $150 million in hotel taxes annually, so it's a small revenue source for us. We pay attention to it, but it's pretty minor.

1231
03:24:04.280 --> 03:24:23.540
City of El Cerrito: On the non-tax side, as I mentioned, on May 19th, I will be bringing with some of my colleagues, bringing a master fee schedule to the City Council for consideration for adoption. Most of these fees are limited to cost recovery basis. We have our updated cost allocation plan and master fee study completed last year with the consultant firm Will Dan.

1232
03:24:23.630 --> 03:24:30.470
City of El Cerrito: Some of these increases are based on inflation or other estimates, if they are not limited to actual cost recovery.

1233
03:24:30.510 --> 03:24:46.859
City of El Cerrito: On the fines and forfeitures side, we're seeing some steady and increasing revenue from fines and forfeitures due to higher enforcement activity by the police department in particular, and then I believe they were also getting through a backlog that they've had over the past few years, in the last year or two, so they've been clearing out that backlog.

1234
03:24:47.190 --> 03:24:57.979
City of El Cerrito: On the grants side, we budget for grants if they are confirmed and we know that they are real. Until we are absolutely certain of them, we don't budget for them. We bring them back to Council when they are awarded and certain.

1235
03:24:58.270 --> 03:25:20.080
City of El Cerrito: We do have some very significant grants, especially in the transportation side, some pretty big grants and state subventions over the next couple of years that we can mention in the CIP section. And then on the cannabis side, statewide trends are currently showing a contracting cannabis market. There's a lot of still pressures from the illicit market, a lot of pressures from various forms of regulatory fees and taxation.

1236
03:25:20.080 --> 03:25:31.760
City of El Cerrito: But there's also a possible shift in the cannabis market if it is rescheduled from Schedule 1 to Schedule 3 at the federal level, which would have some significant impacts to business operations, especially on the banking side.

1237
03:25:31.760 --> 03:25:39.219
City of El Cerrito: So we'll see what happens with that. I believe it's been fast-tracked at the federal level, but, we don't know exactly when or how that will go.

1238
03:25:40.320 --> 03:25:58.139
City of El Cerrito: On the expenditure side, personnel is the largest part of the city expenditures. We always say people are services. It's the firefighters who come, it's the police officers who come to an incident, it's the staff who review the permits, so people are the services that we provide as a city, overwhelmingly.

1239
03:25:58.140 --> 03:26:12.029
City of El Cerrito: One of the largest contributors to our current expenditure trends are new labor agreements. Those have been adopted and approved by the City Council over the past couple of years. Those include cost of building adjustments of 3 to 3.5%, depending on the unit.

1240
03:26:12.030 --> 03:26:29.480
City of El Cerrito: There are also market adjustments for 16 different position classifications, between 3% and 10.25% over the two years. So that's not 10.25% annually, but that's across the two years, and that's based on the classification and compensation study for positions that were found to be significantly below market rate.

1241
03:26:29.730 --> 03:26:40.299
City of El Cerrito: For the most part, the largest percentage increases are in SEIU, and so those are… in… within the city's labor agreements, you can see exactly what percentages are changing if you want to see the detail.

1242
03:26:40.490 --> 03:27:03.090
City of El Cerrito: We also have some new one-time or increased benefits, depending on the bargaining unit. I will note that the PEA, the Police Employees Association, contract expires on June 30th, and so that is currently in the process of beginning negotiations, but if those are not completed before budget adoption, there may be consideration of budget amendments shortly after the budget is adopted, just based on the timing of the negotiations.

1243
03:27:03.500 --> 03:27:22.179
City of El Cerrito: One of the largest contributors to personal cost increases, other than our labor agreements, are medical benefits. Our healthcare… our health cost increases, in particular, we expect to go up about 9%, which is very high. It is consistent with what we're seeing with peers. It's not unique to us, but it is,

1244
03:27:22.180 --> 03:27:38.579
City of El Cerrito: We're not the only ones with the problem, but we do have the problem, which is that medical costs are increasing very, very quickly. Dental costs are increasing, but at a slower rate. And the medical benefits, both medical and dental, are fully paid by the city for all full-time employees and their dependents.

1245
03:27:39.890 --> 03:27:56.559
City of El Cerrito: On the CalPERS side, on the pension side. So, this is a slightly different graph than you may have seen before. This is the current, pension estimates based on the 2024 report that was published, and that's the most recent one that's available. The new one will come out at the end of September for the 2025 year.

1246
03:27:56.670 --> 03:28:20.489
City of El Cerrito: What you can see in this UAL, which is the blue section, is that we are getting pretty close to what I'll call peak UAL. We expect that to be around 2032, although that could shift depending on market returns, but we're getting to the point where our pension costs will start to decline, and that's the result of the shift from Classic to PEPRA members. That little bump in the out year, I always thought that was really weird. It's because there was a…

1247
03:28:20.690 --> 03:28:40.839
City of El Cerrito: It's niche. There was an exceptionally good year, and if you remember that CalPERS schedules are like… it's like if you had a different mortgage every year, and they're layered on top of each other. When the really, really good one goes away, the pension cost spikes really quickly. So it's a little bit counterintuitive that when the really good one expires, it goes up, but that's why you have that spike out in

1248
03:28:40.840 --> 03:28:42.829
City of El Cerrito: 20… I think that's 2040…

1249
03:28:42.990 --> 03:28:50.979
City of El Cerrito: That was from a really good year, about 4 years ago, that's go… that's leaving our books, so to speak.

1250
03:28:50.980 --> 03:29:07.569
City of El Cerrito: If you want to talk in more detail about that, I'm always available, but, for now, this is the current graph, and you can see that the normal cost, which is what the city pays for current employees, stays quite steady and then increases just ever so slightly in the out years, but our UAL comes dramatically down after about 6 years.

1251
03:29:07.590 --> 03:29:27.980
City of El Cerrito: The city does have a Section 115 trust, which the Council has established and funded. It currently has about $3 million, which, you read about, at… for this meeting, and Director Rehm spoke about earlier. And then again, staff evaluate prepaying our UAL, and for those, it's on the slide, but the UAL is the unfunded actuarial liability.

1252
03:29:27.980 --> 03:29:37.419
City of El Cerrito: So that's a huge piece of our pension cost. So we evaluate prepaying that in a lump sum at the beginning of each fiscal year for about a 3.3% savings rate.

1253
03:29:37.450 --> 03:29:46.120
City of El Cerrito: Which is a really good rate. We would potentially see some of that if we kept the money in the bank, but typically prepaying is the safest and best deal.

1254
03:29:48.790 --> 03:29:49.930
City of El Cerrito: Insurance.

1255
03:29:49.930 --> 03:30:10.910
City of El Cerrito: insurance markets are bananas, and our incredible assistant city manager sits on the board of MPA, and I know we've talked a lot with you about insurance. Our insurance costs are skyrocketing, and they continue to skyrocket. We are currently expecting an increase of 12% in our insurance costs, which is about half a million dollars. In the past,

1256
03:30:11.190 --> 03:30:27.530
City of El Cerrito: 8 years, 9 years, you can see that our insurance costs have gone from just over half a million dollars in the insurance premiums, not including workers' compensation, they've gone from just over half a million dollars to $3 million from 2021 to 2028.

1257
03:30:27.820 --> 03:30:36.240
City of El Cerrito: our revenues have not grown that fast, and so it is just a massive, massive cost that cities are having to deal with these days. Insurance markets are…

1258
03:30:36.540 --> 03:30:41.250
City of El Cerrito: really, really difficult. And so, we are doing our best to estimate for this.

1259
03:30:41.560 --> 03:30:59.710
City of El Cerrito: it's just an enormous cost. And excuse me, I said… I said 12%. It's actually 19% in fiscal 27, and it's 12%. We hope that things will stabilize in 2028. We think it's reasonable. I've got… I had a discussion with staff from MPA, they're risk analysts, that 12% is a realistic

1260
03:30:59.890 --> 03:31:05.439
City of El Cerrito: possibility, but it is really difficult for us to forecast this.

1261
03:31:05.440 --> 03:31:28.829
City of El Cerrito: workers' compensation is more moderated, but it is still a very large expense. The change in allocation methodology, that's a staff change at El Cerrito, that's not an MPA insurance change. That is that we have shifted slightly how we allocate workers' compensation. We previously did it where we allocated the same exact amount per FTE. Now we're working with MPA to weight it based on the prorated safety

1262
03:31:28.830 --> 03:31:44.980
City of El Cerrito: So we're weighting safety higher, because typically the workers' compensation costs and insurance are higher, because it's… they're much more physical jobs, so they often have higher burdens in that respect. And so we're weighting those costs slightly differently to… with safety versus miscellaneous, and then allocated on an employee basis.

1263
03:31:45.600 --> 03:31:53.630
City of El Cerrito: I just want to clarify that allocation on an employee basis has no relationship to the individual's actual worker compensation. That's entirely separate.

1264
03:31:53.840 --> 03:31:58.049
City of El Cerrito: So that's, again, that's internal city budgeting, but not related to MPA costs.

1265
03:31:59.180 --> 03:32:10.939
City of El Cerrito: Other major expenditures, I mentioned international conflict. I'm sure many of you who have cars that take gas have seen this lately, that gas prices are also upside down. Staff currently estimate that if

1266
03:32:10.940 --> 03:32:22.450
City of El Cerrito: the current conflict were to continue for all of the next fiscal year, it would be at least $85,000 additional cost for fuel for the city. We are currently budgeting for a portion of that, but with a hope

1267
03:32:22.530 --> 03:32:31.390
City of El Cerrito: That maybe peace will be achieved, and maybe a ceasefire will hold, for many more reasons other than just our fuel costs.

1268
03:32:31.750 --> 03:32:40.579
City of El Cerrito: The city also does piggyback on state contracts for fuel costs, so some of those are up for renegotiation around January 1st, so there's some potential impacts as well.

1269
03:32:40.770 --> 03:32:43.319
City of El Cerrito: On the professional services side.

1270
03:32:43.320 --> 03:33:02.030
City of El Cerrito: Chief Keith spoke about animal services briefly earlier. We also have our dispatch services. We have dispatch services provided through a contract with the City of Richmond. That contract ends at the end of fiscal 27, and so it will be renegotiated, and so we've budgeted for some of those cost increases, but there's some uncertainty with that contract as well.

1271
03:33:02.330 --> 03:33:15.219
City of El Cerrito: On the utility cost side, we budgeted similarly with our utility revenues, so the nice thing about having utility tax consultants is they provide really excellent analysis of utility markets, and so we can also use that on our cost estimate side.

1272
03:33:15.220 --> 03:33:28.190
City of El Cerrito: We do have slightly lower natural gas costs than others because of the amount of our energy bills that are for street lights. So, we have a lot more electrical-specific and a little bit less gas than, for example, a typical home might have.

1273
03:33:28.930 --> 03:33:48.069
City of El Cerrito: Finally, we have revised some of the ways that we do overhead allocations, primarily because we now have the cost allocation and master fee study that's been updated. So the new cost allocation plan has allowed us to review the way that our cost allocations have been done with our special revenue funds and our enterprise fund.

1274
03:33:48.070 --> 03:33:52.429
City of El Cerrito: So it increases the accuracy of overhead costs, some of which haven't been updated in quite some time.

1275
03:33:54.890 --> 03:34:18.920
City of El Cerrito: Do we want to pause and ask questions about that section before we go on to CIP? Should we just keep going? I know we have another item this evening, too, so I know it's a long meeting. Let's keep going. Alright, so a little bit about the CIP. So, about the process. So, to begin the process, departments and public works identify needs and they submit projects. And then all of those projects are reviewed by Public Works staff. So, for example, the police department might say.

1276
03:34:18.920 --> 03:34:33.469
City of El Cerrito: we need this infrastructure improvement on the Public Safety Building. Public Works reviews all of the different projects that are submitted, and they, identify… they prioritize them, and they prioritize based on a variety of things, including urgency and functionality, health and safety.

1277
03:34:33.470 --> 03:34:54.429
City of El Cerrito: alignment with Council priorities, and then funding availability and time constraints. So sometimes projects are higher because there may be grant funding and other projects that might be high priority, but we have no funding source, might have to wait. Then Finance and Public Works work together to analyze funding and staff availability for the projects to make sure that the CIP, plan is realistic.

1278
03:34:54.440 --> 03:34:59.529
City of El Cerrito: And then finally, the CIP is recommended and to the Council for review and approval.

1279
03:34:59.790 --> 03:35:24.789
City of El Cerrito: One thing that is new this time, I mentioned a new budgeting software. We've been using ClearGov for a few years for the city's budget book to provide a nicer, kind of more online and transparent system. We are now also using their capital budgeting module to have a more streamlined process, but to also provide more detail and more information. So we have project sheets for each project, where you can see a little map of where it is, and you can see all the details and all the information, and then a bunch of different visuals

1280
03:35:24.960 --> 03:35:29.430
City of El Cerrito: That'll provide different ways to see, what's happening in the city's capital program.

1281
03:35:30.040 --> 03:35:54.169
City of El Cerrito: Is there some of the funding sources that are supporting our capital projects? The Capital Improvement Fund. Now, these are mostly funds that were previously allocated by the City Council as where you would have them budgeted in the Capital Improvement Fund, because the Capital Improvement Fund doesn't have its own funding sources inherently. So, for example, you have the Del Norte Complete Streets project. If that has been, you know, let's say the Council allocated $8 million for the project, but not all of it was expended in the

1282
03:35:54.170 --> 03:36:07.349
City of El Cerrito: first year, then you would budget out of the capital improvement fund in the second year. So it was originally maybe general fund or grant, it was put into the capital improvement fund. Now those funds are housed there as the project is being worked on, and so that's why you budget it out of that fund.

1283
03:36:07.460 --> 03:36:09.000
City of El Cerrito: Yeah.

1284
03:36:09.220 --> 03:36:23.479
City of El Cerrito: So, then we also have local grants, we have state grants. Some of the big ones are ASIC, I'm gonna say all these acronyms incorrectly, but we have a lot of transit, especially transit-oriented grants right now. We have some federal earmarks that we, I think, are

1285
03:36:23.480 --> 03:36:32.320
City of El Cerrito: hoping will, potentially come, and I believe we've received some in the past. And we also have Measure A Street Improvement Funds, Measure J storm drain funds.

1286
03:36:32.320 --> 03:36:47.319
City of El Cerrito: SB1, which is a form of gas tax fund, we have general fund contributions. IWM has one small capital project this budget cycle currently in the proposal, and then occasionally we have donations that support capital projects.

1287
03:36:47.560 --> 03:36:49.419
City of El Cerrito: This is an overview of…

1288
03:36:49.420 --> 03:37:13.099
City of El Cerrito: the CIP funds in each year. As you can see, state grants are really big in the first year, and in the second year, Measure A, street improvement is the largest source. The reason we don't have any more of the CIP fund, the capital improvement fund, in the first year is because presumably those projects are then being budgeted out of those other funds. So when we do the formal adoption of the second year of the budget for fiscal 27-28,

1289
03:37:13.100 --> 03:37:20.020
City of El Cerrito: We might expect to see some projects that are being budgeted in the Capital Improvement Fund, because they're very large, longer-term projects that are still in progress.

1290
03:37:20.810 --> 03:37:34.999
City of El Cerrito: On the preliminary CIP, this is just another way to look at it. You can see, the different funds that these are a part of. I think sometimes it's a little easier to see in this format. So again, state grants, capital improvement in the first year, and then measure A street improvement, and still some state grants in the second year.

1291
03:37:35.000 --> 03:37:43.019
City of El Cerrito: Now, this could all change, especially if we receive more grants, if there are other projects that end up getting a different prioritization, but this is the current preliminary CIP.

1292
03:37:43.380 --> 03:37:54.399
City of El Cerrito: The project list, we have a large number of projects. I won't read all of them, but I'll just give us a moment to look at this. And I believe we have Director Ortiz

1293
03:37:54.820 --> 03:38:14.820
City of El Cerrito: No? No, she's not, just kidding, she's not here. But we have a detailed list of all of the projects, and I encourage anyone, this is included in the Council materials, if you want to look through the list of projects, we will also have a much more robust and detailed budget document for the CIP once that is ultimately presented and published.

1294
03:38:15.950 --> 03:38:18.940
City of El Cerrito: So that's all I have for you today. Do you have any questions?

1295
03:38:19.130 --> 03:38:20.010
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

1296
03:38:20.380 --> 03:38:24.639
City of El Cerrito: Let's… we'll start over… over with, Councilmember Cassavis. Thank you.

1297
03:38:24.940 --> 03:38:40.580
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much, Claire. I have just one question. I… you mentioned early on the real estate property transfer tax, and I'm just wondering if there are any projections being made, and given the possibility that the tax gets outlawed statewide.

1298
03:38:41.730 --> 03:38:47.790
City of El Cerrito: We are tracking that very closely. If that happens…

1299
03:38:48.480 --> 03:38:55.889
City of El Cerrito: it would be 8-9% of our general fund. And so, if the real property transfer tax does go away.

1300
03:38:55.990 --> 03:39:05.390
City of El Cerrito: We would come back to the City Council and do a very different budget process mid-year. We really, really hope that doesn't happen. It would be very, very…

1301
03:39:05.580 --> 03:39:23.360
City of El Cerrito: difficult for us to provide the high level of service that we want to for the community. Okay, I just want… I ask just to make sure it's on your radar. It sounds like it is. Yeah, we have a lot of convers… I… I try not to, think about it too much, because it keeps me up at night, and, you know, try not to doomsday too much, but yeah, it would be really bad. Okay, thank you.

1302
03:39:24.330 --> 03:39:26.039
City of El Cerrito: We'll go to Mayor Pro Tem.

1303
03:39:26.850 --> 03:39:40.549
City of El Cerrito: just wanted to say something on that, which is, of course, this was a big thing we talked to our legislators about when we were in Sacramento, what was that, a month, two ago, whenever that was. And it… I think that it sounds like…

1304
03:39:40.750 --> 03:39:46.299
City of El Cerrito: things might not be so bad, and hopefully… they definitely hurt us, and…

1305
03:39:46.390 --> 03:40:06.170
City of El Cerrito: hopefully we're not gonna get caught up in it. So I felt a lot better after those meetings than I felt going in. So yeah, the city's very much on top of it. And I… although I have lots of questions about the budget, I'm gonna hold them, because we're gonna have future presentations, and I don't want us to get to the 11 p.m. cutoff.

1306
03:40:06.930 --> 03:40:08.360
City of El Cerrito: Yes, Councilmember.

1307
03:40:08.470 --> 03:40:11.919
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor, and thank you for your really

1308
03:40:11.980 --> 03:40:26.879
City of El Cerrito: concise presentation, and that's a lot of stuff to get through, and it was very clear. I have a question about the CIP, and, kind of going through this and hearing some of the public comment this evening.

1309
03:40:26.880 --> 03:40:32.510
City of El Cerrito: You know, there's, you know, there's a big component of oversight in labor by the city.

1310
03:40:32.690 --> 03:40:37.139
City of El Cerrito: for each project. Is that calculated in this new software program?

1311
03:40:37.720 --> 03:40:53.020
City of El Cerrito: Do you mean, like, city staff time spent on the project? Typically, we don't track staff time on individual projects unless there is a reason, potentially, grant reimbursement, that we would track actual hours. Otherwise, typically, we don't track staff time on a project basis. Okay, because I think…

1312
03:40:53.030 --> 03:40:58.709
City of El Cerrito: The… there's a, you know, common misunderstanding, but that, you know.

1313
03:40:59.950 --> 03:41:11.079
City of El Cerrito: things happen if it's, like, donated money and donated activity, that there's no relationship to staff time, but I think that's the… that's kind of where the…

1314
03:41:11.290 --> 03:41:20.429
City of El Cerrito: Our pinch point is, is that we… some things we have money for, but we don't have staff for, and it's like, how do we measure that, and how do we…

1315
03:41:20.570 --> 03:41:31.070
City of El Cerrito: express that in our… in our budget. And one of the core ways is through the prioritize… the project prioritization process, which is that, Director Ortiz and her team

1316
03:41:31.790 --> 03:41:33.800
City of El Cerrito: create a CIP that is…

1317
03:41:34.370 --> 03:41:51.229
City of El Cerrito: to the best of their abilities, realistic to their staff's availability to make those things happen. And so what happens if other projects come in or other grants come in, those things that had been prioritized based on their staff and workload may have to get shifted down. So if there's… even if it's just a small thing.

1318
03:41:51.280 --> 03:42:08.620
City of El Cerrito: there is a plan, and we never have enough people to get everything done, and so there's always going to be more work than we have people for, and so even small things that come in, it necessarily shifts the rest of the project on the list. So the goal is to get a comprehensive CIP and capital program, knowing that things happen.

1319
03:42:08.630 --> 03:42:13.209
City of El Cerrito: But that allows staff to plan their workload and plan their time,

1320
03:42:13.880 --> 03:42:31.690
City of El Cerrito: because of that exact dynamic that we… we simply can't do anything. Like, these giant… can't do everything, excuse me, these giant grants, you know, big transportation grants are so fantastic, but they do take a lot of staff time to administer, so even… nothing is free. There's no free money. Everything has some level of cost and balancing act for staff.

1321
03:42:32.360 --> 03:42:46.079
City of El Cerrito: Thank you very much. Yeah, I just want to say thank you for the presentation. Looking at what we're dealing with, and I have talked to mayors up and down the state, you know, compared to,

1322
03:42:46.080 --> 03:42:56.779
City of El Cerrito: a lot of the cities near us, we're doing quite fine. We don't have these million-dollar deficits that… multi-million dollar deficits that our closer cities here have.

1323
03:42:56.780 --> 03:43:07.680
City of El Cerrito: And we have cities close to bankruptcy that are having difficulties, and they will be making their government smaller. We're not even at that level yet, so we have…

1324
03:43:07.680 --> 03:43:09.689
City of El Cerrito: Had a head start on,

1325
03:43:09.690 --> 03:43:22.830
City of El Cerrito: getting our house together and in order, so, just know how much we appreciate your leadership and, and just, more transparency and just letting us know what we need to do. So…

1326
03:43:22.830 --> 03:43:39.249
City of El Cerrito: A couple of things that, that, I know our city manager is working on. We're one of 27 cities that do have the real estate transfer tax. We are concerned because there are groups that want to get rid of that, and, so know that,

1327
03:43:39.250 --> 03:43:42.859
City of El Cerrito: We're working regionally and statewide to make sure

1328
03:43:42.900 --> 03:44:00.650
City of El Cerrito: the other cities and leaders support us, and especially there in Sacramento. Let's go to open comment right now. Now's the time for members of the public to wish to provide public comments on this item. Requests to speak can be submitted to the City Clerk by completing a speaker card.

1329
03:44:00.770 --> 03:44:08.359
City of El Cerrito: In person, we've possibly taken first. Please remember to identify yourself and your city of residence at the beginning of your comments. City Clerk.

1330
03:44:09.340 --> 03:44:10.810
City of El Cerrito: Do we have any comments?

1331
03:44:12.280 --> 03:44:26.969
City of El Cerrito: Sorry, we do have a couple requests to speak, I just… we're still trying to figure out the logistics of screen sharing and seeing visually in the room, and I can't get the speaker timer to display in the room, so,

1332
03:44:26.980 --> 03:44:36.809
City of El Cerrito: We just have two requests to speak, so I will do the timer here, and I will just call out when the time has extended, or has expired. 3 minutes, okay.

1333
03:44:38.130 --> 03:44:43.270
City of El Cerrito: So, our in-person request to speak is Janet Byron. You want to go ahead and come on up?

1334
03:44:45.890 --> 03:44:47.110
City of El Cerrito: It is 3 minutes.

1335
03:44:48.700 --> 03:44:52.090
City of El Cerrito: I'm… I'm Janet Byron, I'm an El Cerrito resident.

1336
03:44:52.380 --> 03:44:58.020
City of El Cerrito: I'm speaking today on behalf of Brian Richmond, co-president of the El Cerrito Trail Trackers.

1337
03:44:58.230 --> 03:45:04.339
City of El Cerrito: And myself, Avis Kadrone, and David Giorke, members of the Trail Trekkers Public Paths Committee.

1338
03:45:04.640 --> 03:45:09.770
City of El Cerrito: Earlier today, we provided a detailed letter, which should have been included in your packet.

1339
03:45:10.460 --> 03:45:21.100
City of El Cerrito: El Cerrito's 60 developed paths are treasured community connectors linking neighborhood parks, schools, and transit, and they are also important for evacuation purposes.

1340
03:45:21.360 --> 03:45:29.360
City of El Cerrito: Currently, none of the 60 paths in El Cerrito have signs, and many of these paths are in need of handrails or other repairs.

1341
03:45:29.630 --> 03:45:34.780
City of El Cerrito: TrailTrekkers has identified 12 undeveloped paths on public rights-of-way.

1342
03:45:34.980 --> 03:45:41.750
City of El Cerrito: Which we have offered to develop into passable paths at our own expense and with volunteer labor.

1343
03:45:42.070 --> 03:45:47.339
City of El Cerrito: The City Manager and Public Works Director have shared with us that staff time

1344
03:45:47.460 --> 03:45:55.769
City of El Cerrito: can only be allocated to public paths if they are included as a priority in the capital improvement program budget.

1345
03:45:56.400 --> 03:46:04.380
City of El Cerrito: the budget process, Provides the opportunity to make path improvements a high-priority, low-cost investment.

1346
03:46:04.540 --> 03:46:11.229
City of El Cerrito: One that strengthens community safety and access without competing with major capital projects.

1347
03:46:12.040 --> 03:46:19.309
City of El Cerrito: First, we request a one-time allocation of $38,000 for public path signage.

1348
03:46:19.500 --> 03:46:23.790
City of El Cerrito: This number was estimated by Planning Manager Sean Moss.

1349
03:46:23.950 --> 03:46:30.830
City of El Cerrito: Public Works Director, Yvette Ortiz, and Sustainable Transportation Program Manager Jarrett Mullen.

1350
03:46:30.990 --> 03:46:35.949
City of El Cerrito: Of that, about $25,000 would be for labor and materials.

1351
03:46:36.120 --> 03:46:38.929
City of El Cerrito: With the remainder for planning and design work.

1352
03:46:39.840 --> 03:46:48.329
City of El Cerrito: We also request that the CIP budget include a line item for public path rights-of-way at $50,000 per year.

1353
03:46:48.560 --> 03:46:53.079
City of El Cerrito: To be allocated for staff time, labor, and materials.

1354
03:46:53.260 --> 03:47:02.929
City of El Cerrito: We recommend that the staff time be allocated for the Public Works Director to coordinate with El Cerrito Trail Trekkers on building undeveloped paths

1355
03:47:03.110 --> 03:47:09.230
City of El Cerrito: And assessing current needs for handrails, concrete repair, treads, and other improvements.

1356
03:47:09.630 --> 03:47:20.080
City of El Cerrito: Finally, we request that the CIP budget include a line item of $25,000 per year for the management of the hillside natural area.

1357
03:47:20.230 --> 03:47:26.490
City of El Cerrito: To include staff time, labor, and materials, which would include trail design and repair.

1358
03:47:26.760 --> 03:47:30.590
City of El Cerrito: Non-native species removal and other management needs.

1359
03:47:30.930 --> 03:47:31.950
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

1360
03:47:33.460 --> 03:47:41.349
City of El Cerrito: Okay, and then we have one request… virtual request to speak. Ira, you should be able to unmute and begin your time now.

1361
03:47:45.770 --> 03:47:47.969
ira: Irish Arenel, El Cerrito.

1362
03:47:48.250 --> 03:47:54.200
ira: When it comes to budget issues and tax measures, I am concerned about the lack of transparency.

1363
03:47:54.640 --> 03:48:04.859
ira: I want to use Measure A, the 2008 pothole repair sales tax, as a concrete example of what inadequate oversight looks like over time.

1364
03:48:05.180 --> 03:48:10.769
ira: The Citizen Oversight Committee meets approximately twice a year for about an hour each time.

1365
03:48:11.060 --> 03:48:16.660
ira: The ordinance, Chapter 4.60.150 parens A,

1366
03:48:16.770 --> 03:48:31.199
ira: states clearly that no revenues may be spent on department administrator salaries. At the committee's first meeting in January 2009, staff confirmed that interpretation, and the committee voted 5-0 to affirm it.

1367
03:48:31.610 --> 03:48:38.779
ira: By November 2011, staff was telling the committee that the Public Works Director could be billed to the fund.

1368
03:48:39.110 --> 03:48:49.570
ira: By fiscal year 2018-19, over $91,000 in non-capital personnel costs were being charged annually to a fund restricted to street repair.

1369
03:48:50.430 --> 03:49:05.260
ira: At its September 2020 meeting, the committee voted to change its own standing rule from requiring members, quote, shall, unquote, review source documents and vendor invoices to, quote, may, unquote, review them.

1370
03:49:05.420 --> 03:49:07.859
ira: They formally weakened their own oversight.

1371
03:49:08.380 --> 03:49:18.480
ira: Meanwhile, El Cerrito's Pavement Conditioning Index dropped PCI, dropped from 85 in 2016 to 65 today.

1372
03:49:18.800 --> 03:49:23.980
ira: While the fund collected roughly $26 million in dedicated sales tax.

1373
03:49:24.290 --> 03:49:30.509
ira: No one on the Council or the Oversight Committee has offered a public explanation for that decline.

1374
03:49:30.680 --> 03:49:32.759
ira: I think residents deserve one.

1375
03:49:33.120 --> 03:49:35.220
ira: We need more transparency.

1376
03:49:35.620 --> 03:49:41.720
ira: We also need more transparency on the Richmond Street bike lanes. How are they being paid for?

1377
03:49:41.830 --> 03:49:50.500
ira: Given what was really, asked for on the, from the, from the,

1378
03:49:51.870 --> 03:49:59.660
ira: Growth Council, A, Parcel A, grant. Thank you very much.

1379
03:50:01.630 --> 03:50:03.919
City of El Cerrito: Mayor, that concludes our request to speak for this item.

1380
03:50:10.770 --> 03:50:19.510
City of El Cerrito: to… It's just a… okay, there's not… we don't have… Definitely.

1381
03:50:22.350 --> 03:50:37.909
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we don't have to do a motion on that, so we'll go to the next one. Thank you very much. Appreciate that. Next, we're going to go to transition from at-large to district-based elections for City Council, beginning with the November 28

1382
03:50:38.220 --> 03:50:40.760
City of El Cerrito: 2028 general municipal Election.

1383
03:50:55.050 --> 03:50:56.519
City of El Cerrito: No, I didn't.

1384
03:50:56.850 --> 03:50:57.979
City of El Cerrito: I'm sleeping a plane.

1385
03:50:58.910 --> 03:51:00.070
City of El Cerrito: You can hide.

1386
03:51:00.380 --> 03:51:02.580
City of El Cerrito: Okay, Skype.

1387
03:51:09.180 --> 03:51:23.260
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Good evening to you and the City Council. I'm Sky Woodruff, your City Attorney. First, I'm going to try to find the correct distance from the microphone to reduce the feedback. We'll see how that goes.

1388
03:51:23.580 --> 03:51:36.609
City of El Cerrito: I also wanted to, before launching into the presentation as outlined in the slides, I thought I might begin with a few initial comments about this item.

1389
03:51:37.160 --> 03:51:59.160
City of El Cerrito: So, I think for any… for the Council and for any members of the public who've already read the written report, it's seen the City Manager's update, read the attached letter to the report, you'll understand that the item before Council right now is consideration of adoption of a resolution of intention that would initiate the process of converting the City Council's elections from

1390
03:51:59.160 --> 03:52:02.950
City of El Cerrito: Current elections, which are called at-large, to…

1391
03:52:02.950 --> 03:52:17.279
City of El Cerrito: Elections by district, where the city would be divided into city council districts, and council members would be elected, by each of those districts, and would be required to be residents within those districts.

1392
03:52:17.460 --> 03:52:32.169
City of El Cerrito: This is not a process that's being proposed by staff, as a staff-driven process, it's not something that the Council has prioritized and asked to be brought forward. This is directly the result of a threat of litigation under the California Voting Rights Act.

1393
03:52:32.500 --> 03:52:42.060
City of El Cerrito: Many cities, across California have attempted to fight these similar demand letters. So far, none of them have won.

1394
03:52:42.220 --> 03:52:57.310
City of El Cerrito: None have won. There is still pending litigation, which might produce a different result, but so far, cities are batting zero. And they have all paid significant attorney's fees to the plaintiff's attorney at the conclusion of that litigation.

1395
03:52:57.360 --> 03:53:02.240
City of El Cerrito: And that's because the CVRA, I will use that acronym throughout the presentation.

1396
03:53:02.590 --> 03:53:10.650
City of El Cerrito: Provides for attorney's fees for a plaintiff that sends a demand to transition to district elections and, ultimately prevails on the issue.

1397
03:53:11.090 --> 03:53:24.050
City of El Cerrito: Since about 2016, the legislature has capped those fees, and I will talk some more about that, but only if a city that receives a demand letter stays within the Safe Harbor timelines that I will also be discussing.

1398
03:53:25.670 --> 03:53:37.010
City of El Cerrito: Roughly 6% of California cities, use district-based elections prior to the adoption of the CVRA. As of 2025, that's increased to more than 44%.

1399
03:53:37.180 --> 03:53:53.899
City of El Cerrito: And that's a direct result, I think many believe, of the state's guarantee that just by sending a letter, sometimes with a statistical analysis attached, sometimes not, will entitle an attorney to what is currently about $38,000 to $40,000.

1400
03:53:53.900 --> 03:53:58.359
City of El Cerrito: And more, much more, if the city chooses to fight that transition.

1401
03:53:58.570 --> 03:54:15.970
City of El Cerrito: Unfortunately, the Safe Harbor timeline is extremely condensed. We had 45 days from the receipt of the letter to bring this resolution to you for consideration, and after… if Council adopts it tonight, you'll have 90 days to complete the process of

1402
03:54:15.970 --> 03:54:26.439
City of El Cerrito: Adopting an ordinance to… of approving an ordinance to, to, adopt a district map and set a schedule for transitioning.

1403
03:54:26.570 --> 03:54:39.779
City of El Cerrito: My office attempted to negotiate, extensions that are allowed by statute so that there would be a more thoughtful process that could engage the community on this topic and attempt to ensure that people had a

1404
03:54:39.970 --> 03:54:44.060
City of El Cerrito: thorough understanding, and Council had a reasonable amount of time to consider it.

1405
03:54:44.190 --> 03:54:58.769
City of El Cerrito: The anonymous El Cerrito resident, who is the potential plaintiff in this case, refused to grant any extensions. And so as a risk mitigation measure to the city to limit attorney's fees to the extent possible, we're bringing this resolution forward to you tonight.

1406
03:54:59.180 --> 03:55:08.419
City of El Cerrito: So, with those initial comments out of the way, I will launch into this presentation so that Council and the public understands the context for what's being proposed.

1407
03:55:08.800 --> 03:55:27.549
City of El Cerrito: The overview will expand… here's an overview of what we'll be talking about. I'll expand some on the background, provide an overview of the relevant law, talk about, what this phrase, racially polarized Voting. I will use another acronym, which is RPV, which is racially polarized Voting.

1408
03:55:27.670 --> 03:55:33.640
City of El Cerrito: Talk some about district-based elections, and then talk some more about the timeline and the action that's being proposed.

1409
03:55:34.270 --> 03:55:38.790
City of El Cerrito: As I mentioned, the city currently uses an at-large election system.

1410
03:55:38.890 --> 03:55:57.719
City of El Cerrito: Whereby every… every two years there's a council election, some years there are two seats up for elections, sometimes there are three. Members of the public get to vote for each of those seats, and, if there are three people running.

1411
03:55:57.730 --> 03:56:06.990
City of El Cerrito: For two seats, you get to vote twice, and, the person who gets the most votes wins for each of those seats. So,

1412
03:56:07.090 --> 03:56:15.410
City of El Cerrito: It's more complicated than that, but I think everybody kind of understands how council elections currently run. We received this demand letter on March 17th.

1413
03:56:15.630 --> 03:56:31.359
City of El Cerrito: And it included a claim, with a statistical analysis attached that included some identifiable flaws, which I will come back to, but the letter claimed that the city's at-large election system

1414
03:56:31.360 --> 03:56:39.849
City of El Cerrito: is racially polarized and therefore violates the CVRA. It demanded that the city transition to district-based elections because of that.

1415
03:56:41.400 --> 03:57:04.979
City of El Cerrito: So the California Voting Rights Act, prohibits an at-large election system that impairs the ability of a protected class to elect candidates of its choice or its ability to influence the outcome of an election. And forgive me for reading this, but I want to just get the wording correct. A violation is established if racially polarized voting and dilution occurs in elections

1416
03:57:04.980 --> 03:57:18.519
City of El Cerrito: or other matters submitted to the voters. What does that mean? If a statistical analysis, that uses indirect measures of racial voting determines that a,

1417
03:57:18.520 --> 03:57:31.579
City of El Cerrito: And a block of voters identified by race consistently votes together, and that they are either unable to elect their candidate of choice, or to influence the outcome of the election in favor of their

1418
03:57:31.580 --> 03:57:38.560
City of El Cerrito: of their candidate of choice. That analysis, constitutes racially polarized voting, and

1419
03:57:38.560 --> 03:57:54.830
City of El Cerrito: And is the basis for a claim of a violation of the CVRA. As I mentioned, cities all over the state have received similar letters, challenging their election systems. There has been litigation, and none of them have won.

1420
03:57:54.850 --> 03:58:11.689
City of El Cerrito: part of the reason that they have not won, to emphasize this point again, is that the statistical threshold for the establishment of, RPV, is highly tilted in favor of plaintiffs. And where there is,

1421
03:58:11.690 --> 03:58:18.519
City of El Cerrito: conflicting statistical data. The case law essentially directs the, court

1422
03:58:18.520 --> 03:58:38.140
City of El Cerrito: to, favor the statistical analysis that concludes that there is RPV. So, to put that differently, if a plaintiff shows up with an expert statistician and demographer who says there is RPV, and a city shows up in court with an expert with the same credentials who ran their own analysis and says there isn't.

1423
03:58:38.300 --> 03:58:55.199
City of El Cerrito: And there is not conclusive, evidence one way or the other. Case law, pushes the court in the direction of ruling that there is RPV, and that's a violation of the CVRA, and the city has to make a change to its election system.

1424
03:58:57.330 --> 03:59:13.979
City of El Cerrito: As I mentioned, the way that the CVRA has structured this process provides what's referred to as a safe harbor process, which requires the city that receives a letter to,

1425
03:59:13.980 --> 03:59:27.250
City of El Cerrito: adopt a resolution of its intent to transition to districts within 45 days of receiving the letter, and after the adoption of that resolution, to establish a district-based election system within 90 days.

1426
03:59:27.260 --> 03:59:31.610
City of El Cerrito: If a city follows that Safe Harbor timeline,

1427
03:59:31.870 --> 03:59:41.570
City of El Cerrito: which I, as I mentioned, can be extended with the agreement of the potential plaintiff and their attorney. But if the city ultimately sticks with it.

1428
03:59:41.850 --> 03:59:47.670
City of El Cerrito: The statute caps attorneys' fees, at what is now between $38,000 and $40,000.

1429
03:59:52.230 --> 04:00:05.530
City of El Cerrito: I think that leads to some fair questions about, you know, what is an RPV analysis? So, and what did the city do in response to having received this letter? My office, retained,

1430
04:00:05.530 --> 04:00:20.620
City of El Cerrito: a nationally recognized statistician demographer to do an independent review of elections in El Cerrito, both city council and other votes, to provide an independent analysis of whether or not there is racially polarized voting.

1431
04:00:21.170 --> 04:00:32.199
City of El Cerrito: They reviewed the local and statewide elections, analyzed voting patterns, used several different statistical methods, but ultimately concluded

1432
04:00:32.200 --> 04:00:49.450
City of El Cerrito: that there is a statistical possibility of RPV related to Latino voters in local elections and statewide general elections. So this is a statistician demographer that my office retained on behalf of the city, did an independent analysis, and reached a similar conclusion

1433
04:00:49.720 --> 04:01:03.420
City of El Cerrito: Not exactly the same, interestingly, and this is, this goes to the flaws that are in the statistical analysis that was attached to the letter, that, for example, mischaracterized one of the… the outcome of one of the City Council's elections.

1434
04:01:03.430 --> 04:01:10.109
City of El Cerrito: But the city's own statistician verified the statistical possibility of RPV related to Latino voters.

1435
04:01:11.960 --> 04:01:24.829
City of El Cerrito: With that in hand, and there is a summary of that analysis, attached to the staff report, the choices between… for the City Council are… are fairly narrow.

1436
04:01:26.220 --> 04:01:38.689
City of El Cerrito: One is to move forward with district elections. And, as I mentioned at the beginning, what district elections look like is that the city would be divided into several city council districts.

1437
04:01:38.690 --> 04:01:55.949
City of El Cerrito: Council candidates would have to reside within the district to be elected, and voters within the district would vote only for the city council candidates within their own district. There is a slight var… so one… there are a couple of variations. One is to have,

1438
04:01:55.950 --> 04:02:04.420
City of El Cerrito: five council districts. Another is to have four council districts with a directly elected mayor who is elected at large.

1439
04:02:05.020 --> 04:02:11.020
City of El Cerrito: These are… these are questions that… that Council will have to address as it goes through this process.

1440
04:02:11.720 --> 04:02:22.430
City of El Cerrito: The timeline for district-based elections to stay within the safe harbor, is to, is to

1441
04:02:24.090 --> 04:02:30.089
City of El Cerrito: Sorry, that's actually on the next slide. Just to address the information that's on this slide.

1442
04:02:30.090 --> 04:02:42.910
City of El Cerrito: We did look, because this was actually the initial demand, at whether or not it would be possible to transition to district elections in 2026, so this upcoming city council elections.

1443
04:02:42.910 --> 04:02:52.090
City of El Cerrito: Pursuant to the elections code, and we confirmed this with the county, maps would have to be provided by July 1 of this year. We concluded that was not possible.

1444
04:02:52.090 --> 04:03:07.709
City of El Cerrito: And so the resolution that the, that is before the Council would initiate a process to begin the transition with the 2028 Council election and conclude with the 2030 Council elections to maintain staggered elections.

1445
04:03:08.560 --> 04:03:21.179
City of El Cerrito: Here's the timeline that I wanted to discuss to stay within the safe harbor provisions. Between, April 22nd and July 21st, the City Council will have to conduct at least 5 public hearings.

1446
04:03:21.480 --> 04:03:44.269
City of El Cerrito: approve an ordinance that includes a district map and a schedule for the transition to district elections. There will be, as I mentioned, there will be at least 5 public hearings. City Council can schedule more, but the time frame is compressed. But we have built out an initial timeline that leaves, sometime in April, late June for additional meetings, and the ultimate

1447
04:03:44.270 --> 04:03:50.659
City of El Cerrito: process again… conclusion again would be to transition it for the November 2028 and November 2030 elections.

1448
04:03:52.300 --> 04:04:08.020
City of El Cerrito: Before moving on to, the items for consideration, because I know that there have been questions from Council, there has also been some public comment about this, including in the packet, which is, are there any alternatives to transitioning to district-based elections?

1449
04:04:08.470 --> 04:04:14.239
City of El Cerrito: So, there is some case law that, suggests that, that

1450
04:04:14.630 --> 04:04:23.869
City of El Cerrito: It… in instances in which there is racially polarized voting, district elections may not be… actually be a solution, and may not be the only solution.

1451
04:04:23.870 --> 04:04:41.089
City of El Cerrito: There are other voting systems that have been devised and used in other circumstances. I think many people will be at least passingly familiar with ranked choice voting. There are a number of jurisdictions in Alameda County that use ranked choice voting, including the City of Albany right next door.

1452
04:04:41.360 --> 04:04:51.089
City of El Cerrito: There are other… there are other systems, and the City of San Luis Obispo is in the process of, transitioning to, a limited voting system.

1453
04:04:51.090 --> 04:05:03.490
City of El Cerrito: that they have an agreement with the potential plaintiff, in their case to allow them to, to attempt this system to, as a means of addressing RPV.

1454
04:05:03.870 --> 04:05:21.819
City of El Cerrito: There are a couple of important considerations, both legal and, budgetary. The legal consideration is that, as of right now, the California Voting Rights Act provides a safe harbor only for the transition to, district elections. And so.

1455
04:05:21.820 --> 04:05:36.580
City of El Cerrito: Any of the cities that… any city that moves to an alternative voting system may have an agreement with a single plaintiff that they will not initiate litigation if the city moves to that alternative system, but that does not prevent another plaintiff

1456
04:05:36.580 --> 04:05:48.049
City of El Cerrito: from filing an independent action to say that ranked choice voting, for example, did not solve the problem, and that the city's election system is still resulting in RPV.

1457
04:05:48.110 --> 04:06:02.400
City of El Cerrito: So that is… whereas, if a city transitions to district-based elections, it is immunized from further, allegations under the California Voting Rights Act that the city's voting system is resulting in racially polarized voting.

1458
04:06:02.780 --> 04:06:11.509
City of El Cerrito: That's the legal issue… consideration. The budgetary consideration, is that no jurisdiction in Contra Costa County

1459
04:06:11.510 --> 04:06:27.120
City of El Cerrito: has yet transitioned to an alternative voting system, including ranked choice voting. We have conferred with the Contra Costa Elections Division, and they have told us that the first jurisdiction that chooses to transition to Ranked Choice Voting

1460
04:06:27.170 --> 04:06:33.799
City of El Cerrito: We'll have to pay $170,000, to pay for the cost of implementing that system.

1461
04:06:34.400 --> 04:06:40.410
City of El Cerrito: After that, they will have to pay $70,000 a year, as an annual license cost.

1462
04:06:40.480 --> 04:06:54.539
City of El Cerrito: and then each time that there's a general municipal election, that jurisdiction will have to pay $100,000 to $120,000 that's in addition to the standard cost of conducting an at-large election. So again.

1463
04:06:54.550 --> 04:06:57.150
City of El Cerrito: $170,000 one time.

1464
04:06:57.150 --> 04:07:22.019
City of El Cerrito: $70,000 annually, $100,000 to $120,000 each general election that is in addition to the two… the standard cost that the city pays. This is different from Alameda County. Because they have multiple jurisdictions, the cost of acquiring the necessary systems has already been paid for. The annual license cost is split among multiple

1465
04:07:22.020 --> 04:07:27.390
City of El Cerrito: jurisdictions. The additional costs are split among those jurisdictions,

1466
04:07:27.540 --> 04:07:47.780
City of El Cerrito: basically the first entity, public agency in Contra Costa County that chooses to move to Ranked Choice Voting is going to be responsible for these costs, and they will only begin to be allocated once additional jurisdictions move to RCV. So there's a significant financial cost to moving in addition to the legal risks.

1467
04:07:49.480 --> 04:08:06.200
City of El Cerrito: With all of that said, the recommendation before Council tonight, is to adopt the resolution of Intention to transition to districts beginning with the 2028 general election. The resolution authorizes my office to execute agreements with,

1468
04:08:06.200 --> 04:08:10.900
City of El Cerrito: a demographer, it will be the same one who did the RPV analysis.

1469
04:08:10.900 --> 04:08:26.559
City of El Cerrito: For consultant work and software services necessary to transition to districts. That includes providing the city with a mapping tool that will allow members of the public to themselves propose different district maps that can be considered as part of the public hearing process.

1470
04:08:26.560 --> 04:08:34.679
City of El Cerrito: The resolution would also amend the 25-26 budget to appropriate funds necessary for those expenses. And with that, I'm available for questions.

1471
04:08:36.400 --> 04:08:37.080
City of El Cerrito: care.

1472
04:08:37.190 --> 04:08:39.870
City of El Cerrito: I'll look to my right over here. Any questions?

1473
04:08:41.170 --> 04:08:41.980
City of El Cerrito: right over here.

1474
04:08:43.360 --> 04:08:47.500
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we have no questions. Any, public comment?

1475
04:08:47.680 --> 04:08:55.530
City of El Cerrito: Yes, Mary, we do have some requests for public comment on this item. I have… 5 requests to speak.

1476
04:08:56.080 --> 04:08:56.830
City of El Cerrito: Okay.

1477
04:09:19.880 --> 04:09:26.680
City of El Cerrito: Okay… I'll go to… our first request is Elise Mills.

1478
04:09:28.590 --> 04:09:29.910
City of El Cerrito: Louis still here?

1479
04:09:31.020 --> 04:09:33.730
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we'll go to our next request, Janet Byron.

1480
04:09:34.990 --> 04:09:36.840
City of El Cerrito: Okay? Bill Barrish?

1481
04:09:39.140 --> 04:09:40.400
City of El Cerrito: Michael McDougal?

1482
04:09:43.630 --> 04:09:48.519
City of El Cerrito: Hello, I'm Michael McDougall, I'm a resident of El Cerrito, I'm also on your financial advisory board.

1483
04:09:49.030 --> 04:09:59.129
City of El Cerrito: the… I don't love this, I don't think any of you love this, but I also think it's a relatively straightforward choice, and I recommend that you vote to adopt this.

1484
04:09:59.300 --> 04:10:18.219
City of El Cerrito: I've started thinking a little bit about, what it will take to run for City Council, not for myself, but for anyone. So there's some practical things that I think that you should direct the person who's starting to make our maps. We're on a very short timeline. But one thing that I think would make sense is to try not to split along streets. The natural

1485
04:10:18.370 --> 04:10:30.489
City of El Cerrito: inclination of people when they're drawing these maps is to divide things by streets, and that's a little bit odd when you're actually walking door-to-door to knock on people and ask them to vote. You know, we're gonna have maybe

1486
04:10:30.860 --> 04:10:48.020
City of El Cerrito: 5,000 people per district who are voters, and so I ask you to draw these maps through backyards and across streets, and there's some other considerations about staying away from future gerrymandering to just try to make the districts convex.

1487
04:10:48.060 --> 04:10:57.830
City of El Cerrito: So, those would be a couple of thoughts that I have in general as we're going into this. So, anyway, I'm sorry that we're faced with this hard decision, but I think it's a straightforward one.

1488
04:10:58.240 --> 04:11:01.339
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. Thank you. Our next request is Jeffrey Wright.

1489
04:11:06.440 --> 04:11:16.089
City of El Cerrito: Jeffrey, sorry you had to wait till, 10-15, but, it is what it is. So, good evening to you, Mayor Quinto, and members of the City Council.

1490
04:11:17.030 --> 04:11:23.619
City of El Cerrito: I don't have an issue with this from the standpoint of risk management and the city attorney and the council.

1491
04:11:23.830 --> 04:11:29.799
City of El Cerrito: Having to make a decision from a risk management perspective.

1492
04:11:30.550 --> 04:11:35.339
City of El Cerrito: But this has become somewhat of a legal cottage industry.

1493
04:11:35.430 --> 04:11:39.200
City of El Cerrito: We saw this was the West Contra Costa Unified School District.

1494
04:11:39.230 --> 04:11:55.970
City of El Cerrito: We saw it also with the city of Richmond. But what I will say is here in the city of El Cerrito, I believe we have a very unique set of circumstances, being a small community, and if you look at the very composition of our city council right now.

1495
04:11:56.110 --> 04:11:59.569
City of El Cerrito: So I would be one to really question

1496
04:11:59.740 --> 04:12:04.519
City of El Cerrito: The merits of what's taking place from a legal point of view.

1497
04:12:05.430 --> 04:12:08.240
City of El Cerrito: I don't want to use the word money grab.

1498
04:12:08.340 --> 04:12:15.459
City of El Cerrito: But I'll use the word money grab from the standpoint of what is transpiring.

1499
04:12:16.350 --> 04:12:20.380
City of El Cerrito: So I would like to offer a suggestion

1500
04:12:20.970 --> 04:12:22.989
City of El Cerrito: to the City Council and the staff.

1501
04:12:23.370 --> 04:12:29.219
City of El Cerrito: Do what you have to do from the standpoint of risk mitigation.

1502
04:12:29.370 --> 04:12:33.900
City of El Cerrito: So it doesn't put us in a position where we have to spend an inordinate amount of money

1503
04:12:34.430 --> 04:12:44.660
City of El Cerrito: But also, I would like to see this city council not just knuckle under, And roll over.

1504
04:12:44.910 --> 04:12:47.879
City of El Cerrito: We have to play defense right now.

1505
04:12:47.980 --> 04:12:52.860
City of El Cerrito: But because of the nature of what's going on, I'd like to see two things happen.

1506
04:12:52.990 --> 04:12:53.940
City of El Cerrito: One.

1507
04:12:54.380 --> 04:13:05.020
City of El Cerrito: I think some things need to happen on the legislative level as it pertains to the California Voting Rights Act, which Governor Gray Davis signed in 2002.

1508
04:13:05.140 --> 04:13:09.710
City of El Cerrito: In 2016, the Safe Harbor component was included.

1509
04:13:09.950 --> 04:13:21.170
City of El Cerrito: So I think maybe something needs to happen from a legislative point of view to take the financial incentive out of it for those who seek to do this just purely to profit on it.

1510
04:13:21.740 --> 04:13:26.910
City of El Cerrito: And the other thing I think we should do as a community, as a city council.

1511
04:13:27.170 --> 04:13:29.830
City of El Cerrito: It's just that, let it be well known

1512
04:13:30.180 --> 04:13:37.120
City of El Cerrito: What the composition of our council is, the diversity in this community, and almost shame those

1513
04:13:37.610 --> 04:13:39.360
City of El Cerrito: Who would come forward.

1514
04:13:40.570 --> 04:13:56.260
City of El Cerrito: on a money grab, especially when, in my estimation, it doesn't apply here in the city of El Cerrito. I did look at the statistics, and I know it's a tough statistical game, but I think we ought to flip the script and put them on defense.

1515
04:13:56.460 --> 04:13:57.349
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

1516
04:13:58.930 --> 04:14:04.009
City of El Cerrito: Mayor, that concludes our request to speak on this item. Okay, any final thoughts? I'll start over here.

1517
04:14:05.540 --> 04:14:08.589
City of El Cerrito: How about over here? Councilmember Martiano.

1518
04:14:08.800 --> 04:14:12.390
City of El Cerrito: Thank you, Mayor. Thank you.

1519
04:14:12.880 --> 04:14:16.650
City of El Cerrito: City Attorney for the presentation, and…

1520
04:14:17.620 --> 04:14:30.819
City of El Cerrito: Yeah, we are being held over a barrel on this one, and my biggest concern going to districts is that, you know, we'll be, you know, balkanized so that there's not

1521
04:14:31.010 --> 04:14:37.660
City of El Cerrito: an approach where we are really thinking about what's good for the entire city. We'll have, you know.

1522
04:14:38.160 --> 04:14:46.829
City of El Cerrito: Every district kind of… acting for itself, and I think we're too small for that, and I really,

1523
04:14:47.020 --> 04:15:02.459
City of El Cerrito: very disappointed that a resident of El Cerrito would choose to do this to us, because it's going to be very expensive just to do the mapping anyways, not just, you know, legal fees and, you know, if there is litigation, but, you know.

1524
04:15:03.180 --> 04:15:20.680
City of El Cerrito: I think that the fact that we have to amend our budget so that 11th hour, we have to, you know, schedule a zillion extra meetings to make this happen. We need to get, you know, track people down and get input for this at a time of year where people are generally pretty busy.

1525
04:15:20.800 --> 04:15:25.280
City of El Cerrito: So I think that this is just,

1526
04:15:25.450 --> 04:15:30.520
City of El Cerrito: really horrible, and I wish we could sue.

1527
04:15:31.180 --> 04:15:34.130
City of El Cerrito: And I know we can't, so I will…

1528
04:15:34.920 --> 04:15:37.549
City of El Cerrito: Grip my teeth. Thank you. Mayor Pro Tem, go ahead.

1529
04:15:38.710 --> 04:15:41.620
City of El Cerrito: Absolutely agree with all of that,

1530
04:15:42.580 --> 04:15:55.330
City of El Cerrito: it's… we don't really have a choice, because we don't have the funds to… to back up going to court over this, and we know everybody else is lost, and we probably would too. But it's… it's a little bit…

1531
04:15:55.830 --> 04:16:02.280
City of El Cerrito: Ironic, because the intention of the law was to, you know, protect voting rights.

1532
04:16:02.280 --> 04:16:20.839
City of El Cerrito: And ultimately, we're… we're gonna end up having probably less competitive elections. We're probably gonna have a lot of elections that aren't… don't have any competition. If you look at the last several elections, in our last election when we were up, you know, there were…

1533
04:16:20.840 --> 04:16:36.559
City of El Cerrito: 3 seats open, and only 5 candidates, so if there'd been 3 districts, at least one of those districts would have been uncontested, and maybe 2 of them would have been uncontested, so we're gonna see more. It's actually gonna give voters

1534
04:16:36.560 --> 04:16:43.469
City of El Cerrito: fewer choices, and I don't know if this El Cerrito resident really thought through what they were doing, but it's gonna mean

1535
04:16:43.470 --> 04:16:59.499
City of El Cerrito: There's just gonna be people who can stay on the council forever with no accountability, which is the reality when you have systems like this in such a small city, because to find multiple people within 5,000 people that want to be on the city council is… it might be…

1536
04:16:59.500 --> 04:17:04.980
City of El Cerrito: tougher than this person thinks. So, it's very unfortunate. I wish we didn't have to do it, and I…

1537
04:17:05.000 --> 04:17:12.370
City of El Cerrito: I especially agree. It's very disheartening that they weren't willing to allow us to actually take the time to do

1538
04:17:12.370 --> 04:17:27.069
City of El Cerrito: a thorough process, and to our residents, who are now going to be forced to peer interested in this, to come to a whole bunch of hearings in a very short period of time, and to tune in very quickly, I am very sorry. I wish we didn't have to do it this way, and could take

1539
04:17:27.070 --> 04:17:32.560
City of El Cerrito: our time and do it the right way, but it is what it is. We're being forced to do it, and so…

1540
04:17:32.560 --> 04:17:41.970
City of El Cerrito: If you're ready for a motion, I'll move the item. Sure, I just want to say, I completely agree with my colleagues on what you just mentioned.

1541
04:17:42.440 --> 04:17:59.799
City of El Cerrito: Jeffrey Wright, former president of our chamber, I hear you, and I wish we could do something. We do not have the funds to sue. I would love to do that. Maybe we can talk to our Attorney General about attorneys taking advantage of

1542
04:18:00.020 --> 04:18:08.499
City of El Cerrito: And making bogus, accusations like this when, I truly believe that,

1543
04:18:08.500 --> 04:18:25.370
City of El Cerrito: you look at the… our body of our council, and you look at, when we get to, when we have to change this to district elections, we won't have this diversity, what we have now, district, you know, citywide. So.

1544
04:18:25.430 --> 04:18:30.720
City of El Cerrito: This is something that I'm very, very concerned about. They were talking about Latino.

1545
04:18:30.720 --> 04:18:47.019
City of El Cerrito: you know, in Latinos in our community, which is very small compared to other communities, next to us. We do have a large Asian American population, so our demographics is very similar to

1546
04:18:47.020 --> 04:18:57.219
City of El Cerrito: the Walnut Creeks and La Morindas and, and, Danvilles and San Ramones. And, so,

1547
04:18:57.250 --> 04:19:16.889
City of El Cerrito: truly, I do not believe this pertains to El Cerrito, but I see that, someone's trying to, shake us down for funds. So… One thing to add to that. Yeah, just a second when I'm done. I would just… I'm not done yet. So, so one of the things I want to make sure is that,

1548
04:19:16.980 --> 04:19:18.709
City of El Cerrito: You know, we,

1549
04:19:18.750 --> 04:19:27.300
City of El Cerrito: We need to let the press know about this, and we need to get the word out, that communities like ours are being threatened.

1550
04:19:27.300 --> 04:19:45.089
City of El Cerrito: by these bogus lawsuits, by, and they don't have, the guts to even tell us who this resident is. So, the resident who is probably watching us here in this room or on TV, you're gonna make things worse for, the city, and I'm,

1551
04:19:45.090 --> 04:19:50.640
City of El Cerrito: Sorry that, you're playing dirty politics like this, so… Go ahead.

1552
04:19:50.640 --> 04:20:11.990
City of El Cerrito: Well, thank you, Mayor. The only thing that I was gonna say, I was gonna encourage those that are watching, and especially those who haven't already read the letter, which is a part of the presentation in the packet, I want you to definitely go back and read it, because it referenced specifically the race in 2022, and I'm not just saying this because I was elected in 2022. However.

1553
04:20:12.320 --> 04:20:26.389
City of El Cerrito: it is notable that it talks… it points to that particular election that elected a out-Asian-American man to the council and elected the first Black lesbian man in the history of our state. It's using that particular race

1554
04:20:26.390 --> 04:20:34.630
City of El Cerrito: to try and create this issue in a city where actually the majority of voters, as it says in its own letter, are non-Hispanic.

1555
04:20:34.630 --> 04:20:58.679
City of El Cerrito: white voters. So the fact that those non-Hispanic white voters elected an out Asian man and a Black lesbian woman, it's incensing. I do… what I do think is gonna happen in this process, we are going to see a lot of things from a lot of parts of our community that are gonna be very uncomfortable. But I do encourage people to go back and read the letter. I do second what the mayor said as far as

1556
04:20:58.710 --> 04:21:12.899
City of El Cerrito: speaking out and speaking to the present. Thank you, Jeffrey Wright, for bringing that up, because just because we can't sue doesn't mean we don't have the power to actually make the issue widely known and make people actually pay attention to what's happening in a city like El Cerrito.

1557
04:21:13.920 --> 04:21:16.129
City of El Cerrito: Thank you. Do I have a motion to approve?

1558
04:21:16.750 --> 04:21:24.779
City of El Cerrito: Second. Okay, we have a motion by, Mayor Pro Tem Saltzman, and second by, Councilmember Motayama. All in favor?

1559
04:21:24.920 --> 04:21:31.770
City of El Cerrito: Aye. Aye. Any nays, abstention, motion passes. Thank you. So next is,

1560
04:21:32.530 --> 04:21:37.229
City of El Cerrito: regional boards, do I have any updates?

1561
04:21:37.830 --> 04:21:38.980
City of El Cerrito: Yes, go ahead.

1562
04:21:39.960 --> 04:21:45.079
City of El Cerrito: Go to the Urban Forest Committee… sorry, Urban Forest Committee on April 13th.

1563
04:21:45.240 --> 04:21:48.680
City of El Cerrito: The Economic Development Committee meeting was canceled this month.

1564
04:21:48.830 --> 04:21:56.500
City of El Cerrito: Went to the West County Integrated Waste Management Recycle More meeting on April 19th. I'm also part of a subcommittee there that's met two more times to…

1565
04:21:56.670 --> 04:22:01.889
City of El Cerrito: Establish financial controls, and review the audit, and financial record keeping.

1566
04:22:02.550 --> 04:22:17.900
City of El Cerrito: And I continue to have my meetings with constituents. I typically have them on the first and third Saturdays of the month at El Cerrito Natural Foods. However, this last month or so, I've done them more often than that, and often once on Sunday, and then often on other Saturdays.

1567
04:22:17.930 --> 04:22:23.009
City of El Cerrito: And if anybody wants to meet, feel free to send me an email, and I'll send you a calendar invite and sign you up.

1568
04:22:23.120 --> 04:22:23.920
City of El Cerrito: Thank you.

1569
04:22:24.610 --> 04:22:31.499
City of El Cerrito: I'll give my update real fast. I did attend, the stationary source meeting for the

1570
04:22:31.650 --> 04:22:33.829
City of El Cerrito: Bay Area Air District.

1571
04:22:34.570 --> 04:22:47.849
City of El Cerrito: I'm hoping residents will attend my meeting coming up, the first Wednesday of May, where we will deal with, the nine Bay Area counties. We'll be dealing with,

1572
04:22:48.170 --> 04:23:05.069
City of El Cerrito: rule changes and rule updates dealing with electrification. So, you know, this is what we need to do, and we need to get to lower GHDs. And I did speak about that at the last, at the San Francisco

1573
04:23:05.110 --> 04:23:24.419
City of El Cerrito: Climate Week. But I also want to say we do pay the highest rates when it comes to gasoline and electrical costs. It's going to be even higher if CARB gets their way. They're not… they're being anti-business right now. If our refineries leave in Contra Costa, Contra Costa is in trouble.

1574
04:23:24.480 --> 04:23:28.220
City of El Cerrito: And we get a lot of tax dollars from,

1575
04:23:28.620 --> 04:23:34.850
City of El Cerrito: our industry. And, what they're trying to do is, make,

1576
04:23:34.850 --> 04:23:56.039
City of El Cerrito: refining, done elsewhere, like in Asia. And we all know what's going on in the Middle East. We know what's going on and what could be done in Asia, where we still have the same enemies. They're playing war games right now in the Taiwan Straits. So this is a national security issue. We do need to have our oil

1577
04:23:56.040 --> 04:24:07.380
City of El Cerrito: refined here in California, where we do this the safest, cleanest way. And, I was getting debates by ideologues, and I know these ideologues love

1578
04:24:07.380 --> 04:24:30.840
City of El Cerrito: to go on vacation and drive their giant SUVs, but the truth is, most people are hurting right now with the high cost of energy. As President of the League of Cities, our stance for the League is cities demand affordable energy prices. And I know getting to solar will get us there, but this was never to get rid of big oil.

1579
04:24:30.840 --> 04:24:49.630
City of El Cerrito: Never. So people still need to fly. You know, we don't want to take long bus rides again, like in the past. So I did speak at Climate Week. Tomorrow, we'll be, heading out and driving out. They're taking the train to Sacramento. I'll be there all this week. I'm doing a gubernatorial

1580
04:24:49.630 --> 04:24:59.830
City of El Cerrito: panel with, Javier Becerra, with Antonio Villagosa, with Tony Thurman, and, possibly,

1581
04:24:59.950 --> 04:25:09.910
City of El Cerrito: the candidate named Hilton. So, we'll see how that goes. So, a lot of work to do in the Assembly, and we'll be lobbying

1582
04:25:09.910 --> 04:25:34.899
City of El Cerrito: The executive committee will be lobbying with leadership on both sides, and I know my colleagues here in the Council will be meeting with, our assembly members and senators in the area, so that's my update. Any updates from you? Okay. Thank you, Mayor. I'll go really fast. On April 8th, I attended the ABAC Housing Committee meeting. We had a… we are going to be convening

1583
04:25:34.900 --> 04:25:38.989
City of El Cerrito: stakeholders for BAFA, the Bay Area Housing Finance Agencies.

1584
04:25:38.990 --> 04:25:54.840
City of El Cerrito: potential bond in 2028. On April 10th, I attended the meeting with staff, with CAL FIRE to build relationships and to prepare to apply for the next grant cycle. And on April 13, I attended the closed session special council meeting. Thank you.

1585
04:25:54.900 --> 04:26:05.399
City of El Cerrito: Okay, we are adjourned at, 1028. Our next City Council meeting will be on March, May 5th, 6 p.m. Thank you.